Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

I think there might be some crack in this Italian ice cause I keep coming back. I’m so happy to give those girls my 5 dollars it’s ridiculous. Black cherry and chocolate baby, black cherry and chocolate.

This place is awesome. Not only is the food just delicious but there ate like 25 flavor of super smooth Italian ice to choose from. They make these gelati things that are Italian ice swirled with soft serve ice cream. On top of the amazing selection and quality the prices are awesome also. Family of 4 for about 11 dollars today. Love this place.

Great way to end a night. Wonderful evening great tasting treats. I think I’m addicted. Pineapple and Coconut! Hmmmmm

So happy to have found Jeremiah’s. We have found it interesting that in moving to Orlando from New Jersey that there would be LOTS of great ice cream places. Sadly, not so. And we thought even more impossible to find Italian Ice. Well we hit that here at Jeremiah’s. Flavorful and creamy plus they have gelati which is a mix of soft ice cream and Italian Ice. Lots of flavors which we will have to come back and try. The store is kind of buried «under» the LA Fitness in kind of an alleyway so it was a little difficult to find. Parking in the front off Conroy Windermere is tight so we worked our way to the rear of the building but didn’t see a sign anywhere so we did the logical thing — followed the kids from the parking lot which lead us to the store. They have various flavors of soft ice cream too. But doesn’t look like they have hard ice cream which is fine for us as we prefer Italian Ice. Sign up for their club online and get freebie coupons to use on your first visit —
. If you order the gelati, small is pretty small because it’s half ice and half ice cream. So get medium or larger or if you’re sharing, get 2 small ices and one small ice cream. And they accept credit cards.

We love the piña colada gelati with vanilla! The small is the perfect size for a single person. We’ve been to the ones in Winter Park and alafaya and do find it interesting that they choose to hire young girls that all where booty shorts, but the product they sell are good.

The ices taste amazing, you can tell they’re fresh! My grandmother said she’s never tasted anything like it and has to come back to try more flavors. The staff is super friendly and the service is quick. The lines are crazy long, but they get it x down so quickly with a smile.

Love this place. Great selections. Staff are very friendly. So many flavors that entices you to come again and again. Like how it is set up.

I loveeee gelati, so when we walked by Jeremiah’s, I knew we had to stop by for dessert after lunch. I got the mango italian ice with vanilla soft serve and it was amazing! I ordered a small, which was good enough for me, but for a little more, you do receive a more generous portion. You can sample any flavors before making a decision, which was nice. I tried the horchata, which was delicious, but the mango was calling my name!

What a disappointment! I’ve seen the long lines and read the great reviews and was expecting much, more. Brought my entire family to try this place out and we all had the same reaction, eha. My daughter threw most of hers away. Save your money and go someplace else. This place is lost on me!
The best part of the experience was the cute servers.

Jeremiah’s is always delicious. The price seems inexpensive, but if you compare it to a half gallon of ice cream at the grocery store, it seems pricey… but then again, this is not your average frozen treat. This location was a little hard to find with my GPS and the parking lot was a bit confusing in the rain, but we eventually arrived. The staff is always really nice and bubbly.
I love the variety of Italian ice, but it also makes me spend more time deciding on what I want. I end up getting a small gelati with two different Italian ice flavors paired with vanilla soft serve. This time I matched Café Latte and Sea Salted Caramel with vanilla soft serve. It was 47 degrees outside, but we still seemed to enjoy our sweets as we shivered under the ceiling fans (I’m not sure why they had them on).
I usually would not come to this location, but I was in the area. I would definitely recommend this location or even return if I am back in the area.

I am addicted. I even take the long way home just so I have an excuse to stop for a scoop. I recommend mixing and matching ice only, with soft serve (gelati) or mix and match both and make it your own. My favorite combination is the Black Cherry with Vanilla or the Pina Colada and Strawberry. I cannot be happier that new locations are popping up around Central Florida all the time.
Sign up to join their list and receive coupons and news about events and new locations!

My first time visiting Florida and I had a sweet tooth for some gelato. This place sure hit the spot! It was sooo good I actually came back the next day for another one.
The workers are girls who aren’t tooo enthusiastic about their job but still make sure you get the right flavors. I ordered the gelati swirl with p nutty and cookies and crème and let me tell you, the P Nutty is to die for. I recommend the P Nutty or the mango. The flavors are light and creamy but not as heavy as ice cream.
I love love love this place! Please open one on the West Coast!

Came here for «spirit night» to support my kids school as 10% of proceeds go back to the school. They had soft serve ice cream and Italian ice with all different flavors. They also mix the together and call it «gelati»…no not gelato :)
Weird pricing as they had a small for $ 3.10 and a large for $ 4.50 yet the large was twice the size of the small. You can definitely share the large size unless you are a large individual. Lol
Cute girls behind the counter do a good job of serving and making the concoctions to order.

I think I fell in love. I had the sea salted caramel gelati. It taste better with every bite

This is definitely the place to go when you’re in the mood for some gelato! We stopped on by with the ‘2 for 1′ coupon I received from joining the J-​List; what a great deal! For about $ 4 (medium) we were able to satisfy (and then some) our sweet tooth with very delicious gelato.
I ordered a Cookie Butter & Salted Caramel with vanilla ice cream while my gf opted for a Cookies n’ Cream with vanilla ice cream. I enjoyed her gelato, but I absolutely loved my combination. I couldn’t have devoured it any quicker. Not only does Jeremiah’s offer a great tasting product, but they offer a generous portion size, especially considering the price.
I’ve read that this location can get crowded, but the line seemed short during our Saturday evening trip. However, I can see how seating would be an issue since there were only a handful of tables. The service seemed friendly and I really have no complaints.
I can see myself returning sooner rather than later.

Pretty solid selection and the service was really quick. I love their gelati! The amount of gelati you get for the price is great. For $ 3 a few coins, you can get a delectable swirl of Italian ice and soft serve.
Try to chocolate soft serve with raspberry Italian ice. It is like Valentine’s Day in a cup! Their sister chain Gelati Joe’s in Lakeland offers Pineapple Dole Whips for $ 2 and I was a little bummed that Jeremiah’s didn’t.
Make sure to sign up for the Jeremiah’s text alerts. There’s always chances for free gelati! Who doesn’t love that?

I only knocked off a star for two things: the atmosphere & the service. The food is really good though.
We came late Monday night around 10pm & saw the huge line and mass of people. Its tucked away in a dark shopping center so the mob of people was surprising. After we found a fairly close parking spot we walked up & heard it before we saw it…
I felt like I was back in high school & I even asked my boyfriend if there was a high school nearby or something. It’s a TON of high school aged kids sitting around & being VERY loud. I could barely hear myself think. Its a walk up window type of place but we couldn’t seem to figure out where the line was or who was just standing around.
I was able to sign up for the J-​List while waiting in line & very quickly received an email for buy one get one free, which was nice! The prices weren’t bad though, $ 3 for a medium gelati (half Italian ice, half soft serve) & the medium was wayyyy more than enough, the small would’ve been fine.
Considering our interaction with our server lasted all of four minutes, it wasn’t the most pleasant experience but then again it looked like the cheerleading squad was working the entire place. I felt very rushed, and she offered no help (or smiles). I asked for a sample & got a very impatient «Anything ELSE?» And immediately had the fear of God for asking for a sample (despite stickers lining the windows saying «samples all day every day»). I just went with one of he suggested combos, peanut butter Italian ice with chocolate soft serve, because I felt rushed. My boyfriend got orange ice with vanilla. Despite there being a nice looking park across the street and lots of (full) tables we decided to leave because we couldn’t stand the high school lunch table vibe.
All in all our food was really good, the soft serve was sweet and delicious and the Italian ice was good. The portions are huge and at a great price. We’ll definitely be back & hopefully with a little less crowd.

Sign up for the J-​List and be treated to BOGO coupons. Ices have a great flavor and when complemented with ice cream (Gelati) they are even better. The flavors do change, but there are enough flavors to explore. I am a big fan of Pumpkin during the fall. Now cookies and cream is probably my favorite and cake batter is second. I was disappointed with Horchata which was a little weak on flavor. I would also add the sizes run on the big side. I am satisfied with a small galati when I go to Jeremiahs. Overall an inexpensive treat and covered outdoor only seating to enjoy.

Jeremiah’s is by and far my favorite Italian ice place. They have a good variety of flavors that actually taste like what they claim to be, and creamy light, soft serve ice cream that goes perfectly with the Italian ice. If you’ve never tried the mix, it’s very delicious and definitely something you’ve got to try.
My favorite flavors include banana, lime, and strawberry lemon. I like the fruit flavors myself and find the chocolate and savory (like peanut butter) flavors to be too weird in ice form myself.
This location is very nice — it’s new, has a great shady area or park across the way to sit, and the employee working that day was really sweet and helpful.

Happy to have a Jeremiah’s a little closer to home! This location is part of a growing plaza called the Grove at Isleworth. Recently this complex also added a Dexter’s location and a BurgerFi is set to open soon. This area is definitely becoming a hot spot!
Jeremiah’s features such a wide variety of rotating italian ice flavors, so there is always something new to try. As is typical of Jermiah’s, this location is counter service only, with no indoor space for patrons, which I think works fine for their business. This location had a nice covered outdoor space, which featured several picnic benches and some counter space as well. I visited on a Sunday evening and the place was hopping! They were well staffed though and the line moved fast.
The main items you can enjoy at Jeremiah’s are vanilla/​chocolate soft serve, italian ice, or gelati, which is a layering of italian ice and gelati.
This trip, I enjoyed the gelati– vanilla ice cream with some cocount and horchata italian ice (you can get up to three different flavors in a small!). Loved the mix of the icy and creamy textures and the interesting flavor choices. Yum!
As a bonus you are also encouraged to try samples of flavors that are new to you! For me, that helps a lot with my indecisiveness!