CiCi’s Pizza

Loved the buffet.

Trailer trash heaven. If you’re painting the house or are overdrawn in your checking account– this place is for you. Cheap. Tacky. And that’s its patrons!
Salad bar consists of lettuce, cheese and not much else. Pizza is OK. Nothing to die for… it’s cheap. Yes, you can make requests. Whoppee.
Little kids everywhere and stuff all over the floor, even tho they try to keep it clean.
Not my idea of a good time. Classic example of you get what you pay for.
The highlight was me was making it out of the door before one of the staff yelled «C, C, c ya later».
Nope, nope you won’t.
If you’re in high school or college, have 10 kids and no dental insurance — you’ll love it.

Just try this place for the first time. Great job. Came in near closing food still hot and fresh. Staff super friendly and accommodating and very enthusiastic about serving us.
Had the buffet. Salad good and loved the cinnamon rolls.

great place. great price! great variety. definitely recommend

I don’t come here often, but when I do I’m not disappointed. For the price of a McDonalds value meal I can get a drink and a buffet of salad, pasta, pizza and dessert. Is it the best I’ve ever had? No. Is it good enough for me to want to come back? Heck yeah!
Cici’s doesn’t claim to be the best but it should be proud of what it offers. It’s a very kid friendly restaurant– which I often try to avoid. The pizza is made fresh with the option for a special order at no extra charge. There are a wide variety of toppings available and they rotate the pizza combinations constantly. If you see one you know you’ll like, grab two slices right away!
There is always pasta available as well as a full salad bar. The dessert portion is often the same choice of brownies or a greasy delicious cinnamon roll. So good, but so bad for you.
The staff here are friendly and the place is pretty clean. The only problem I generally have is with parking. The lot for this strip mall fills up fast.

The service was great, the food was fresh, and the experience wasn’t all that bad. If you’re planning on a quiet night out this isn’t the place for you. If you want a kid friendly environment with good food for the right price, CiCis is for you!
I only gave three stars for the following reason:
I tried to recognize a wonderful employee (Jamika) by informing the manager (Dave) and he blew off the comment by saying «We hear that often, she’s new.» Then quickly turned around, I’m assuming to ignore the recognition. I’m utterly discusted with his behavior. SHE’S the reason we stayed. She was upbeat, positive, and very polite. Even while cleaning up the vomit on the floor and getting balloons for all the kids. It’s people like her who make businesses strive. As for Dave, he should be the one cleaning up the vomit on the floor.

My favorite part of Cici’s? Feeding a family of 5 for under $ 25. The food is steadily rotated (besides, its pizza. Pretty sure it could sit out for 2 days and still be good). They always have a variety of pizzas, and are more than happy to make a whole pie with the toppings you want at no extra cost. Friendly staff. They work hard to keep the dirty dishes picked up.
My only advise, avoid the weekend dinner rush. Kinda busy, and it seems every single mother with 8 kids is there.

Been to many Cici’s. Convenient, economical and value for the money. This Cicis is no exception. Excellent location. Neat inside. Very good selection of pizzas. When we requested a special pizza, not only did they bring one to the table, but were courteous enough to add one to the buffet as well. We were pleased with their attention to detail and customer service. Would not hesitate to go again.

The 1 star is due to the soda selection they have on tap.
We followed suit and paid for the buffet like everyone else. The pizza selection was mediocre and tastes as though it had sat out for a while.
Once realizing the we could make a request I opted for a deep dish pizza with 2 toppings. The pineapple on my pizza was old or tasted that way. And, don’t hate, the chicken that was skimped on was flavorless and small. I joked that I needed my glasses to see the tiny little cubes.
Now on to the noticeable violation. The busser/​table cleaner was using the same dirty rag to wipe down all the tables. And where did that rag go when she went from table to table??? She put it in the same place with all the dirty dishes she was collecting.
My daughter wanted to eat here as we were passing through town and that’s how we ended up here.
If you want affordable pizza and price is the only thing that matters… you will like it here. If you want better quality food keep driving.

If you’re considering this as a meal option, you should reconsider. I never thought a place could make Pizza Hut look like a 5 star dining experience, but alas Cici’s has succeeded.
Where do I begin? As you walk in the door a gentleman asks if you’re familiar with the menu. Me being an honest, unprepared man, foolishly answered, «I am not.» WRONG ANSWER! Does he go on and explain to me the simplicities of a buffet? Nope. All of a sudden there’s a bell ringing, followed by a litany of minimum wage employes yelling «welcome to Cici’s!» At this point half of the overweight, unemployed, pack of mouth breathers known as guests stare at me with a confused look as if to say, «how have you never been here, it’s West Allis’ Mecca of gastronomy!» How embarrassing.
Moving on… I begin to survey the buffet lineup of endless pizza, pasta, and salad, as I scout for the classics. Ya know, pepperoni, works, and perhaps something quirky. «Oh look, they have one with pineapple, how fun?!?» Played out, firstly. And not very good, secondly. Figure it out pizza guru’s. Anyway… I go for a slice of pepperoni, and one of veggie, and find myself a lovely little table, with a view of the parking lot. Which I’ve come to realize, is what West Allis is. One big parking lot. So I go for the veggie first… I make it two bites before giving up. I’ll just throw some adjectives out there. Soggy, unpleasant, limp, undercooked, under seasoned. «Ok, perhaps the pepperoni will be better, nobody fucks up pepperoni.» Wrong again. I slide my plate forward and decide it’s gonna be a salad bar day.
So I cruise over to the salad bar. Now, I’ve been at a salad bar or two in my 32 years on this rock, and let me tell you, this was not that. It more so resembled the burger bar at Fudrucker’s than any salad bar I’ve ever seen. Pickles, jalapeños, banana peppers, what’s going on here? I settled for a few pizza toppings atop a bed of iceberg lettuce with a side of lite Italian dressing. Which I might add may as well have been a mixture of water and oil. Adjectives for this portion include bland, limp, insulting, and confusing mostly. Needless to say, not much better than the pizza bar.
At this point I figured I better call it quits before I snap on someone. I skip the pasta and dessert, and hightail my ass outta there, to never return again.
High points, the busboy was friendly and prompt. Also, the soda was not flat. That’s about it.
In closing I’d say step it up Cici’s, but based on their clientele, I’d guess that’s not necessary.

I been coming here since they opened. Always friendly service with good food.
You get a whole buffet with 10 – 12 different pizza’s or you can get one made to order.
They have a pasta and salad bar too along with desert.
Where can you go nowadays and feed a family of 4 and get stuffed for under $ 30 like here at Cici’s Pizza.
You will not find a gourmet pizza here but you will get a quality good valued meal for the price.

This is a nice place to get all you can eat pizza. However, don’t go in thinking you will be wowed by the quality of the pizza. It’s good for the money, but just very so-​so pizza overall.
There is a decent variety to the types of pizzas served and they also make any pizza you would like on request without any additional cost. There is also a salad bar, a pasta booth, and and a dessert selection (3 options including the brownies).
Service is also very warm and friendly.
Overall, its a nice place to go and eat some pizza and more on the cheap.

We had a coupon for one free buffet if you buy one and a big drink. We heard that Cici’s was something like the old Shakey’s and were really looking forward to trying it. What an utter disappointment. The salad bar wasn’t bad, but not anything special. The pizzas were mostly dough with very little toppings. The atmosphere was not good at all – noisy and certainly no ambiance.
The chicken soup was tasteless as was the garlic bread. I guess you get what you pay for. At $ 5.55 per person, what can you expect? You would be much better off by going a little bit north and eating at the New China Buffet. Now that is one terrific buffet!!! My hubby and I go several times a week there.
I must say that the entire staff was very friendly and amiable, but that certainly would not be enough to bring me back. As with any restaurant, it’s all about the food and this food was atrocious.

Descriptive phrase: cheap pizza buffet.
The quality of pizza at CiCi’s is never going to win any awards, but you can’t go wrong with a $ 5 all-​you-​can-​eat buffet, especially when they do serve up a lot of different options (including desserts and salads). Workers were also extremely nice and attentive to the somewhat rude and obnoxious clientele.

Ok so update. Tried using the Unilocal check in offer and was denied. Told their store is corporate owned and doesn’t recognize Unilocal.So negative stars from me if I could.

Cici’s pizza… buffet style all you can eat pizza, pasta and salad. As you walk in the door we were greater by a very nice young lady. Asked if we visited before. This one was our first visit so the whole staff greeted us with a bell ring and a little Cicis greeting. The pizza station was filled with a variety of pizzas ranging from traditional pepperoni, customized to dessert pizza which is my favorite! The restaurant was clean and most importantly staffed with great people. Always asking how was the pizza and very personable. $ 5 you can’t go wrong, bring your appetite cause the pizzas will keep coming!

It was slightly over $ 10 for two people and two drinks, that’s Mcdonalds pricing for all you can eat pizza, Not a bad stop once in a while nothing was all that impressive but for $ 5 did you expect it to be? The breadsticks however are pretty good.

For the price, it’s good. The quality isn’t wonderful and the selection is limited. There was no cheese, sausage, or pepperoni pizza made when we came. It came out eventually. The dessert was weak. Tazinos has a better setup but is more expensive. For a cheap pizza buffet, you can’t go wrong.

Cici’s has mediocre all you can eat pizza for $ 5. That in itself is a good enough reason for 3 stars. Palatable pizza, pasta, and salad as well as drinks. My favorite is when they have the buffalo chicken. Not as good as other pizza chains, but as they say, it’s deece. You can also take it to go very quickly. If you’re eating in and the pizza you want is not out, you can request it and they will make it immediately.
Yes there are kids because it does cater to families. If you were looking for a quiet romantic dinner (even while i was there they had «That’s Amore» playing)… and even at 8:00, lady, it won’t be found anywhere with a $ 5 buffet. That’d be like going to the mouse and pizza eatery across the street and complaining about the birthday parties and the noise of video games. If you’re like me and just eating out with friends, you won’t mind.
Staff is outstandingly friendly and are quick to clear your dirty dishes while you’re on round 2. Polite too.
With cheap, eatable food and friendly staff i will definitely Cici them later!

OK, Let me start with the good. As a Mom I am always looking for places that a) my child will eat the food b) she won’t disrupt the universe and the elderly couple next to us and c) if she doesn’t eat a thing I won’t be out $ 10. CiCi’s is your place if this is what you are looking for. To top it off, she gets a balloon, which makes her day. You are greeted with a bell and howdya do if you have never been there before. Kids get a kick out of this as well.
However, as far as pizza buffet’s go. I have had much better. I find their pizza bland, their salads over dressed and wilty, and their pasta sub par. You can get specialty pizza made for you and brought to your table before placed on the buffet, but once again, compared to other pizza buffet chains the quality is lacking.