Tin Bakery

Love this bakery! Heard recently that they are further limiting days and hours of operation, but every cupcake I’ve had here is great! Pumpkin Spice is my fav, and the owner makes them year-​round because of such a high demand and amount of requests for them! The menu has expanded since opening, and believe she also makes brownies.
Also stopped in later one evening (close to closing) to buy just 2, and the owner told me to pick 6 for the same price! So you may score a free cupcake or so if she has leftover at the end of the day!
Really can’t go wrong with any flavor here!

Hands-​down the best cupcakes in Columbus!!! Our favorite is the chocolate cupcake with peanut butter buttercream icing and my wife loves the lavender cupcake. The cupcakes are definitely gourmet. The store/​bakery is beautifully decorated with a small seating area.

The owner is a nice lady and I liked the cupcakes but the cost for the size just isn’t worth the visit to me. They weren’t the best cupcakes I’ve ever had either but still tasty. The buckeye cupcake is the best!
It would be nice if she served a wider variety of product as well since it is called a «bakery», then it might be worth going back.
The interior is beautiful.

Beautiful store, but disappointing cupcakes. Prices weren’t posted, which I found odd. The owner was very friendly though which was nice. The cupcakes were just forgettable.

OH. MY. HEAVENLY. TaStY!!!
This place is orgasmicly amazing! Perfect for those sweet tooth cravers or even those who just like amazing CuPCaKeS! You walk into a small shop, packed of customers with their eyes wide open and mouths dropped long! The 15 minute finding parking is definitely worth it! Theres a whole array of cupcakes to satisfy to chocolate of chocolates to red velvet lovers for cupcake eaters. Each cupcake is definitely rich and moist yet light and fluffy. The cashiers are always so patient and friendly, always giving out suggestions and helping you decide. Definitely great for friends, birthdays, dates, families, kids, or even an afternoon out stop!

This is one of my favorite cupcake shops… and I LOVE Baked goods. The Lavender cupcake is absolutely heavenly right along side their Salty Caramel. AMAZING! Very moist. We go back for ourselves and gifts several times a month!

I’m not sure what I thought when I heard «Tin Bakery», but I was a little surprised to find out all they have available are cupcakes. The cupcakes are nice (a bit dry for my taste), and the owner is wonderful, but unless I have a sudden craving for specialty cupcakes, I can’t see myself going back.

Tin is a great little bakery and can be easily missed due to their location and size. Their cupcakes are amazing and brownies are excellent. They have some very traditional flavors but also have some other, trendy flavors. It is very clean and the women who work their are very friendly. The cupcakes are small for the price though but are homemade and taste homemade and fresh– which is something I think some of the other cupcake shops in town miss on. Check this place out– you won’t be disappointed.

Stopped in here just before closing on a Saturday night prior to stopping at the Wine Bistro. Owner was super nice even though we got there at she was closing. She told us her story and how she came up with the name and logo. I bought the Oreo and Chocolate PB cupcakes. Both were super moist and delicious and we loved them both but if I HAD to choose I would take the choc pb. She had a couple gluten free options as well but we didn’t try them. Love their logo and the shop is super cute. I will definitely return and would recommend.

I stopped in to pick up a couple of cupcakes while my husband was at the dentist (neighboring location). He enjoyed his vanilla/​vanilla and I liked my lavender/​vanilla. I appreciated that she made lavender as well. I will go back when I am in the vicinity.

It’s a nicely decorated, very small bakery. The staff is very friendly. When I think bakery, I automatically think lots of beautiful desserts, endless options and fantastic flavor. I was disappointed with all. I’ll try it one more time, but will only return if the selection has improved.

I want to give Tin Bakery more than three stars, but I can’t at this time. My chocolate cupcake with vanilla butter cream was pretty amazing, but I am a chocoholic! Maybe if they start to carry a larger selection, I can write another review with more stars. I will say though that I was surprised at how much I actually liked white frosting. I only ever order chocolate. So kudos to them getting me to enjoy something that I typically would never order.

One of the best cupcakes I have ever eaten! Such a lovely shop, owner, and product. The cupcakes were moist, flavorful, and delicious. My grandmother was an excellent baker and candy maker so my expectations are always very high. These were superb! I’ve tried the red velvet, cookies and cream, and the white cake with pink icing.
Regarding Walt’s review… I found the packaging simple and elegant.

I noticed Tin Bakery heading home into Upper Arlington and remembered it as I headed east on Lane Avenue at Noon (Sunday). Parking in the rear was plentiful as it was a weekend and there is a back door. Upon entering I get the feeling this little bake shop had yet to get its name out there — no one was inside but the owner/​baker. No coffee was made. The décor is sparse with only three small tables with a few chairs there. Seemed cold.
There were six flavors of iced cupcakes in the display. When I asked if there were any other baked goods the owner politely mentioned she made cupcakes, just cupcakes. Now, there was a stack of chocolate brownies under glass so I simply took her answer as what she knew best. I looked at the cupcakes and thought they were smallish for the charge of $ 3 per cake. After a short moment of contemplation I bought a vanilla/​vanilla cake and two brownies.
My feeling is there is a lot of money being spent on branding instead of product. The packaging of both the cupcake and the brownies have TIN BAKERY pre-​printed on the fancy FANCY box and holder. A brown bag would suffice if the cupcakes were $ 1.75 — $ 2.00. The vanilla/​vanilla was small once out of its shell and it was a little dry. Hmmmm… wondering about all this. The brownie was very moist with chocolate chips mixed in — the baker got this right.
I discussed with the owner options on cupcakes. Why not a Scarlet & Grey cupcake? How about poppyseed? Perhaps promotions that help the Susan B. Komen Race for the Cure — a pink & pink cupcake? She was receptive but really didn’t have much of a response on ideas.
It would be my hope Tin Bakery survives. The shoppes there on Lane are cute. But I think variety will be the answer.

This little cupcakery, unbeknownst to me somehow for several months, popped up in the same strip as The Wine Bistro in Upper Arlington, early this winter. This cute shop serves only cupcakes. They had about 5 or 6 flavors at the time. I tried the red velvet cake and pumpkin spice flavors. Both were moist and tastey. I don’t remember exactly, but they were about $ 3 each, which is a little more than cupcakes I’ve had at Blue Frost in Worthington.
I’ll have to come back and try more flavors soon.