Infinity Diner

Great diner with a super friendly and attentive staff! I love their gyro platter and they make the best Greek dressing. I could drink that stuff!

Been coming here for decades, food is great, portions large, prices are affordable, what more can you ask for.

super bowl sunday everyone!

My husband and I love this diner. Even when busy we get sat pretty quickly. Whoever is at the register is always friendly and jokes with our daughter. The prices are good and always given more food than can finish (yeah leftovers)! While parking can be difficult sometimes, that just means lots of people like to eat there.

I’ve been here a few times and I usually dont rate places but this place was outstanding today i got a plate for breakfast called «benny florentine» which was amazing really recommend at least for breakfast i live in the area so its very convenient to stop there … i have to make it a habit to come in more often

My family and I have been going to this diner for years the hospitality of Tony and his family is incredible the food is amazing the service is good this is one of the best diners in Long Island they make you feel like you’re at home. Just love this place

Driving around with my son and his friend who said she has eaten here, I decided to give it a try. I was extremely disappointed and a bit grossed out about the grilled chicken sandwich. It had the fat at the end of the meat and all over it, you know that skinny layer of fat that one must remove from the chicken before cooking it. I cut out the fat, and used the knife to scrub the remaining layer of fat myself. I try not to give bad ratings to restaurants but this one, I can’t let it slide. It looks like someone buys the chicken, throws some seasoning and straight to the cooker. First, all meat, must be cleaned before cooking, meaning one has to cut the fat and sit the meat in water with lemon and vinegar for 10 minutes or more, then one must rinse the meat again with plain water, and that’s how one cleans the meat before cooking it. But even if the cook here would had rinse the chicken in some plain water, this chicken would had been ok. The taste of the chicken was pretty bad. I took a few bites and could not keep eating it. 2 stars not 1 because the chicken quesadilla and the burger we also ordered was okay. Seriously, the grilled chicken sandwich is a no, no, here. The menu has a wide variety of Greek food, so maybe the Greek food is excellent here. Also, the meal prices are higher than other Dinners. For example a meal on other places average is $ 9.99, here that same meal is $ 14.99.
All in all, most likely I won’t come back to eat here. I am sorry, I don’t like to give low stars, but that chicken sandwich earned it.

Ordered pickup for office. $ 18 for grilled chicken sandwich with mozz cheese, fries and a side of brown gravy. Meanwhile on their menu all their chicken sandwiches are $ 10.95 with fries included. They said since its how it was ordered that they charged me $ 18. What a rip off. They would not do anything about it. They also charged $ 2.50 for gravy on the side. Do yourself a favor and avoid getting ripped off and go elsewhere.

The place could do a lot better if they concentrate on fewer dishes and upgrade some recipes. We had lunch here and everything that we tasted was bland. Only soup was good according to one person in our group that tried it. After the meal, we all felt very tired and heavy even though we did not consume an excessive amount of food. That was kind of weird. The prices were reasonable and staff was accomodating. I would probably not be back here though unless absolutely out of options.

The reviews for this place was pretty good via Unilocal so I came here after a charity football game with my boyfriend. I got a house salad with «grilled chicken» which wasn’t grilled chicken. It was roasted chicken, but that’s OK. I also got chicken noodle soup which had one small piece of chicken in it… so it was really it was just noodles in chicken broth. The portions were pretty big, but expected for the price ($ 14 for lettuce, cucumbers, and chicken). I forgot what my boyfriend got but he took one bite and said it was cold and didn’t finish it. Before we left we just placed an order for a plate of fries and they weren’t fully cooked. I HATE to be that person that complains about everything which is why we didn’t bother our server who was very young, sweet, and patient with us. Our bill came to around $ 45 bucks for two sodas, a salad, a sandwich, and an order of fries. I work at a pizzeria and could have gotten all that, for less than $ 30 bucks… same portion size and all. But anyway. This place is definitely all hype and I won’t be returning if I’m ever in the area again. The staff and service was great which is why I gave it 3 stars!
Also, there’s barely any parking. We got lucky with one open spot.

We stop here every time that we stay nearby for a show at Nikon Jones Beach. The meals are quality diner food and the service is good very friendly. The place isn’t too big but we’ve never had to wait long. Definitely recommend it!

My favorite diner. They have great food, great atmosphere and the owners are so great! I recommend coming here anytime!

Food was tasty and abundant, fast service, clean, pleasant décor.
Added to my bookmark list.

The best diner I know in terms of food quality, value and service. Parking is poor but that’s my only complaint. I live in Dix Hills. My choices are Olympic, Premier and Dix Hills. Kills all but Premier in food quality. Premier’s food may be a little better but it’s much more expensive.
If you’re a carnivore, try the london broil. Always perfect. Fish and chips will reset your expectations for the dish. Fresh fillets fried to order. No frozen fish cakes.

After a co-​worker of mine mentioned how great this diner was, I just had to try it. Two friends of mine & I went into the diner on a late Wednesday morning (maybe 10 – 11) and were seated right away. Upon walking in you’ll notice the hostesses podium also doubles as a bar — I thought that was nice. We were given breakfast menus and seated in a booth.
Both of my friends wanted breakfast food, but I really felt like having lunch. When the waitress came to greet us, which was prompt and friendly, she brought me a full menu. so you can order whatever you want at any time of the day — plus! We started with mozzarella sticks, which came out pretty quickly. It was an order of 6 for $ 5.95, and it was SOOO good! We also ordered onion rings, and those were great! It was a mix between breading & beer battered which I think sets them apart. Shortly after our appetizers, our meals came out. I ordered the Greek Chicken wrap and although the menu states «Please no substitutions» I asked to leave a few things out (feta cheese, onions) and my request was accommodated with no questions asked. My friends enjoyed their breakfast as well. The waffle was perfectly cooked and the hot syrup the waitress brought us out made it so much better. The French toast, although it didn’t look great, tasted fantastic. Our waitress was attentive, personable, knowledgeable & offered helpful suggestions.
All in all this was an epic first experience. I would recommend this diner to anyone! The menu offers a pretty broad selection to please even the pickiest of eaters. I will be back a lot sooner rather than later :-)

I love the Infinity! Its the best diner in the world. I eat there several times a month & I always look forwards to it. Can’t beat the lamb, the short ribs, the flounder oreganato, and the service!
PC

Could be better. Stopped in for brunch before hitting the Tanger Outlets in Deer Park. Apple-​Cinnamon Pancakes were fabulously decadent and delish, while the Egg Burrito wasn’t good. It seemed thrown together with waste products in the kitchen. The eggs way overcooked, bacon was chewy and fatty not crispy, cold cheese. Everything also came out TOO quick, a red flag in my mind. The side of hash-​browns were ok. Coffee, thank goodness, was above average. Wouldn’t rush back here, However I’m willing to return to try something off the lunch /​dinner part of the menu.

Service is great. We had Kathy waiting on us. Very pleasant very accommodating.
Food was mediocre. Omlet overcooked and under seasoned. Home fries seemed like leftover from breakfast with hard burned pieces and also completely under seasoned.
Hubby enjoyed his more. Had a Belgium waffle. Lightly crisp and tender in the middle. Although his food was served on a plate that had multiple big chips.
Would have rated 2 stars if not for the great server.
Was really hoping for a great diner.

Just a visitor not a regular but quick service, huge delicious portion. Husband even enjoyed split pea soup. Clean. Unique décor friendly staff. Really good experience. Would stop again.
They even have juke boxes.

So far my husband and I have come here twice. The portions are huge and the staff is very friendly. When you first walk in you automatically get a bread basket and some cold pasta with chick peas and olive oil as a complimentary meal starter. You are also asked if you want a complimentary glass of wine.
The first time we came it was pretty busy so our waitress didn’t come by very often, but the second time we came the waitress and the hostess both made sure our meals were okay and kept asking us if everything was okay.
The bread was great it was worth the calories! I’m trying to stay away from bread and keep my bread and carb intake limited. If I choose to eat a piece of bread now it needs to be good since I’m not having it so often. My husband said the bread was good from the bread basket and he was right.
I got spinach pie the first time we came here, and the Arizona salad without the chicken the second time. The salad was huge, they gave me extra cheese and extra walnuts when they found out I don’t eat meat. I ate some salad at dinner, then I ate some the next day after that I had to throw it away because salad doesn’t last long in the fridge before it starts getting soggy.
My husband had the chicken parm twice. Definitely a top diner!