Firehouse Pizza

I don’t know how this place has such a great rating–
Firehouse pizza; my opinion was they should burn this place down…
Maybe if the pizza wasn’t sitting there for days, and they used better ingredients I’d have something less negative to say but they weren’t even friendly behind the counter.
Skip this place
Go anywhere else.

Pizza and calzone i had here was pretty good. Dining area is small with small tables and no chairs. Good for takeout. Owner was pretty cool too.

Ive eaten here a few times for lunch and the pizza is all Ive had, so i really don’t know how the rest of the food is. But what i can tell you is that the owner provides good customer service and always appreciates the business and the pizza is pretty good and fresh.

Great pizza. Not being from New York, I have tried many local pizzerias and I must say, this one is by far the best pizza in the area. The owner really knows how to make Italian food the right way.

Michael the owner is a classically trained chef. The pizza is wonderful and the crust of the pizza is truly upper crust (pun intended). I highly recommend the calzone… especially the one with spinach. My Husband loves the meat version.
It is a cute place and also… Michael is a real fireman in WHB.
Cheap and good… hard to find in the Hamptons.

Not bad pizza — service is good too. Best in WHB? Hardly. But decent. Keep in mind I live 2,500 miles away so any NY pizza is great pizza. Man, I miss NY pizza already at it’s only been 2 days…

Firehouse pizza is a pretty cool place. The inside is decked out with fireman/​firehouse stuff. The pizza is pretty good as well. They only seem to serve pizza though, didn’t see any other dinner options.
There also isn’t any place to sit down and eat inside.

The best pizza in whb. Have a buffalo chicken slice. You will not be disappointed. The only thing I don’t like is that the village does not allow them to have seats. But in the summer they have picnick tables.

Firehouse Pizza is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Being from further up the Island, I consider myself somewhat of a pizza snob and for years I have complained about the lack of quality pizza on the east end. My complaining days are over. The pizza here is made from the best quality ingredients and is always hot and freshly made. There are all kinds of specialty pizzas and each one is made with the perfect amount and mix of ingredients. I’ve yet to try the salads and sandwiches because the pizza is so good I can’t get tired of it but I hear that they are of equal quality.
There is outdoor seating around the side of the building that is quite nice but unfortunately there is no seating inside the restaurant. Only standing room tables. This small laps in comfort is more than made up for when you consider how superior the food is when compared to any other pizza in the area. I’ve seen other reviews that say the pizza has too much cheese. I understand how some people might think so however when you are given such high quality mozzarella, it does not seem as heavy as eating pizza made with lots of cheap low quality mozzarella. In addition, you can always order a pie with less cheese. They seem more than happy to make you a pizza any way except badly.