Pizzarena

Great service in the store. Guys at the counter and wait staff are very friendly and accommodating. The place looks awesome since they renovated and expanded.
Not so crazy about the food here lately though. The sauce seems to be getting more watery and usually a dish comes with way too much of it. The variety of pizza is great, but most of the time it tastes like it’s been sitting out on the counter too long.

The margarita pizza beats every pizza place out there!!! You guys are the best and always so nice!!! all the food is great never a disappointment !!!

This is our go to for pizza, hands down the best in town. The garlic knots are great too!

great pizza and very nice employees. gotta love this place.

Not the best pizza at all but it’s the only pizzeria around (for now). I get it. Also pick up is best because last time I had it delivered and it took over an hour and arrived cold. When I called to complain I was told to put it in the oven for ten minutes and it’ll be okay. Lol. Nope and then I spoke to a manager who was more like a teenage girl and she said that was the best they can do. thanks buddy I’ll take my business elsewhere. So for that, never again.

Clean Place, very nice people, best sicilian pie around. highly recommend this place.

Every time I call I never can get through. Either you need a new number or a new hostess. It’s been three weeks & I can’t even ask questions on the menu smh

I have been coming to Pizzarena for their pizza for many years now. Their pies are simply the best in Rockland County, and I have been a resident for over 45 years and have tried many other places. Tasty, the right amount of ingredients. The regular slice is spectacular and the specialty slices are also excellent. I have enjoyed dinners there as well and I think they are first rate.
Besides the pizza, the owner of the restaurant is the single nicest, most welcoming businessman I have ever met. Rich is just an impressive, nice, friendly man who makes you want to come back to his restaurant. They have recently increased the size of their restaurant, adding a whole new sit down area and that made me feel great for Rich. Hard work and impeccable manners have served him well through the years!
Go to Pizzarena and try their pizza. It’s the very best in Rockland County.

Came here after the pool with the family! Everyone absolutely loved the pizza: Sicilians, Grandma, & BBQ Chicken. Definitely will be returning!

Pizzarena has great pizza! Weekday specials are really good deals. Rich and his staff are very friendly!

Had Pizzarena cater my daughters graduation party. GREAT FOOD. All the guests (all ages) loved it. The sausage and pepper, penne vodka, chicken francaise and cavatelli with broccoli were all amazing. Thanks for everything!

This was our first time at Pizzarena, but definitely not the last. We had a ½ white with spinach and ½ fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, with whole wheat crust. This pizza was simply heavenly. It was hard to say which ½ was best as they both were among the best I have ever had, and I am a pizza enthousiast. The white side was loaded with creamy ricotta and the spinach was well seasoned with just the right amount of garlic (not too heavy). The mozzarella and tomatoes had fresh basil and was bursting with flavor. We asked for a side of sauce, which was also very tasty.
We did not order salads, but saw our neighbors’ and it also looked very nice.
The service was excellent, and everyone was very friendly. They made us feel welcome. They worked as a team and both servers made sure we had all we needed.
The place was very clean, including the restrooms! It is a notch above your typical pizzeria! Definitely a keeper!

Thin Crust Sicilian is simply outstanding. Reminds me of Rizzo’s in Astoria. The Service was fantastic.

Food is good. Pizza is great. Stay away from anything with marinara sauce as it tastes like pure sugar. tick with the pink sauces. S

I have been coming here for years. Great pizza, great atmosphere. Rich and all that work there make you feel welcome all the time. The food is always on par. I was so sad when I stopped by and saw the placed closed down. Then I realized they were coming back better than ever. Thanks for being my place to go. And thanks for having the garlic knots and stuffed meat pizza.

Small but excellent food… Best pasta at a pizza place… One of those silent but excellent. Restaurants

Have been there several times over the last few months. Service above average, food is very good & always comes out piping hot. Wonderful hosts & the BYOB feature works for our usual group of 6. The recent expansion has made this into a go to place!

I moved here recently and was quite happy to discover Pizzarena! I moved from Nyack. Which has several options in not only pizza but also any kind of food you may be craving at almost any time. Shortly after moving here I wanted to order out and found there weren’t many options locally. I tried one pizza place around the corner but it didn’t hit the spot! Finally I noticed Pizzarena. I have literally been going there at least once — twice a week minimum. The service is friendly. Good made with love. And quick! Their sauce is something is something to be admired. So I always order extra! I highly recommend !

Everything on the menu is excellent! Come for lunch or dinner you cant go wrong.
Remember its BYOB and order your fav dish, the ambience, the service is fantastic! The food is perfecto! Best local place for pizza or italian cuisine. I promise you, its worth the visit!

I’ve been going to Pizzarena for years. I always felt their pizza is first rate and I will Continue to give them business. I stopped to have a quiet sit down before my meeting… An early dinner.
My server was pleasant and quick on the mark.
She brought my appetizer of mussels in short order. Unfortunately, quite a number (6 or 8) mussels hadn’t opened and I’m not taking that chance.
My entrée came, canateli bolognese «with a hearty meat sauce», it was more like marinara with a trace of meat and was so hot (heat, not spice) I could barely eat it. It was okay… Only okay.
I’ll always go back to Pizzarena and their new store is very nice. BUT, with two kids in the restaurant, it was very noisy and I beat a hasty retreat. Sitting in the dining room, I felt I was part of the conversations in the pizzeria area.
A partition would go a long way.