Mellow Mushroom

Pizza was delicious. The venue left a lot to be desired. I have dined at Mellow Mushroom in other states this one definitely needs updated but I still give it 4 stars because the Holy Shit. & Karma Cosmic was fantastic

I live right around the corner and we usually order our bi-​weekly pizza here. The pizza itself is really good. Everything else… Not as expected. On several occasions we ordered pizza over the phone and come to pick it up 30 minutes later it still isn’t ready, when the ETA is 15minutes (don’t order on Wednesday or whatever game day is cause you won’t even find a parking spot).
One evening we ordered and my husband went to pick it up and they never put his order in over the phone lost it or whatever. He had to wait there an hour!
Last time we ordered last week we got one of the special pizzas with no sausage no bacon… But there was both on it when we got home.
The girls who answer the phones have attitudes if you don’t know your order asap. They get pretty inpatient. When we dine in though they are quite nice.
Would I order here again? Maybe sometimes but I think twice before ordering.

Pizza was very delicious! They had forgotten pepperoni on one of the pizzas but it was still delicious. I would definitely choose this place over other pizza places anytime. We got carryout.

Despite Mellow Mushroom being known for pizza, they also have good salads. Variety of food is great. Gluten free pizza options too. Have had the gluten free pizza before and it’s pretty good. Had the Chef salad this go around. It was tasty as always. I like that they have the choice of large or small portion salads. Server was pleasant. Bathroom was clean. Will continue to come here.

This was my first bad experience at a mellow mushroom. I’m not sure if it’s a franchise, or what, but the food was definitely subpar. I ordered the 2 slice lunch special, one pepperoni and one extra cheese. They both came out cold and too crunchy, like they had been baked twice and left out to get cold. The slice that was supposed to have extra cheese had less cheese than the pepperoni slice. The sauce tasted like canned tomato sauce with no spices or seasoning added. We got a cheesy bread and I had to add salt, pepper, and parmesan cheese just to make the «marinara» sauce edible. The manager came and spoke with me about the food and he was very helpful. We will be back to give this mellow mushroom another try, just maybe not during the lunch rush.

I love this place ! Please note that the folks at MM make your order fresh. Not much is pre-​made there so be prepared for a «reasonable» wait time. In my mind I can totally justify the wait for the quality food that you receive. Also keep in mind that you pay for what you get but prices are in line with other higher end pizza places.
Comfortable atmosphere
Clean restrooms
Nice staff
Great food.
We ordered various items to include salads, bread sticks, calzone, pizzas.
Salads were fresh with fresh items and good dressing options.
Bread sticks hot and fresh.
Calzone and pizza were cooked to order and great. Huge portions and the crust is amazing. They do have gluten free crust if requested.
Overall just a good experience. I wish we are here more often and we are going to make an effort to do that.

I love this place great people and I always feel comfortable witch is very important ti me in public eating ouy thanks guys

So loud! Maybe just getting too old:0) we go here pretty frequently and every time have a hard time having a conversation. Very crowded and even the tables can’t seem to hold everyone’s food. Now for the positive– awesome food. Every. Single. Time. Staff is always friendly and welcoming.

It was just ok nothing exciting

This place is great! Watch out for Wednesday as it’s very crowded around 7 for trivia. The food is solid and the wait staff busts butt. Pretty good prices too

I haven’t dined in, but I do love that I can order pizza there with my friends even though I’m vegan. Yep, there are vegan options. I typically always order a gluten free crust, veg out with kalamata olives, vegan cheese (daiya) and tempeh and it never fails to delight me.

Great food

Had a group of 20 visit today and it couldn’t have been anymore perfect! Travis is the bomb and that’s all I really have to say. Been coming here for years and have yet to be disappointed! Loyal customer for life!

Stopped at Mellow Mushroom yesterday for my best friend’s birthday dinner. The restaurant was packed, though we had room outside on their heated patio. It was cold outside, so it was perfect. Our server was the wonderful Omawum, she was polite and very professional and took good care of us. While here, the only complaint that I have is that even though they were extremely busy on a weekend in the «Back-​of-​the-​House» they have to be used to it by now, it took 65 minutes for our pizzas. Maybe they only have two ovens, if that is the case, they could use a 3^rd. I would come here again as their pizza is really good and I loved their Calzone, one of the best that I had in Atlanta.
Just please, get the food out faster. 65 minutes is a long time to wait for pizza. If you come at 7pm, expect to wait, so order salad as they only take about 15 minutes.
Omawum did a great job, thanks for taking good care of us and for the birthday ice cream and brownie.
[Review #276] (Thirty Sixth Review of 2015)

The food was delicious! We ordered a wing appetizer which was so tasty! The pizza was the best we have had yet. The dough was fresh and lots of cheese.

My family and I have been frequenting this place for over a decade. The menu has changed over the years, but the food has remained consistently good. Great atmosphere, great food, and great staff

Good pizza and good beer!

I decided to kick back at my childhood favorite pizza joint for my 18^th birthday dinner with my best friends. This location was nothing less than perfect!
Though they don’t take reservations, I called ahead to tell them that I was planning on bringing a large party. They told me everything I needed to know to including the best time to arrive.
As soon as I walked up the hostess stand, I was greeted with a polite smile from the hostess. The smiles continued throughout the night; the service was fast, efficient, and respectful! They had everything set up for me in a timely manner and were eager to please my entire large party!
The food, as always, was fantastic. I am obsessed with creating pizzas and they have SO many fantastic options! I recommend a Pesto base with regular cheese! Overall, ALL the pizzas we ordered were delicious; we took every single slice we didn’t finish home with us!
The heated patio is the Real Deal. There is no skimping on the heat level; it is perfectly comfortable in addition to being perfectly eclectic!
Overall, great service, great food, great atmosphere, reasonable pricing, and cool merchandise (they have t-​shirts)! I will DEFINITELY be visiting Mellow again for more enchanting pizza with friends.

Just what you want: great food, fast and nice people. Ask the manager Greg to show you the trick he does with his toes!

I haven’t had mellow mushrooms since the location on 78 in snellville closed down oh so long ago (which is now the dublin pub and grill).
I miss the hand tossed pizza and customizable toppings galore that you can put on there.
Came here with coworkers on a chilly thursday and they reserved the outside covered seating for us. After a while of waiting for our entire party, we requested the heaters to be turned on, which they did. It wasn’t a problem but when tables opened up on the inside, they accommodated us well inside. Which was nice but the draft from either door was pretty chilly though. There should be something to block that wind chill from coming in.
We all ordered 3 pizzas: mighty meaty, maui wowie, and the mellowterranean. Of the three, I would have to say the maui wowie is my favorite. But I do love pizza that has meat and pineapples on it. So maybe a bit biast but that’s just my personal preference.
I like that they have a wide variety of choices and also the option of just building my own. A large pizza easily shares between 3 – 4 people depending on how hungry everyone is.
Overall, people are nice here, establishment isn’t that big but it’s not a problem if you have a party of 10+ as long as you’re ok sitting out on the patio.
If you’re new in the area, the restaurant is located a good bit on 78 past hwy 124 so be on the lookout, right before a shell gas station. I really thought I was going to hit loganville and miss this place all together.