Tonino’s Pizza

Best Pizza in three towns! Wide variety of Italian food.

The best in the WHB area, and reasonably priced, too. Intensely good fried calamari, satisfying homemade soups, and the house specialty, pasta bolognese, is a must– incredibly delicious. Look no further for amazing Italian food!

Love the food and the workers are some of the nicest people I’ve ever met. I live here all year long and it’s the only place I like getting pizza and delivers!

Good pizza. Thicker crust than I like; more cheese than I like. Pretty pricey I would say. But overall I was happy as was my wife and our old friends, the Tobiessens. Our pizza was loaded with vegetables and baked perfectly
We’ll be back soon.

The best thing you can do is not walk inn to this place. Overrated pizza sucks. Overpriced Chewy not cook properly taste like doe. No pride here they just what to make money. Entrees taste the same. I vowed never to walk back into this place again they just did me wrong. My wife said sauce taste like from a can. No culinary chefs here enough said !

Our family has been coming to me the Hamptons for decades and Tonino’s is the go to Pizza place in Westhampton. Subs also not bad.

What a terrific find. The food is excellent. Fresh. Delicious. Inexpensive. What more can you ask for? The staff is sweet and helpful. Not snotty at all. We had chicken parm and it was plenty for two. Next day we had eggplant parm. The wait was a little long but the reward was freshly thin sliced eggplant in a lovely sauce. Again plenty for two. My friend swears the grandma pizza is the best she has eaten anywhere in the world. That’s my next meal. Don’t hesitate to eat here. You will be very happy with your meal.

No. There are no pizza rolls. That’s ‘Totino’s,’ you ignoramus.
Tonino’s does have pizza. And actually, they do have rolls too; I think I saw chicken and sausage. But no pizza rolls.* This shouldn’t really matter, because those frozen abominations are like mini Hot Pockets, which I now avoid because I like it when my intestinal tract works properly.**
Anyhoo, Tonino’s serves the best pizza I’ve had in Westhampton Beach. Admittedly, the only pizza I’ve had in Westhampton Beach, but I loved every second of the face-​stuffing.
Facts:
The pepperoni and mushroom pie is a clear winner over the sausage and peppers.
The garlic knots are breadier than you might imagine, but awesome. Get extra sauce.
The Caesar salad is great.
The wings aren’t. But we still ate them, because wings.
The mini-​cheesecakes are dope.
And the service was excellent as well.
It was a bit pricier than expected, but anytime a town has a «Beach» in its name, it’s going to be expensive. If there’s also a «Hampton,» you’re going to have a bad time.
_​_​_​_​_​_​_​_​_​_​_​_​_​
*If this is a serious issue for you, I’m assuming you can roll up their pizza.
**

This is what happened tonight:
6:16pm: arrived at Westhampton beach train station. My train arrives at 6:30pm. Starving!
6:17pm: ordered urgent pizza delivery to the station. They were excited for the mission.
6:25pm: pizza pie delivered with a smile.
6:30om: boarded train with a full pie in hand.
Thank you!

Tried it for the first time 3 weeks ago & I am in love !!! Grandma pizza was amazing and so was the grilled chicken Caesar salad !!! I am going to order from you guys right now !!! LOL !!! Keep up the good work guys !!! When I get myself some wheels I’ll make sure to come down there and sit and stuff my face !!! LOL

We are visiting our family and this is our first time being here in WHB. We had a very active day and my wife was really craving italian, our family recommended Baby moon, but after looking at the reviews and their website we decided that their price points and non caryout was not what we where looking for. We did a search for Italian food in WHB and Toninos came up. After looking at their website and looking at the reviews we decided to give it a shot. All we can say is WOW next time we are in town we will definitely be coming back and our family who lives here will be back as well. You get a lot of food that is fresh and hot and just what you need after a very eventful day. Thank you guys so much. My wife is in heaven and as we all know, «happy wife, happy life.»

Quick service and clean. Pizza dough was baked perfect, but sauce was disappointing. Sauce could be bolder. Also, the pizza could use some more sauce quantity added. Just okay… I’d go for papa johns instead if it was closer.

I felt compelled to write this review to say woohooo I love the new renovations! The place has this nice indoor/​outdoor thing going on now. Really nice seating. It’s really neat. There are cool plants allover. So when the sun shines in during the afternoon, it’s pretty beautiful. Great atmosphere to enjoy a good slice in. I’ve only tried to spinach ricotta slice (yum!) but everything else looked really good. Also, the staff was really nice. There’s like 3 other options in the area and I just think the quality of food, plus the quality of the service (real nice family/​friendly feel) makes this the best one. So to me, this is the best pizza place in town.

Wow. I hate to be a downer.
It is the best pizza in WHB. Honestly. It’s really the only game in town for delivery: I don’t think Baby Moon’s delivers.
Sit outside when it’s nice out and it’s almost always nice outside in WHB.
But kids, this is marginally better than frozen. Any pizza is better than no pizza, just like any sex is better than no sex.
I still order from here like like 20 times a summer.

Toninos definitely has great NY style, thin crust pizza down pat with such a great variety of flavors. Their taco salad and 3 cheese pizza were divine. If anyone has problems with this place, it’s probably that they can’t get enough of the pizza from here.

I really like their grandma pie. Their sauce is very good. I like to order it with extra cheese. It gives it a boost of heaven. You know good pizza when it taste great the next day right out of your toaster oven. Also enjoy their chicken wings and salads. Not to mention they deliver. Thats a wonderful bonus.

Great pizza. Tonino’s is open all year, which is great. After all the crowds clear out, I will still be surfing and enjoying the best pizza without the crowds.

This place has pretty good pizza if you like crunchy and medium-​thin crust. It is quick on on the way out of the Hamptons.

The pizza at toninos is pretty good. The thing i liked the most was that they have good lunch specials and deals.

The best pizza in town