Butch’s Pub&eatery

Friendly staff, great food and drinks. Small town feel to it. If you’re looking for a good steak at a great price hit up Butches. The Friday fish fry is a great portion for the cost as well. Want a martini? They have about 60 on the menu to fit the bill.

Was sad when the 27^th Street location closed.
I visited the new location, it is much like the old one; same décor, same paper menu. Except that Butch offers a few daily specials that he cooks from scratch at this location that he didn’t at the 27^th location. The specials are fantastic.
Same great filets here. Although, I noticed that he raised the prices by a bucks. Not a fan of this at all. Part of the reason that I liked his casual pubs is the cheap, awesome eats. I hope that Butch reconsiders his pricing.
Now, in response to the reviews of the décor. You come here for the food, not the décor. The name says it all: «PUB and eatery» and not a fine dining establishment. If you are overly concerned with the décor here, then you aren’t paying attention to your food or your company. Mo’s House of Steaks might be a better choice for you then…
The service at any Butch’s is fantastic. Great bunch of people here. They make a superior martini, too.

Must say the Panko Shrimp are AWESOME! Butterflied, large, crispy, hot yumminess! However, our recent trip my husband had a filet, although it was cooked exactly as ordered (medium rare), the piece of meat was just not enjoyable. The fish fry is rather tasty too. Drinks… They are well made and quickly made!

Was really bummed when the 27^th Street location closed so when I heard that a new Butch’s opened in Stallis, I just had to try it out.
Got there a little after 7 on a Friday night and they had a few tables open.
Definitely a nicer bar then the previous location. The tables and chairs could still use a little updating. Table was a bit wobbly.
Ordered the 8oz steak sandwich and it was fabulous!!! Just as I had remembered it. Is it a bit pricey? Yes, but the steak is soooooo good and tender. The steak is topped with mushrooms and Comes with a side of fries and coleslaw. The coleslaw has a small amount of horseradish in it. Definitely not too much though. Love that the coleslaw wasn’t your typical side.
The service was great! Friendly waitresses.
They still offer their $ 5 martinis for happy hour and have a great selection.
Hope this location works out for them because I will definitely be back.

I was kind of disappointed…
I have been to their other restaurant out in Oconomowoc and really liked it. So, I figured their pub and eatery would be pretty good. I knew it wouldn’t be as nice. But, overall, I was not very impressed. I guess their menu offerings (and pricing) did not match the décor on the inside. This place is older. It’s definitely just more of a bar. But then they have $ 12 sandwiches and $ 25 fish specialties. It’s just not normal prices for more of a dive bar.
With that being said, my burger was tasty. And we got about 15 fries with our burgers.
In general, the food did taste good. But I just feel like this deserves an «I’ve experiences better» rating. And, if I wanted a $ 25 seafood dish, I would definitely go to a place where it is a nicer restaurant.
Wait staff was friendly.

A bunch of us stopped in for cocktails the other night — the bartender knew what he was doing and the drinks tasted great. The prices were refreshingly inexpensive.

got a steak sandwich told then NO mushrooms I’m allergic, comes out with mushrooms, fine I remind them I said no mushrooms I’m allergic. They bring out a seemingly fine sandwich, I guess they either scraped off the mushrooms or reused the bread, because my face started to get numb and a little swollen, itchy throat and some breathing issues, thankfully I live 3 houses down the street so I had medication to take care of it. But o had to ask for the sandwich to be taken off. The service was slow and they seem to only pay attention to the people at the bar. $ 8.95 for some frozen motz sticks, for that price I don’t expect prepackaged frozen food. Also my soda came in a can, there’s a full service bar you can’t give it from the soda gun? The only good thing is now that its not Stephen’s its nicer and doesn’t have a funky smell, and that’s where the good ends. Will NOT be back, will NOT recommend.