Which Wich

After you’ve read all the employees friends dumb reviews, believe me when I say this place is a total rip off! $ 7.50 for a sample sized sandwich! Way less filling than a 6″ sub at Subway. The food is not that good. The Philly Cheese steak was bland and boring; barely any cheese. This place is horrible.

This sandwich shop is fantastically unique. You walk in to a large wall of bags. Choose the bag that matches your taste for the day (turkey, seafood, veggie, breakfast, etc). Choose the size. You then mark the bag with all of your requests. Your sandwich could be made on white or wheat or in a bowl (think salad) or lettuce wrap. Hot or cold. Add your selection of cheeses, veggies, and toppings. There is a large selections of toppings — so each trip could be a completely different combination.
The menu also offers kids options and vegan options.
They also offer shakes, cookies, and cookie sandwiches for a dessert. The shake was thick and full of toppings. A good add to my healthy sandwich.
I love the customizable options at this place. The vast selection and fresh ingredients offer a great variety to meet any taste. Give it a try!

A little pricey for my lunching tastes, but the thanksgiving themed sandwich I had was very good. I couldn’t find info on sandwich sizes, maybe I missed where it was listed and I ordered a large. Thankfully they made it wrong and realized it before they gave it to me, because it was huge! When they remade it I asked for a smaller size and they had no problem refunding me and charging me for the smaller size.

This sub shop is conveniently located by the woodmans, Costco, and target in Sun Prairie. They offer a reward card so if you plan on coming often, utilize this to earn free subs (who doesn’t love free).
The sandwiches are completely customizable. You can either build your own or they have prearranged choices for you. When you walk in, you will go to the wall with all the bags, choose the bag with your meat choice and complete your order on the bag accordingly. You take your filled out bag to the cash register to complete your order.
The staff is always very friendly and it doesn’t take long to get your meal. I’m not generally a sub person but I feel they really step it up with all the options they provide to customize your sandwich.

I have to write this update on Which Wich, because I’ve been here a few additional times now since my first visit.
–They’ve updated their rewards club/​punch cards which is great. We frequent Which Which often before or after getting groceries, so it all adds up quickly for free subs.
–The friendly employees do not go unnoticed. Every time we’ve been there we are greeted, asked if we have any questions, and overall see employees working hard whatever the task is they are doing. I know this is a fast food place, but I’ve noticed that the young workers really do a great job!

They’re doing things a bit different at Which Wich. If Subway and Chipotle had a baby, it would be Which Wich. You walk in and are jobbing-​it with an array of bags, pens, numbers and choices. It can be so overwhelming that they have a dedicated employee who welcomes you and asks if you’ve been through the assembly line before. Me? Oh, I’ve done the run-​through (but secretly need to read the board each time I arrive). But today was different. Today was my free birthday wich, and I was on a mission!
Turkey Club time! Like their father (Chipotle), you choose a genre: The sandwich with bread, bowlwich or lettucewich. Then, like Mama Subway, you choose the fixins. But, this is where they stand out. With creative innards like crushed potato chips, crispy onion strings, or crushed blue cheese … they’re rockin’ the sandwich! Good stuff, and slightly different each time.
Now for the cost. In my humble opinion, a sandwich is exclusively the goods between bread. That’s it; there is no bowl or lettuce wrap. These are many things, but a sandwich they are not. So, a 7″ sub is $ 5.50; a 10.5″ sub is $ 8.25; and the monster 14″ behemoth is $ 11 bucks. Perhaps a little pricey. But, not too bad, given the amount of flexibility in the sandwich. However, their rewards point system works on the number of subs purchased. Now, I’m no math wizard, but two 7″ subs seems to cost the same as one 14″. To me, the 14″ is much more reasonable (and attractive) if under $ 10 — not to mention the rewards points.
The taste was — dare I say — better than Subway? Oh yes, better than the chain-​o-​matic sandwich shops. I’m a fan of putting everything and the kitchen sink between the fresh bread, toasting the whole thing, and enjoying it with good company. Top the whole thing off with a freshly baked cookie… And like an elderly Arnold Schwarzenegger, I’ll be back! Lunch is served.

This is a good place to grab a sandwich in the booming area of Sun Prairie. There is a unique concept of ordering on the bag, which the employees are nothing but friendly to help out and explain.
An advantage of this place is that their are a ton of options. I usually stick with the tried and true turkey club. The quality of the items taste pretty good, and I haven’t had any poor experiences.
One area of concern is that the employees need to do a better job in cleaning up the restaurant. I feel like each time I go, I need to wipe down the table before we sit. The second is that the price point is on the higher side of things.

A little pricey for what they offer but they have a lot of options which which (intentional) is nice. A step above the other build your own sandwiches place with some healthier varieties.
Not food related but they’re seating is very weird and not meant for you to hang out and chit chat for a while as they are REALLY uncomfortable chairs!

There isn’t too much to be said about a chain but ill do my best to make it as interesting and accurate as possible. Now as far as this location goes, its a great location for those who live in Sun Prairie. It is located right in the middle of the new intersection near their new movie theatre (which is fantastic by the way). Some simple seating, a counter, and a wall with bags to your left is what your greeted with. This location was pretty clean and the staff was pretty friendly as well. We had never been here before and a really nice employee came over and explained the whole shebang to us. Simple enough, grab a bag the size you want, choose the base of the sandwich (I got the cubano) and choose all the fixin’s your little hear desires.
Here is where it sort of started going a little down hill. There were six of us which I know is a big order but it looked like they had a pretty organized line for the actual manufacturing of the sandwich. It took a lot longer for the sandwiches to be made than I thought. About 30 minutes for one or two of them. My sandwich was pretty poorly made with half of the ingredients falling out of it when I pulled it out of the now oily brown paper bag. The sandwich I asked for toasted and was warm on one side and the other was as if it came out of the fridge. Again it is a chain so my expectations weren’t a gourmet melt or anything. They also doused a very strong mustard on the sandwich but only in one spot… Which was a nice shock to my taste buds.
I’ll probably return to another Wich Wich some time, maybe not this one just because of where I live but it wasn’t the worst place i’ve ever been.

The sandwiches took awhile to come out but were great! Good variety of sandwiches. Cool vibe inside. It was fun ordering our sandwiches and checking off options on the bags. Ordering on the bags allowed for more customization! Will be going back.

They are not Ike’s in Foster City CA, but pretty close and if you double meat it, gets closer.
The system is very easy and convenient and all tastes very good. Definitely recommend double cheese on all.

I had the «muffuletta”-it was ok, but certainly not at all authentic (no mortadella, wrong bread, weak olive dressing). The bread is the biggest disappointment, and of course, for a sandwich shop, that’s HUGE.
I think the concept is very solid-​people want choices, and the number of possible combinations here are virtually endless.
The quality of the meat is certainly a step up from Milio’s, Cousin’s etc.
I thought the prices were spot on. They had about five employees on duty when I was there-​how they show a profit with that many employees is a mystery to me.
I gave them an extra star because they were very fast & very friendly

Today was my first time at a Which Wich. The staff was very helpful in explaining how the ordering process works. The guy that made my sandwich even made it in a way that was easy to eat while driving without making a mess of the condiments.

I love coming here. A wide variety of choices that pleases the whole family. I’ve had a handful of choices but I usually stick with the buffalo chicken or the bacon egg and cheese. I like that they have the nutritional facts easily available so I can stick to my goals. Will definitely be back again. Prices are fairly reasonable.

I love Which Wich! These sandwiches are amazing. I’ve been getting a medium and its enough for two meals: the staff is really helpful and they’re super clean.

I have had a few different sandwiches here, some are definitely better than others. I like the grinder, and add pesto to mine.
They have a nice variety of toppings available, which I think make or break the sandwich.
I would agree with other reviewers that they are overpriced and have a serious seating comfort problem. Going here with my 3 and 5 year old is a problem due to the mainly tall stool seating arrangement.

I revisited Which Wich. I had no plans to do so, but my kid was having a bad day and wanted to go there (she thinks that all food places should make you write your order on a bag now…).
Nothing had changed since my first review, but I ordered the Gyro sub this time.
Now, I’ll go a good distance for a solid gyro. They’re one of my favorite entrees. I love a really good gyro. The gyro sub at Which Wich is entirely solid. The meat was nice and flavorful, the tzatziki was creamy, but delicate. The fact that they served it on a whole wheat bun (because I asked for it), did no damage to the overall familiar gyro flavors, and I have to say that I was pretty impressed by it.
I wish they’d put in a few more comfortable seats. The stools at the tall tables are horrendous. I just stood to eat instead, given that all the normal tables were taken.
It’s still just a sandwich shop, but I’ll be going back if for no other reason than to get that gyro sub.

I probably won’t return. I’ve been noticing these chains popping up all over the Dane County area and decided to stop by for lunch with a co worker while I was in Sun Prairie.
What I like is that as soon as you walk in, you’re greeted by someone who helped you with the process if you’re a first timer. This is very different from other sandwich places. You go up to a station where all of their sandwiches are written in bags. So if you want a turkey sandwich, you crab the brown paper bag that has written in the back all of the turkey options they have. They do the same for beef, tuna, veggie, chicken, etc. You grab the bag of the sandwich you want and on the bag, you mark with a provided sharpie all of the toppings you want. This is a really neat idea. I liked the selection process. When you’ve marked your bag with all of your toppings, which they do provided a lot of choices I must admit, you take the bag to the register to pay and the bag is sent to sandwich artist. They put the finished sandwich in the same bag with your selections. Again, very cool idea. When’re sandwich is done, they call you by name. There is a place on the bag for you to put your name down.
However, they are overpriced for their quality of food. You get to pick from three different bread sizes, 6, 10.5 and 14 inches. For a 10.5 inch, it’s $ 8.25 if you don’t add toppings that are priced extra. The sandwich was just OK. Nothing special. They gave me the wrong mustard but it wasn’t a huge deal. My biggest issue is that there isn’t any combo special. At least that is not what was told to me. For a 10.5 inch sandwich with not extra priced toppings and a small bag of chips, it was over $ 10. Had I added a pop, I would have been close to $ 12. It’s a lot of money for a sandwich that’s very basic and some chips. If the sandwiches were gourmet or other products were locally made, I totally could see the justification of price. However, the sandwich was just basic. I prefer Quiznos or Pot Bellys over Which Wich to be honest. I had a lot of toppings on mines, but my sandwich was overwhelmed with mayor and horseradish. I couldn’t even taste the other toppings.
Doubtful i’d return. They aren’t terribly bad but they are far from greatness. The experience of picking your sandwich is cool but that’s really the only positive I have from my first time experience. I can at least day I tried it and seen what they had to offer. Now I know and I won’t be returning. I’ve had better sandwiches elsewhere.

I had a BLT with avocado, spinach and cheddar. I was a bit nervous at all the choices. But it was hot, the bread was nicely toasted, the bacon was nicely copied up into chunks which made it great for eating. Veggies were fresh.
You have limited interaction with the staff, counter person who took our order was friendly.
Seating isn’t great. It’s uncomfortable and sparse. Sorta like they want you to take it and GO.

I ordered the avocado & tomato on wheat. I also ordered other things to go on this sub but I couldn’t tell if they were on their by taste or not. The ooshy gooshy avocado was big time overkill and completely dominated the sandwich. Now I love avocado, I’ll eat it straight with a spoon ya’ll, but this avocado mash was border line rotten, yet surprisingly tasteless goop. It oozed and leaked all over the place. I think I just ate a green slime sammich. Not that anyone would be shocked to know this, but I felt ill after eating it.
However, since this place is brand new in the Sun Prairie area I’m willing to give them another chance sometime down the road. But I won’t be ordering the avocado sludge monster again.