Domenic’s Apizza

Excellent pizza. Get bacon and onion with raw bacon cooked on the pizza all pizza and dinners are awesome great value.

I’m not sure what all these other reviewers have been eating. Tried this place for the first time today and it was one of the worst pizza places I have tried. I tried a slice of cheese pizza. It was lukewarm and about an inch thick of dough with a little bit of cheese and sauce on top. It was microwave pizza quality at $ 2 a slice. I tried a steak and cheese sub. Easily the worst steak and cheese I’ve ever had. The steak was cold cut roast beef toasted. The vegetables were awful and wilted.
On top of that the owner appeared fairly unfriendly and apathetic. The restaurant itself isn’t fantastic but I do not like to make judgements based solely on that. Also a very small menu.

Grossest pizza. Doughy with little cheese or sauce. Garden salad was wilted lettuce with a can of black olives…

I’ve never left a review on Unilocal because I’m Way too lazy but after tasting this pizza I felt obligated. I’ve been living in West Haven for 3 years now and this is the best pizza in town. it might even be good enough to give pepes a run for their money.

Awesome hot subs:)! First time my husband took me here, I just fell in love with Dominic’s subs.

Vinnie’s Apizza of Woodmont in the early 70’s was the high water mark for pizza in my life. Since their closing, Domenic’s has been the absolute best place in the area for really good pizza. The old Mama T’s on the north side of Rt. 1 in Milford was a close second.
A wonderful little place that’s been around forever. Remember Grand Union? They were here right across the parking lot making pizza back then.
Their pizza is truly fantastic. Thin crust, cooked just right every time and quickly. 15 minutes each and every time you call or stop in and order. Enough time to cruise across the street and sit on a bench at the beach & watch the waves, or hit The Dive Bar and/​or Oyster River Tavern both located within throwing distance for a quick pop or three.
Why would you go anywhere else? I’m think I’m going to get a job at the small bike shop next to Grand Uni…, er, Dollar Store, live in my classic old RV mid-​parking lot, and love life. Baybrook rules!
This place is so worthy of 5 stars.
I’ll gladly pay $ 1100 for a large pie here any Saturday night. ;)