Papa Murphys Take N Bake Pizza

I think half my reviews on Unilocal are for pizza joints. Sigh. The life of the working mom. Anyway, Papa Murphy’s is a mainstay at our house. I’d give them five stars just for their seasonal kid pizzas… My son and his cousins loved the pumpkin pizza with the face made out of pepperoni. Little touches like that are what endear Papa Murphy’s to this lady.
Anyway, 90% of the time, we are getting their supreme (they have two versions of the supreme, and we get the one without the green peppers) or their Cowboy Pizza, which has sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and black olives. Delicious. I like that they make the pizza while you wait, and they don’t skimp on the toppings. Their thin crust is good, but we typically get their regular crust (hand-​tossed). We’ve also had their cookie dough and their cheesy bread, which are tasty, too. You really couldn’t get a bad pizza if you tried.
Their store at Paseo and Wyoming is always very clean and the employees are friendly. One star deducted because this is more expensive than most delivery joints and you still have to cook them when you get home. Occasionally, I’ll burn a pizza and it sucks to pay $ 15 for burnt pizza. But that’s the fault of the end user, and I know that quality fresh ingredients cost $$$. We still end up here more often then I care to admit.

I’ve been a customer of this store as long as I’ve lived in NM, about 8 years. I go to this store, even though it’s 10 miles from my house and there are other Papa Murphy’s closer to me, because the store is clean and the employees are friendly and they do a good job. I’m probably there a couple times a month and sometimes once a week. Over the last several months I’ve noticed a change in the way the pizzas are made, skimping on toppings is what I noticed most. Last week I was in there and bought three pizzas, two of which I was over charged for. The store was busy and it was just a mistake. The error occurred on ⁴⁄₁₇ but I didn’t catch it ’til Sun. ⁴⁄₁₉ when I was on line paying bills. Fortunately I asked for the receipt at the time of the purchase. I called the store and talked to Dominick who said he’d have the owner call me. I never heard anything so on Tue I called and talked to Brandon who said he’d take care of it. Brandon called me back and told me they’d be refunding the entire charge because of their mistake, I told him that wasn’t necessary but he said the owner said to. Next thing I know the owner Shauna called me and left a voice mail saying she needed some info off the receipt and to call her with the info so they could refund the $ 8 overcharge and re-​charge the correct amount. Not what I was told was going to happen but, whatever. I called the number she gave and left a voice mail with the info she asked for. Two days later the issue still hadn’t been resolved so I called Shauna’s number and left another voice mail asking her to call me. I also called the store and talked to Brandon again who said he’d call her about the matter. Here we are two days more, the issue still hasn’t been resolved and I’ve still not gotten a call back from Shauna. I called her again this morning and left another voice mail, because she never answers her phone. I emailed Papa Murphy’s corporate to let them know what’s going on. I finally called my bank myself and told them what happened and they did a charge back for the $ 8 over charge. Most importantly, that Papa Murphy’s store has lost a loyal customer because customer service is important to me and I’m not going to continue to put money in the pocket of a store owner who cares so little about her customers!

These guys are hit-​or-​miss. Now I’ve eaten Papa Murphy’s pizza for over 15 years in a number of different locations/​states. I like the concept, and I like fresh pizza– it’s practically a staple food in my diet. On average, their pizza prices are relatively normal, but what sets Papa Murphy’s pizza apart from your typical pizza chains is… the quality, variety, and FRESHNESS associated with take-​and-​bake pizza.
The problem with this location is the inability to deliver quality pizza ~Every Time~. You never know what to expect. Some days (especially during their deals/​promotions) you get a sub-​par pizza that is the equivalent of a boxed Tony’s pizza from the grocery store. I’m honestly not sure why… ingredients? Pre-​mades? Cutting corners? IDK… but it makes you wish you chose something else.

On GOOD days… they are excellent! So if you’ve brought home their pizza’s and weren’t impressed… chances are, it was a bad day… or a promotional pizza. .or something. For me, the bad days are starting to outweigh the good days. so I plan to stop ordering from them entirely or find a different location along my drive home from work.

Papa Murphy’s is my favorite pizza, and this location does the chain justice. I’ve only been here on Sunday afternoons, but the staff is very friendly and patient. This store isn’t too small,
You can call your order ahead of time and come to pick it up, or just show up and order it; they’ll then make it on the spot for you to take home to bake. Great selection and fresh ingredients.

Love Papa Murphy’s take out pizza. They have the freshest ingredients in town, as far as pizza goes. They’ll make it your way; & their thin crust is the best in town. Check out their delite crust & their specialty pizzas, they’re all great; my favorite one is the Cowboy-it’s my go to order. It’s great, you can call ahead & they’ll have it ready for you when you arrive. They have a punchcard for loyal customers, & I’ve already received two free pizzas! Love the pizza, love the staff @ the Wyoming establishment, & love the quality & quantity you get for the price you pay. Forget delivery-​hurry over to Papa Murphy’s for a freshly prepared pizza!!!
V/​r,
Casey Burnsed

I think Papa Murphy’s has great pizza that you can pick up ahead of time and cook whenever it’s convenient. They have a delicious thin crust pizza called their Delight Pizza.

Fantastic value & very fresh ingredients. Their De-​Lite pizza crust is my favorite.
There are always coupons at
and they also have a loyalty card (after buying 12 pizzas you get a free one topping large).
You buy the pizza and cook it in your own oven — so it is ready when you want it and without sales tax on the price!
Very affordable & tasty way to feed a whole bunch of people.
Only criticism is that I wish their green chile was hotter and so I use my own.