Reino’s Pizza & Pasta

The pizza is classic for a place like this. And the gravy… ohhhh the gravy. Best Italian I’ve had in a while.

Their calzones are amazing, although my chicken parm calzone wasnt the best, my girlfriend’s BLT calzone was amazing. Decent service, couldve waited on us better, had to wait for check for a long time.

Visited today on ANOTHER rainy afternoon in northern Ohio. Was visiting Heidelberg University with my son, and took notice of the positive Unilocal reviews for Reino’s. This place is very «cozy» as another Unilocaler put it. They did have the lunch buffet option, but my son and I just settled for the 16″ cheese pizza. Any one who knows me will advise you that I may have eaten more cheese pizza than anyone on the planet. Six to seven days a week for twenty five plus years, give or take. With that being said it takes a lot to impress me with cheese pizza, and not too many places can make a cheese pizza to die for. As for the Reino’s cheese pizza the cheese was very good, the crust great, and the sauce obviously homemade but with a strange flavor. Not sure what spice my son and I were picking up on, but it definitely wasn’t our thing. We still managed to finish most of the pizza, but I wouldn’t buy it again. I would return to try some of the other items on the menu. If I revisit, I’ll update my review accordingly.
Service wasn’t maybe average, but it appeared that one waitress was trying to put items on the buffet and take care of three or four tables by herself. Total bill was about $ 15.00 — minus tip.

Came here with my parents, who are loyal customers and rave about Reino’s. We sat at the bar and the owner was very personable. He recommended a great red wine and gave me a nice, healthy pour. I ordered the the cheese ravioli, which was a sizable portion and was delicious. My dad got the meat version, which I tasted and actually preferred over the cheese.
If you’re in town, are hungry and want a meal that will satisfy you, along with friendly service, come to Reino’s. I’ll be back the next time I’m visiting the parents.

Meal (****): my female counterpart was my guest on this adventure and she loves Hawaiian pizza: we shared the fold over. That specific combo is not my bag, but every aspect from crust to cheese to sauce and mouthfeel… I ate my share.
Ambiance (*****): booth diner and bar. Single occupant toilet. Very relaxed. They use the space well. People were very quiet!
Service (*****): our waitress knew her stuff. Took great care of us.

Simply the best place to eat pizza and pasta in Tiffin, OH. Reino’s offers great food, friendly service, pleasant atmosphere, and fair prices.

Get the lunch buffet! Really surprised at the quality of the food here since it is in a TINY town in Ohio… But the buffet was very nice (i do not usually frequent buffets) their salad was fresh and plentiful, good pastas, and the cinnamon pizza topped it off perfectly. We came in a huge group right at the beginning of the day and they had no problems.

One of my favorite places in Tiffin. They have great pizza, but their chicken Parmesan is the absolute best.

I have dined here since the 1970’s. I have seen the quality ebb and flow.
After my last two visits I think we are at a stand off, not great, not bad but OK.
The service was friendly and the place was clean. The lasagna was a tad lacking, the gravy aka sauce was lacking and on the thin side.
The quantity is not an issue, they do not skimp on serving size.
The salad was made from typical Iceberg lettuce (ewww) might be worth it to throw in some Romaine, Radicchio or Spinach. When I get a salad made of Iceberg with a little tomato and carrot on it I think the chef is either lazy or working with low budget. I get that this isn’t a big salad eating town but perhaps people would eat more salad if they actually tasted a good one!
On a high note the beer here is cold and fast and the wait staff seems friendly enough.

great little place. ravioli was fantastic.