Marco’s Pizza

I don’t know what it is about this place, but I prefer it over Domino’s, Pizza Hut, Pizza Pit, and other such pizza chains. I have no problem with their crust. I think it’s better than what Pizza Hut has been putting out for the last thirty years. Topping selection isn’t great, but at least it’s focused like the rest of the menu. If you want to throw everything and the kitchen sink on your pizza, you might want to look elsewhere.
Got a salad one time. It was as good as you expect from this sort of place, i.e. a pile of lettuce with what amounts to pizza toppings. I will say the service here seems a step above certain other chains. As in, the employees don’t look so angry and depressed. Their service for both carryout and delivery has been pretty good in my experience. Overall, this has become my go-​to pizza place for cheap pies, especially when they’re cheaper than Pizza Hut or Dominos, even without using a coupon.

The pizza is fine, pretty much like any other fast food pizza delivery place. Service is THE WORST. Employees are completely inattentive to customers and if you order a pizza in person they never give you any idea when your pizza is done. What is the point of requiring a phone number if they don’t at least call you when the pizza is ready? Not worth it.

The pizza was very good and the guy who took my order was friendly. I will order from them again

Our favorite delivery pizza in Sun Prairie. Wings are meh. Get the Old World Pepperoni instead of the regular pepperoni.

The past 11 years that I’ve lived in Sun Prairie, I have had pizza from every joint that has opened, is currently open or closed, and I will say, Marcos is one of the best I’ve had. I ordered off the door hanger, I believe they put them on the doors in my neighborhood just a couple days ago. My mother wanted pizza too and since she just lives across the street I ordered the 2 2 topping medium pizzas. I had pineapple and pepperoni; and my mother wanted fresh mushrooms and black olives. unfortunately Marcos has canned mushrooms. So she ended up having onions and black olives. We both had the thin crust. The flavor of the pizza was very very good, the sauce had a bit of a sweetness to it, which ik found very appealing. So next time you order pizza or are in Sun Prairie I highly recommend trying out Marco’s Pizza, you will not regret it!

I love this place. Dominos serves an uncooked zah, Hut still adds extra grease and never grts an order right. This place, in 5 orders has been spot on… and on time.

Crust is awesome, good flavor in sauce too. Definitely recommend getting all the crust toppers. Pizza reheats great also, IF you have any left over.

I have had their pizza 3 times. Thin crust is very good, which we had first and third time. 2^nd time, we had regular crust, which I thought was lame in taste and texture. Thin crust doesnt suffer from sogginess in middle, like many thin crusts do. They dont have wheat or other whole grain.
The offered crust dust (seasoning and cheese blend they offer to sprinkle on your crust) is yummy. I dont remember what they actually call it… crust dust works for me.
Toppings and sauce were run of the mill /​moderately creative. Chicken, artichoke hearts, pineapple etc. Not Glass Nickle or Neapolitan style creative, like i often like.
The overall result was very good, though I’d only order thin crust.
They offer a movie/​pizza delivery combo. You can call and order a pizza and a movie rental from Family Video to be delivered to your door ! Not sure how you go about choosing a movie selection, but im sure they have something worked out.
If youre doing pickup, you can place your pizza order right through a window in the wall between Family Video and Marco’s and browse movies until they let you know through the window your pizza’s ready !
The one time I was there onsite, they were really nice and friendly. I also ordered the cheddar to be left off my pizza and they got it right — only mozzarella.

Marco’s pizza shares the same building as Family Video. In fact, when you walk into Family Video you can see an ordering window in their wall that connects to Marco’s. It really is the whole «pizza and a movie» idea in action.
We tried a couple of their pizzas last night, and they were pretty good. I’d say they are on par with Papa John’s, Definitely better than Pizza Hut, and certainly better than Little Caesar’s and Domino’s. Prices were pretty good too. Two large 14 inch pizzas, one was a specialty, for 23 bucks total.
Their crusts come with the free option of adding parmesan, roma, or garlic seasonings. They also have salads, subs, meatball bakes, and the typical cheesy bread sticks.
With the addition of Marco’s, Sun Prairie now has 11 pizza joints. Why does a town of 30,000 need 11 different pizza places? They don’t. Domino’s, Little Caesar’s, and Pizza Hut, you are the weakest link, goodbye!