#1Brothers Pizza

I absolutely love this place. My favorate pizza joint neaby. We have been regulars since they first opened up. Always satisfied. They care for their customers, fresh food and delicious too. Friendly atmosphere every time you walk in. Their Lazagna and Ravioli Meet are the best. Try their salads too, always frieshly made. Thank you guys

For starters, don’t trust the horrible ratings that this place gets. My friend had been here once and told me to come so we both came in and ordered Meatlovers Calzones. Their system wasn’t working but the older gentleman did his best to accommodate us and still give us good service despite the troubles with the computer. After about 5 – 10 minutes our calzones were ready and let me tell you it was amazing! They were very warm and absolutely LOADED with nice cheese, meat. About midway through the meal I went up and asked the older gentleman if I could have a water cup. I was expecting a small cup of water but he gave me two cups and a pitcher of water to bring back to the table! Now that is good customer service! You can tell they care what the customer thinks and how their experience goes. I can’t speak to the rest of their menu because I’ve only had the calzone, but I will be coming back try more for sure!

The pizza was really good — the thin crust reminded me of Italian deep dish pizza. My family lived it, we will definitely be back. The people working were very nice too.

Stopped in with the family for a pie. Now I’m not too particular about pizza– I’m pretty much a pizza-​whore and haven’t met too many pizzas I didn’t like. But the pizza here is just awful. There is no flavor. Everything tastes as though it can from a can of generic toppings. The staff seemed preoccupied with something else other than the customers.

Paid 18 bucks for a large pizza. Waaay to much salt and was some of the greasiest pizza I have ever had in my life and I am 53yrs old. Wife and I ate one piece and threw the rest of that crap away.
I should have been paying attention to the HUGE mound of raw chicken wings just sitting out behind the counter not covered. I had to wait 15 minutes or so for the pizza and those wings just sat there the whole time.
Man at the counter was nice. Young ladies working for him were nice. Front of place appeared clean but those wings were a health code violation if I ever saw one.
Pizza was/​is nasty. The rest I cannot comment on. I won’t be back.

First time at this location, used to fo to the one of Cactus and 75^th, and it was always great. Tried this location and will not return. Pizza is no where near the quality of the other location. Their pizza was extremely greasy and their wings must have come off of some quail. They are extremely small and not very much meat on them. If you are in the area and want quality pizza and wings, head to NYPD, don’t waste your time or money here!

I am sorry to say that this was the worst italian food I and my family ever had! I ordered 4 Calzones and Calzones usually start with Pizza sauce and then you pick what you want in them, well I ordered a Sausage Calzone and it consisted of some sausage sprinkled in it and to my amazement that was it no sauce and no cheese no nothing! ! ! And my family members were the same! ! ! So dont throw away 60.00 Dollars on Calzones filled with nothing and a ruined evening for sure. The owner proceeded to call me and say sorry but that sorry was just that a sorry word because it sure didnt bring back my 60.00 Dollars. And a ruined dinner oh and yes a pretty good hit to my pocket book watching eveything go in the trash! ! ! I honestly wish there qas a NO! Star rating that I could pick.

Not only is the food amazing but the owners are equally as amazing. My husband loves their calzones and wings while I love their pizza. There has never been a time we were disappointed or unhappy, truly a great family owned pizza place.

Pretty good overall. Similar to NYPD pizza, but the crust isnt quite as good, its just not quite right. Sauce, cheese, toppings were all good. Generally a good example of a new york pie.
Only real downside is the price… Its a bit too expensive. Knock a couple bucks off and id be back more often.

It’s an okay place, but I have experienced better. Not as good as some pizza joints I’ve been to like Alondra’s in Los Angeles or even Grimaldi’s Pizzaria in Peoria, but it’s still pretty good. However, the pizza is also very pricy; 40 dollars for two 16 inch pizzas is not exactly every week material, in comparison to generic joints like Pizza Hut or Domino’s, and at the same time, I do not feel the quality is on par with other restaurants, like the two mentioned above. That said, their lunch menu is quite cheap with a slice and soda for 4 bucks.
As for the store itself, I do not get a shop that feels like I should dine in. It feels like a take out place due to the cheap furniture and terrible layout.

Yummy! We love coming here. The food is made from scratch and is always fresh. Owner is awesome and very friendly. Pizza, fried mushrooms, and grilled chicken sandwhich.

The place is nice and clean. We ordered 3 X-​large pizza’s to-​go. Cheese, sausage, and pepperoni. All 3 pizzas were delicious! Each pizza had plenty of meats, cheese, and sauce. The crusts were the perfect combo of a lil chewy on the inside and a lil crunchy on the outside. They were also perfectly cooked. I don’t know if this location is part of the other valley Brothers Pizza Restaurants but the pizza here is just as delicious as the other locations with this name. I will be back here when in the area and hope to dine-​in. Sorry I don’t have any pics because the pizza was gone fast!

Despite the reviews I decided to visit this place. I mean how bad can it be? I ordered two slices of pepperoni and I got two slices of cheese. When I brought to her attention she took the plate and then brought out two slices of pepperoni. No thanks for waiting no sorry just put it on the counter. I was the only one in there. It was an older man and older woman and I assume they were married since the we’re arguing like husband and wife. The wife was watching TV picking her teeth with a toothpick sitting behind counter. I purposely walked out slowly and dumped my trash waiting to see if she would say Thanks for coming in! I got nothing. People in New York are nicer than these people. If you notice David J. writes reviews regularly and says good things. He must be an owner or friends with the owner since he always writes a review after several negative reviews. In fact if I recall he is the only one to write a positive review. I won’t be back.

I like to let you know I had a Unilocal 5 dollar off for this location. I tried to use it and they did not honor it. Felt was trick ed but the pizza was ok. But I will take my business elsewhere next time.

Just moved to the area and decided to try this place out. The prices were great for lunch specials, and dinner specials as well. I was amazed at how friendly the staff were and how comfortable they made us. We ordered an extra large pizza, 25 hot wings, a large antipasti salad, and fried zucchini. And may I say… WOW. You won’t be able to find food any better anywhere else along with the great prices. It was an enjoyable experience with the friendly customer service, my favorite sports game on the tv, and great food. Definitely a place I will be going back to.

Great people. Always friendly and the food is great. Stop in and pick up a pizza or lunch specials. Everything is great here, calzones, pizza and salads.

Went there to support my local community establishment & decided to give #1 Brother Pizza. I ordered the baked ziti I thought it was a complete meal to my dismay the salads are only available if you eat in. I felt shorted there’s no reason they can’t box a salad or offered me the antipasta salad. Nothing worse than dinner missing a salad. Don’t you think so.
As for the Ziti the noodle very soggy no meat in there just a complete disappointment. If your going to offer it make it a complete meal including a salad I could of ate it while waiting for my dinner. You also need to make garlic toast instead of sandwich roll. The sauce tasted like tomato paste bland & acid tang. Very disappointed. So the next day spoke to Al or Alex He hooked me up with the best Capstone ever Thank you very much.
Sincerely Von

Okay so first time I had their pizza I was waiting to get a hair trim next door and figured I’d grab a slice. There was no pizza ready so I had to sit there waiting for one slice of pizza which defeats the purpose calling it NY style. Soooo I get my slice and it was bland, hardly any sauce, and the crust was like cardboard. I usually go to Ray’s Pizza, but because this place is so close I wanted to really like this place.
I thought that maybe it was just a bad slice and next time I’ll get a pie. I order a pie and go pick it up in 15 mins as they told me to do. The pizza is siting on the counter just getting cold. When i got it home I had to throw it in the oven. Again, no flavor and very little sauce. I gave up on this place pizza wise. I can go to Ray’s which is further away and my pizza is still hot when I get it home.
Anyway, while watching football I was craving some wings and thought eh why not. Maybe (fingers crossed) they have decent wings. So I order 12 wings. Now I should have sensed trouble when they handed me this tiny bag. So basically a burger size box had all the wings. Again, cold… The wings were so tiny and dry… I give up. I rather drive to Ray’s or Lucky’s.

The pizza and wings are real good, however the service and atmosphere makes it difficult to continue to go back, but I end up going back since the pizza is good.
Update December 2014… they are by far the worst in customer service. They wouldn’t even take the Unilocal coupon.

Not bad pizza, I like the twice cooked to add veggies for supreme, but they were a little too under cooked. If the idea of reheated cheese pizza with the toppings you request added when reheating is ok with you, then you may like it. I do like it, it makes the crust yummy, but you have to get the veggies soft a little… The salad was good, pretty fresh, friendly customer service. I will be back when I need a single slice pizza fix, but if it is consistently like what I had, I may not keep going…