Two Guys From Italy

Delicious food! Lovely attentive server. Ordered a large 3 topping pizza. There were generous toppings and their fries were perfect.

Hate giving bad reviews, but it was/​is bad. We ordered a delivery last night, the food we’ve got did not taste good, fries had a weird aftertaste and chicken-​parm tasted like it was old and just microwaved, but I wish it was the only problem. Both of us (who ate this food) got incredibly sick and the symptoms of a food-​borne illness still remain active…

The pizza is delicious, the prices are amazing, and you get A LOT of food for your buck. The food is amazing, the drinks are strong and the company is great! The owner is so cute he is from Rome, and throws pizza in the air like no ones pizza, it’s like a little show. The chicken and eggplant is mouth watering. Love the fries. I can’t say enough how amazing this place is.

Excellent pizza. Great quality cheese and crust and the crispy pepperoni is incredible. Service was great for a small place. Hidden gem of warwick.

I recently tried this place and fell in love! This is my favorite place to get NY style pizza and the sauce is delicious! I have gotten pepperoni with extra cheese which is very good! The garlic bread with cheese is good too! Come try this place for some pizza! Unfortunately, it’s closed on Sundays and Mondays. I haven’t tried anything else yet so far besides pizza but I’m sure it’s good!

Great drinks. Had a calzone that was bigger than my damn head (I have a huge head) I’ll come back or order ahead just for that!

Just because you’re from Italy does NOT mean you can run a successful pizza business. The word disappointment is an understatement in this case. I will save the negative adjectives but alternatively recommend a frozen boboli Pizza instead. I can almost guarantee you will be more satisfied. Here is the caveat, I had the wicked munchies when I ordered this pie so Ketchup on a pizza box would have tasted great for me. Are you picking up what i’m throwin down? Why can’t Warwick be home to a good pizza joint?: (

Not sure why this place has so many great reviews. I’m certainly not going back.
It’s mediocre pizza at best. Nothing special at all. I’m not sure what it is about Warwick, there’s tons of pizza places but they all suck. There’s no pizza place in Warwick that stands out from the rest. Doesn’t anyone know how to make fresh dough anymore? What’s with all the frozen/​pre-​made doughs these places are using?
So I ordered a large pepperoni pizza for pickup, was told 20 minutes. Arrived to restaurant in 20 minutes, waited another 15 minutes for pizza. It was very odd waiting as well, not many people in the restaurant and it doesn’t even look like a pizza place. not sure why it took so long for a pizza when it was so dead.
The next thing that bothered me was the use of the pizza screen. The bottom of the pizza is completely burnt with diamonds on it from the pizza screen. I’m not sure how many cooking shows you’ve seen and such, but really, there’s no need to use a pizza screen! There’s really no excuse, you dont know what you’re doing if you’re a pizza place that uses a pizza screen to cook on in which it burns the pizza.
So anyways, I have a large pepperoni pizza with one slice eaten from it and I really don’t want to eat the rest. Anyone want this? Oh and did I mention this pizza smells like bbq sauce? haha. I dunno, whatever, I’m not going back. Good luck.

I just don’t understand why this place isn’t busier. This is the best pizza around. The crust is perfect, the sauce well seasoned, the cheese not greasy. LOVE the pepperoni and the way it curls up at the edges, we always order double pepperon (YES there are MANY people that like stacks of pepperoni on their pizza!) and ask for the pizza to be a little well done.
The 5 stars is for the food alone and thats all that matters! This is a hole in the wall gem that is under appreciated.

The pizza was good. We just tried cheese for our first time and some appetizers. They were very friendly when we picked it up. Unfortunately it’s kind of far from my house so it won’t be my first choice of pizza, but everything tasted pretty good. If I lived closer or worked in the area I would definitely order more often.
There is a movie called ‘A Slice of Pie’ in which the owner of a pizza joint is being run out by a greedy landlord. The owner, his wife and the delivery drivers need to make money in some creative ways (it’s an adult movie). The name on the restaurant in the movie is Two Guys From Italy… unfortunately it’s not the same place.

Let’s cut to the chase — you aren’t coming here because you want a sommelier to help you pair a wine with your chicken parm. You’re coming here because you want the best pizza this side of Italy.
If you don’t believe me, read all the other reviews. The pizza is about as delicious as it gets, and the prices are amazing. The only reason that it isn’t packed is that it’s easy to miss the restaurant in a strip-​mall ish location. Don’t make the same mistake that everyone else does in the area when they drive to Bertucci’s down the street, and eat mass produced Italian food made by a kid who just graduated from high school.
Look in the kitchen… if the chef is Italian, yells things you don’t understand (even if you speak Italian), and slings pizza like nobody’s business, that’s your place to go. 2 Guys, home made authentic goodness, any day of the week.

The food is amazing, the drinks are strong and the company is always great!

Tried their pizza for the first time and we are very happy! Will definitely be back! Crispy thin crust with plenty of juicy toppings.

two guys pizza is great, one of my favorites!

Had to try this place due to the fact it has such good reviews on Unilocal!I was overly excited however when eating what I ordered the joy faded. I got a pepperoni pizza and it seemed like a good deal for what it cost (12 bucks a large, really large). They gave me a brick oven style pizza with way to much meat for my liking.
I just do not enjoy stacks of pepperoni on my pie, IDK maybe people do? It was so much I had to pick them off to cut down the sodium and make it tolerable. Other than that, the sauce was good, the crust was nice and the cheese amount was not to bad. I will probably give it another shot but skip the meat, maybe try just cheese.
Cheap, sauce is good, just to much meat.

Was okay not the best in the area for sure we ordered this a few months ago and were not thrilled with their crust or mediocre cheese. Again if you’re in the area its not the best not the worse. I definitely prefer Lakis but that’s a hike up the traffic laden street.

The name says it all: so authentic and delicious! I just ordered a large pie and garden salad. Not sure what they put in the sauce, but it’s full of herbs and mouthwatering spices: the crust is not too thin, not too thick, but a real piece of art.
Great find: this is my new favorite pizza place in the area. Why get the standard chain pizzas when you can get this local flavor!

Back in day you bought pizza from an Italian restaurant with a cook in the kitchen who barked commands in an authentic Italian accent. Well there is one left and it is not to be missed. Homemade, fresh and made to order. It’s real food for real people.
Support your local merchants and stop settling for mass produced cr#p.
See Sal at Two Guys!