Molly’s Cupcakes ‘N’ More

The service was awesome and sweet with a nice location. Inside is cute! But really I went there for good cupcakes. They were dry and tasted like store bought mix. The icing was yummy! But the cake itself wasn’t a wow.

I’ll start by saying I’ve never been to the physical location of this bakery, but I’ve tried some of their items when I’ve purchased elsewhere (primarily at The Good Life in Raymond) and holy CRAP, so good. Specifically the seven layer bar… absolute heaven. A decently sized bar which you’ll want to tackle all in one go but it’s so incredibly decadent and intense that there’s no way you can handle it, which is kind of great because then you have a second serving for later. YUM.

I love this place. Every time I go in the staff is fantastic. Justin is always greeting people with a warm smile and a yummy cupcake. Whenever my mother is in town this is a must stop on her list. Keep it up, guys!

Went to Molly’s for lunch and to buy cupcakes as a gift today. Shop is clean and very cute inside. The girl behind the counter who waited on me was very friendly and helpful. Cupcakes LOOKED absolutly stunning and appealing/​appetizing. However, I ordered an apple pie filling cupcake and the vanilla-​ish flavored frosting tasted like nothing and there was one tiny piece of an apple in the middle of just a plain white cupcake, nothing like what was described to me. The other cupcakes I purchased were gifts for someone else, so I am hoping they at least tasted like something or I am embarassed! I orderd a chicken cranberry walnut sandwich. The homemade bread from the Bakers Bench that the sandwich came on tasted great. The slice of tomato and lettuce on the sandwich was fresh but the actual chicken salad was nothing special. Tasted like it came out of one of those giant buckets pre made salads you would buy in the grocery store deli. It was too watery, sweet, purple, and just not great. I also received a dried out pickle spear that had a jagged piece of plastic wrap or wrapper or something stuck to it. I ordered a cup of their corn chowder and the taste was good. Heavy cream was a nice addition but the potatoes were black. It was basically cream, potatoes, and canned corn, again nothing special. I paid $ 17 for four cupcakes a sandwich and a cup of soup and I won’t be returning especially when a few miles down the street you can go to The Good Life Market and get a fresh delicious sandwich/​lunch meal for the same price. The other sweets in the case looked good too except that they still had valentines cookies in the case which I can’t help but think must be stale or on the verge of stale at this point. So everything looks great here but at a bakery it has to taste as good as it looks!

This is one of my favorite places in Windham — for both sweets and food. Their sandwiches are very good well priced. The lunches that come with a free cupcake are a great value. I’ve had the red velvet cupcakes, and they were yummy, but the cake pops are my favorite. All of their sweets look amazing and are freshly made.