Peter Andrews

There is something at PeterAndrews for everybody and great deals$. They carry things you can’t find anywhere else. Super eclectic. *Great for gift giving*. They even carry awesome clothes and jewelry amongst cool glassware, art, unique furniture, and a million other things. They even do gift wrap.
They are a mom and pop shop that’s been there for about 30 years which is really a cool look for Williston Park which in the past year (the street Peter Andrews is on) opened a few awesome new restaurants (fresca crêpe place, miyabi, sangria, xarello, bbg’s, sweet to lick, vegan bakery, and of course theres always Frantonis, and hildabrants)
We must keep these mom and pop shops alive. We don’t need anymore mall like chain stores taking over the businesses that give WP a unique vibe and life.

What a find! Great gifts and very helpful people. Reminds me of stores of the past! They even have a gift wrapping department!

Peter Andrews is a store that’s truly one of a kind. My mom has been shopping here ever since they opened. She actually happens to know the owner from the flea market he used to sell at before the store opened. I’ve gotten various gifts here such as serving platters, vases, chip & dip bowls, scarves, hats… you name it! We have also gotten many things for our home at Peter Andrews. If you really think about it, where exactly does one get gifts like this? BIg box stores don’t have the interesting and unique items that Peter Andrews sells.
The price point definitely ranges depending on what you’re looking for, but I believe you’ll find something if you have a certain price point in mind. I would definitely stop by if your’e looking to get someone a gift or if you’re looking to get some nice household items for yourself! Also, their other store has awesome furniture! I love the pieces they have, especially the painted furniture.

This place is horrible! Overpriced and complete snobs! I ordered a dining room table and six chairs from them. When it came in it was the wrong table completely! When purchasing the table I only asked two questions: «How many leafs come with the table so I can extend it and how big are the leafs?» She told me there were 2 leafs. On that assumption I ordered the table and when the wrong one came I immediately sent it back. I went to the store and simply said that I wanted the table that I was promised. They said that the shape I ordered does not come with 2 leafs. So I simply said that since it was not the table that my wife had wanted to just refund my money and I’ll find something else. They refused! Their salesperson misinformed me and they actually refused!!! I spoke to everyone in that company from bottom to top! Every person that I spoke to was ruder and more snobbish than the one before. I have been a sales manager for a long time and this is no way to do business. They offered me other tables in different styles of course, but that was not what my wife wanted! I would give them zero stars if I could! Never shop here!

Went in to purchase an anniversary gift for our children. Found a Nambe cheese board marked $ 200 less 20% and paid $ 160. After getting home did a search and found that every other store was selling it for $ 100! Went back the next day and the explanation was that they had a problem with some products that had the wrong price marked on them. They raise the price and offer a discount to make you think that you are getting a great deal. They did honor the lower price after I returned to the store.

PROS: Got some gorgeous glasses for only $ 5 each, as well as an antique silver corkscrew for only $ 7. Great items!
CONS: The staff acted like we were a bother. I had my son in a stroller, and my mother-​in-​law was with us using her walker, and when we went into the furniture section, the staff there were visibly annoyed that we expected them to move two feet to the side so we could get by. I’m not terribly sensitive but it was so obvious and palpable that we just left that section. My mother-​in-​law has impeccable taste and money to spend on décor — it was a stupid mistake on their part.
I might return. Got some great stuff but nothing I can’t find elsewhere without the attitude.

I received a wedding gift from a family member from this store. A cake knife set. It arrived used as this was clearly a returned item that had been sent to me.
I got the sense from the woman’s reaction that this is not an out of the ordinary complaint for them.
Upon trying to call the store to speak with someone about a replacement or refund, I was placed on hold only to be hung up on. Upon calling back, I was basically yelled at because they were trying to close up and the woman who answered was trying to find a manager. I was placed on hold again for a few minutes before I decided to just hang up.
Classy! Will edit this review if I’m able to actually talk to someone about the item to reflect the rest of the story.

The smaller sibling to the Huntington location.
I love Peter Andrews and a few years back when I realized they had a second location conveniently located on my way to work, I was happy.
That being said, I have to admit that the Williston Park location doesn’t hold a candle to the Huntington location.
This location is about ²⁄₃ smaller than Huntington and as such, suffers from the lack of selection Huntington has to offer. You can still score some good stuff but you have to do some heavy duty searching.
I won’t give up on them but I still find myself trekking over to Huntington more than this location.