Stromboli’s NY Pizzeria

This place is a hidden gem. Excellent value for your money, this is hands down my favorite pizza in Orlando. The sauce and crust are perfection. If you like NY-​style pizza, give this place a shot. They also give a Disney Cast Member discount.

Always fresh, always friendly… great neighborhood pizzeria, and don’t miss the pepperoni roll!

Decent pizza but I wouldn’t call it NY pizza at all. The prices are a little extreme for my opinion considering the Caesar salad with chicken that I ordered had maybe half a thin sliced breast on it. Pizza was okay after a long day at Epcot though.

We live right around the corner from Stromboli’s. We usually order delivery ($ 3.00 delivery fee) but have been in to pick up a couple times. Small, quaint and friendly atmosphere. Delivery is fast and drivers are polite. Would definitely recommend Stromboli’s to a friend! Be sure to try the meatball parm hero!!!

The food was okay, it’s the only local pizza place in the immediate area so I’d go again. The workers were super nice but the food was just okay. It was decent not great, but the prices were okay so it was worth it.

I start by calling in my Order were I’m greeted by a loud automated system and I wait 2 mins to get someone on the line, and that’s usually is accompanied by the answering and saying to hold. After I finish My order they tell me 30 min each time. I get there in 30 min and they tell me it’s going to be another min or 2. So I wait, then the cook puts my order in the hot box they hold it in and tells nothing to the front cashier. Not sure if it’s mine I wait patiently and sure enough it is and I have waited another 5 min. That’s on top of the food being ok.

I agree with Janet’s review. This place does a great job of doing what it intends to be: a reasonably priced solid-​quality pizza restaurant. I got the Viagra pizza and liked it (sx joke!).
Friendly staff.
Not life changing pizza, but given the paltry pizza possibilities present in west Orange County, this place is definitely my current go to for pizza around my house in Winter Garden /​Windermere.

Not too far from where I live, this is my go to Pizza place and I’m happy it is. The pizza is always amazing as are the garlic knots. It is the closest to NY style Pizza I have had in the Orlando area and love ordering from here.
I should mention that anything that’s not Pizza should be ordered at your own discretion. This isn’t an Italian restaurant so don’t expect great Italian Dishes. Stick to Pizza and you will be very satisfied. (The Cannoli is an exception to this rule).
Highly recommend.

This place is what it is. It’s a pizza joint and they do it well. Their sausage rolls and Strombolis are wonderful. Garlic puffies are addictive. Traditional antipasto salad. Not an ear in place. Have it delivered or pick it up. Never had an order arrive wrong. More NY style than Chicago but I wouldn’t call in thin crust. It’s just right.

So Strombolis refuse to NOT slice a pizza if I order it?! Never have I had a pizza place refuse to NOT slice one before! She was SO rude about it too!!! I asked her why they refuse when every other pizza place can accommodate this simple request, she said she would ASK the cooks if they would «allow» this but soubtful. I told her not to bother & that I wouldn’t want to order from somewhere so rude! Glad I’ve never given them my money!

This is my go-​to pizza place. It’s near where I live and I have consistently gotten great tasting pizza. I love their pizza sauce and the toppings are high-​quality. I recommend the garlic puffies as well. So yummy!

This casual place is my favorite for pizza and casual Italian dining. Their red sauce is fresh and delicious – not that overly sweet tomato paste stuff you find in many Italian restaurants. The food is always great, and the eggplant parm is the BEST I’ve ever had. As someone who lived in the northeast a few years, I can say Strombolis is the real deal!
Note: they do pizza by the slice

Love this place! Great Italian food. Philly steak roll is delicious! Spaghetti & lasagna is awesome & the pizza is really the best! Order in or dine out! The people are friendly and the food is fabulous!

Consistently good pizza. Always ready at the promised time. Good customer service. Good for takeout or very casual dine-​in. Plenty of parking.

I swear I’ve written a review of this place but it’s nowhere to be found and not in the hidden reviews. Oh well…
Just moved from NJ and the reviews of this place were kinda promising. Sadly it’s FAR from NYC pizza. I’ve tried the place easily 4 or 5x bc it’s so close to home but finally gave up trying to like anything on the menu.
The pizza wasn’t bad the first time we went but the cheese was a cheaper mozz that pretty much liquefies when heated. And not in a normal hot mozz kind of way. The stuffed shells and manicotti all seem to be microwaved and dry the few times we tried them too. Antipasto salad? More of the same. Cheap ingredients for everything we ordered.
Also…what type of ‘authentic’ Italian NYC pizzeria doesn’t carry just plain olive oil and vinegar??? The only options we had every time for our iceberg salad was the tubs of gross fake Italian dressing (and other dressings) that wholesalers sell. Really? Not even a bottle of real Italian olive oil? Red wine or balsamic vinegar? I asked every single time we went and every time they looked at me like I had 5 heads.

Friday night is typically Stromboli’s NY Pizzeria night at our house. Got the meatball and Italian sausage combo (appetizer) and their garlic puffs for the wife and I. The boys will only eat Stromboli’s cheese pizza, so we got them a Large pie. Dinner tonight and lunch tomorrow for the boys.
Food is always good. We especially love the sauce they use on their pizzas and in our case, the meatballs and sausage. Being from NY, I’m always happy with their NY styled pizzas. We’ve tried numerous things on the menu and are seldom disappointed. This is our preferred local pizzeria.

Best ny style pizza in the area, the closest to tri-​state area Pizzaria pizza you can find. Family run– the owners are from one of the boroughs of NYC. Hidden gem.

This place has good pizza. Courteous staff, fresh ingredients, quick service. Convenient location. We ordered a cheese pie extra crispy and it was delicious. They’re a bit pricey but it’s Windermere, so that’s expected. But definitely worth it if you like homemade pie. We will definitely visit again.

The 5 star rating describes this place perfect. As good as it gets. I am originally from the Bronx and this is the closest you will get to a true authentic New York City pizza shop. It is impossible for anything down here to be as authentic as NY pizza because of the water but this place works some magic.
Almost everything here is made from scratch, and is made fresh to order. If you are in a hurry be sure to call ahead of time as they do not keep food sitting around all day only to be heated up when you come and order. They do have a big menu for a pizza place and I have had a number of items and have never been disappointed.
If you have migrated to this area from the northeast or are visiting from out of town and need a NY pizza fix, this is your place.

I like Stromboli’s. The pizza is really really good. It IS a bit pricey. The only way to get around it is to sign up for the club or emails specials. I’ve also had their meatball appetizer, different garlic knots (try the puffs, they are AMAZING) and their hero subs. Again, all very good.
The one time I did delivery, I noticed they charge $ 3 for that, so I am paying that in addition to tipping the driver, so delivery gets pricey too.
I did order a salad once, and it left something to be desired. Although the salad was large in portion, it felt thrown together with whatever ingredients were used for pizza, not worth the hefty price tag. Also– the menu is extensive for a «pizza place» with a lot of options, however, there is nothing with a white sauce, everything comes with a tomato base. If you are looking for something along the lines of fettuccine Alfredo, they don’t have it.
I will be back certainly, as the food is very good. However, this is a splurge for us, not a weekly Friday night pizza place.