One Hot Cookie -Youngstown

Amazing! There are so many different options available. I wish they still had different flavors to try each month though.

We love One Hot Cookie. Tonight we drove all the way downtown to have warm cookies for a late night snack. There is nothing better than a 1 AM warm cookie just because we can — and there is not better place to get it than One Hot Cookie.
My daughter is cramming for finals so this made a perfect late night study session snack. We picked up M&M cookies for my hubby, chocolate chip for my sister and I and a warm maple bacon cookie for Rhyan (with Gummy Bears of course– YUCK!) But she loves it that way so who am I to judge? HA HA HA
OHC is just the cutest little shop. It has funky window seats and a chair where you cna wait for your hot cookies to arrive fresh from the oven, Located next to the late night bards in downtown Youngstown they stay open extra late on weekends to sooth those late night sugar rushes! I am betting the students at YSU love the fact they are so handy as well! Talk about great study break!
The cookies are warm and delicious and you can choose from many flavors. they also have cookie sandwiches with the best vanilla crème filling! AND they have ice cream if you want true cookies and cream!
So now it is 3 Am and we are gonna find a movie and kick back with our cookies and have a blast! Thanks OHC for a great Friday night snack!

Second time I’ve gone and they only have 2 traditional cookies left and they’re still open for another hour.

Every time I come back to Youngstown these are on my list. S’mores are my favorite, but everything is good. Definitely get milk because they are sweet.

I’m a frequent One Hot Cookie customer. My friends and I visit the downtown Youngstown location often, so I have a good idea of what to expect here.
While most people absolutely love these cookies, I find the food to be just okay. I mean, yeah, a big, melty cookie is obviously going to taste good, but it really isn’t anything that special. In reality, the «baking» being done here is something that anyone can do at home. Get a cookie, crumble some Reese’s Cups on top, and throw it under the broiler. It’s not that difficult.
Despite the rather basic food prep, I still find myself coming back to One Hot Cookie weekend after weekend. Why? Because it’s a fun excuse to get out of my house and take a trip to downtown Youngstown with my friends. We’ll eat our cookies, walk around the city, and enjoy the night. That’s what it’s all about.
If you have a late night dessert craving, take a ride downtown and go to One Hot Cookie. Although the food won’t blow you away, it’s at least satisfying. Hanging out in Youngstown is the reason we keep going back. Give One Hot Cookie a whirl.

I visited One Hot Cookie’s Niles Location for the first time last night. It’s a cute little café decked out in hot pink. Fredo, the store’s mascot who’s an adorable pug, occasionally pops out to greet guests in line, so it’s not too bad a wait unless you may have screaming children or impatient friends.
I ordered three traditional cookies, and one specialty cookie (a cookie dressed up in toppings). On their own, the cookies are amazing, and much better than the kind you can get in the mall shops… maybe even some bakeries. They really are hot; your order is piping warm and kept inside a cardboard box to help you get it home… if you can manage that. I kept a few for the next day, and they’re still soft and chewy after time, so not to worry if you can’t ever finish it.
Which might be your case with the specialty cookies. I ordered a Death by Chocolate (which I’m convinced could kill someone with pure sugary bliss). I wasn’t a fan of the ratios of frosting to the cookie, but after removing a bit of the excess, enjoyed it a lot. The frosting looked as though it could be better mixed, but that’s the only area it needed help with. You can customize your own specialty cookie as well if the selections displayed don’t appeal to you.
If you like cookies with ice cream, they serve Katie’s Korner ice cream (locally made ice cream) for an additional charge, and will even make cookies into ice cream sandwiches with it. Cookie cakes are also available.
The staff are troopers, still maintaining friendliness well into the evening hours.
Overall, worth the wait.

Such a cute shop and great concept! I love coming in for fresh hot cookies when I’m visiting the Yo! Great cookies and great staff!

I never met a cookie I didn’t like. At the same time, I could take them or leave them. One hot cookie is a game changer. These cookies are amazing.
My husband will pick them up on his way home from occasionally and I ration them like a fool, because I don’t want them to be gone. The made a custom cookie for our anniversary that looked like it was out of a magazine.
Fabulous sweets and an asset to the downtown area. Thank you!

(3.75) ~ Good Overall Food & Service
OUR MENU:
* Heart Shaped Brownie = (4) very good
* Coffee = (4) very good
* Oreo Specialty = (3.5) good & decadent
* Double Chocolate Chunk = (3.5) good, but the edges were hard…
* Chocolate Chip = (3.5) good, but the edges were hard…
NOTES: There’s parking in the back and yes they take credit cards.

I crave these cookies!!! My husband and I always have to stop here when we are in town! You can never go wrong with their classic chocolate chip or sugar cookies! The girls working their are always so friendly and can always fill you in with what else is going on in Y-​town. Their shop is always super clean and the design of the store is very smartly done considering the smaller space! Plus Fredo is so stinking cute!

Creative, homemade-​tasting cookies, and locally-​sourced ice cream. As an overall package, One Hot Cookie really shines.

Was surprised to find a cute place like this in downtown youngstown. Not sure of the exact concept but as the there are pictures of a cute pug in a tutu on the walls. Reminds me of the inside of a girls dollhouse.
They have specialty cookies or regular cookies. The regular cookies are sold one for $ 1.25 or you can order by the half dozen/​dozen etc. the specialty cookies such as «hot chocolate, smores, reeses, maple bacon» are $ 2.25 each. They all come out warm full of gooey goodness.
Their take out boxes are like pizza boxes which is really cute.
They make cookie cakes and special order items too according to their menu. Coffee and drink choices could be a bit better but that’s not what you’re going to go for anyways.
My husband loves their snicker doodles.
Not a lot of seating so be prepared to stand at the bar area with cookies on pieces of aluminum foil if you’re eating there.
They have a private parking lot on the side.

I loved their cookies! They even warm them up so you get that out-​of-​the-​oven freshness. It was really enjoyable and the service was extremely friendly. The bakery itself was so cute! Love the pink chairs to sit out on in the summer. It is a nice little spot to brighten up the downtown area.

Hmm they have a pet pug in their kitchen. Isn’t that against health codes? Not that I don’t like dogs because i have two, but seriously?? Interesting cookie combinations. Decent tasting. Just weirded out by having an animal in the kitchen.