Piazza Orsillo

Piazza Orsillo has fantastic food and pizza the best around. The service is friendly and the restaurant is very clean. My company has ordered from them for a number of years and the food and the service is consistent. Large selection of pizza to choose from and many choices of other Italian specialties.
Salads are fresh and large. they don’t skimp on anything. You truly get your monies worth. Portions are great too. Homemade everything. you can tell.
Don’t waste your time and money anywhere else. Outstanding!!!

Had the grandma pie. One of the best can’t recomend it more. So far we’ve eaten there three times and the good and service was excellent. One of our, favorite places for a non special occasion place

Grabbed a slice with peppers and onions for takeout. It was good — sauce was tasty and good amount of cheese. Crust could have been a little more toasted but not bad at all. A little too much oil but other than that, I enjoyed the slice. Place had quick service as well which was nice. I’ll be going back to try out some other things on the menu!

Their calzone with «the works» is cooked perfectly, not doughy and not over done either… And enough to feed me for four days! I typically get take out so can’t personally comment on their sit-​down service. It’s BYOB and I’ve heard from others that the servers and quick and friendly.

best grandma slice around, always a large selection of pies to choose from. They accept cards w/​no minimum, and their cannolis are SO GOOD.

I’ve had pizza all over the country so I’m pretty particular about the quality, and always pleasantly surprised when my expectations are exceeded. I stopped by one afternoon for a few slices and found the pizza quite good — crispy crust, tasty sauce. A few days later I had dinner with my wife in their small, but clean, dining room in the back of the shop. My wife had calzone and I had pasta — basic litmus tests of Southern Italian comfort food. We enjoyed both. Prices very reasonable. Service good and friendly. We have recommended this place to friends looking for a casual Italian restaurant with good food and prices.

Best food ever. Period. Everything I have ever had here is delicious and after years I am still ordering on a regular basis. Love this place!

Parking lot stinks.
Place is great.
Friendly workers.
Quick service.
Clean.
Yummy pizza love the meat lovers and buffalo chicken.
Decent price for quality and quantity.
Outdoor and indoor seating.
Byob.
Closed on Sundays.
Nice place. Local.
They have different deals certain days but its cash only if u do deals.
Never had a bad meal there and will continue to patronize.

Home cooking in a family atmosphere. We had baked lasagna, gnochhi with shrimp in a cream sauce, jalapena poppers for an appetizer along with some homemade chicken noodle soup. Loved everything and the owners came around joking with the customers and checking to make sure everything was ok. Friendly and helpful service too. You might find more gourmet Italian food elsewhere but the combination of good food and the friendly, family atmosphere is hard to beat. BYOB keeps the cost reasonable too. And we had plenty of leftovers to take home. They are closed Saturday night and Sunday, a real sign of a family business, some things are more important than money.
They also make great cold subs for a great price. We’ve bought them a few times for picnics and parties.
A neighbor recently bemoaned the lack of restaurants in the area, meaning places like TGI Friday’s or Applebees or something like that. Personally I hope they never show up. I’ll alwayd take a family place like this. ‘Cheers’ in Somerset, for those of you who remember that show.

I ordered a pizza by phone and while I am a fan, the young lady that took my order was less than stellar! She confirmed the order twice on the phone. However, when I arrived my order was not correct. She offered to correct it, but that is the whole reason I called ahead. More mature staff with more attention to detail would be a great improvement. The pizza is good but if you happen to call it in, it might be worth your while to call again to confirm before making a trip.

I have loved this place since it was Dimeglios. Have met with the owners a few times and has to be my favorite pizza in town. The only down side is they are closed sundays. Garlic knots are also very good
Sicilian is ok, I prefer to go with a cheese pizza and a sausage peppers and onion one. Zeppoli’s weren’t my favorite

Best Pizza/​Italian restaurant in Somerset NJ hands down. If your from out of town and don’t know where to go to eat defiantly come here! The owner is super friendly as well as the staff.

Went to lunch here today with my co worker. The pizza is excellent but the pepperoni roll like my Unilocal friends would say (Awesome). Try the buffalo chicken pizza as well — very good. The atmosphere is very nice and mostly corporate. A great place for lunch.

I’ve been coming here 8 yrasrs. Very nice pizza and other hot subs. Merigano style food. I love it. Quality of dish and price, it’s perfect match, you never go wrong with this place. Also nice friendly people over the counter.

I really cannot believe they actually delivered this pizza to my house. Needless to say I will never be ordering from there again. Seriously the box was dripping with grease. Please refer to the picture I posted.

Their pizza quality varies, but on the days where it is good, it is one of the better places in the area. I’m not sure if they have different cheese suppliers or if different people in-​house make the cheese, but that seems to be the main difference that I notice.
The Grandma pie is probably the best pizza there, but beware the kids they currently have working there have no clue how long to reheat it for so you’ll need to check if it’s cold before leaving with a to-​go order. The fact that they consistently seem unaware that pizza isn’t heated when they serve it makes me a bit nervous about their awareness of other food safety rules (like how long it can sit out), but I’m hoping the cooks in the back are more seasoned and enforce those rules.
They are closed on Sundays, which is not out of the ordinary for independent places here.

Unlike my husband, I grew up in Texas with the famous pizza chains such as Pizza Hut, Dominoes, & Papa johns. But he is born and raised in the Northeast where pizza is the specialty.
I loved every bit of it. All the crusts were crispy up to the center of the Pizza, and it was a nice balance of toppings on top of the dough/​crust. I specifically loved the sausage and how it was more shredded than cut up. The garlic knots were top notch in my opinion.
My husband, however, thought that there could have been a tad more salt to nearly all of the pizza. While he thought the same with the crisp and balance of it, the taste just didn’t stand out as much as he had expected. Although, he did like the garlic knots
FYI, the salads were awesome!

I thought to take a break from my usual pizzeria and try this one and I immediately regretted it. I called for delivery and the lady who took my order was just rude and unfriendly but I figured, fine as long as I get my food. My food came and my spaghetti literally had no sauce on it and all the nooses were stuck together. Of course it tasted like sauce less spaghetti and I debated on whether I should just throw it away. I ordered garlic knots as well which were soggy and drenched in olive oil and were inedible so those went in the garbage unfortunately. Never ordering from here again I will stick with Lubrano’s because I was so disappointed.

Not impressed with the pizza or service. Both were subpar. The pizza was greasy and tasteless.
Also, no AC on a hot day? The door was open to let air in (stifling humid air) and a ton of bugs were flying around.

We bought paint next door and had to wait for them to make it, so we had 15 minutes to burn. My girl and I decided to stop by this Pizzeria, and we are glad we did. The place is very neatly decorated. The lighting is great too. We were not planning on staying long, so we ordered a quick snack of mozzarella sticks with extra marinara sauce, and chicken fingers with bbq sauce.
The mozz sticks was bla BAM! The marinara sauce it came with was nice and hot, and has that tang that im looking for. The chicken fingers was nice and crispy on the outside and meaty on the inside. I think our favorite part of this meal was the barbecue sauce. Its the same bbq sauce that we have been looking for all our life. Its the same one as the pizzeria in Hoboken called Impostos. The bbq sauce just sealed the deal for us. I cant wait to come back here and buy a bucket of this sauce. I hope they sell it to us by the bucket.