Your Pie

Great service, better pizza! This is my favorite pizza place in Athens considering the quality and pricing. The pizzas are the perfect size and cooked so that they’re crispy and hot and cheesy and delicious. The prices are so reasonable and the pizza is delicious, not to mention that it’s quick and painless. And it has one of those big drink machines, so you can make any drink you want with no limitations.

One star for quick service, one for diy fountain drinks, and one for the business concept. Flavor: nothing special. Size: personal pan … Would rather go to the Transmetropolitan!

On my first day in Athens, I met with a friend from church for lunch. At first thought, you’d think that this place was for dessert but it’s actually a customized pizza parlor! I hadn’t had pizza in awhile so I was pretty excited to try this out. In addition, it had some amazing reviews on Unilocal.
I ordered the Ischia Pie — Roasted Garlic Olive Oil with Fresh Mozzarella, Roma Tomatoes, Basil, and Garlic. I added bacon and pineapples to this to make it «my own» too!
PROS
–great quantity. I was starving and it was a nice personal size.
–awesome flavors. By itself, the Ischia pie is a really well balanced pie. I personally wanted a bit more bacon salt and the pineapple sweetness to balance that out. It went well with the garlic olive oil as well.
CONS
–I’d like a little bit of a thicker pan crust personally. However, I don’t think I could have finished the entire pie had it been a pan crust. That being said, the hand-​rolled pizza crust was perfectly fine.
I’m glad that they have other locations closer to me towards Atlanta and the few major suburbs OTP. Athens was only for a gig and I don’t know if I would drive over an hour to eat at this place. Definitely worth a twenty-​minute drive though, especially to kick it with some friends over a slice or two! Picture here:

Turkey?
Tofu?
Carrots?
Romaine?!
Pecans?!!
Corn!!!
Cranberries!!!
WTF?!
Seriously, WTF!!!
Those toppings may be on «Your Pie.»
But they sure as heck ain’t on my pizza.
Still, I guess that’s the whole point of «Your Pie.» To each his own!
Anyway, Your Pie does a credible job churning out $ 7.99 personal pizzas in a bit of a Neopolitan style. The pizza wasn’t especially memorable, but it wasn’t bad, either. We ordered take-​out on-​line, which is how I became aware of the absurd assortment of toppings available, but our pizzas were ready in a matter of minutes. Better than the corporate likes of Papa John’s or Pizza Hut or whatever, but the crust was not as crispy as you might hope for from this style.
Parking on this side of Five Points has become problematic over the years. If you’re picking up, you might want to give yourself a couple of minutes extra to find a space.

Another great pizza from your pie in 5 points. Sun dried tomato basil sauce, green peppers, red onions, fresh jalapenos and pickled jalapenos, tomatoes, mushrooms, green olives and black olives, Turkey, Tabasco, red pepper, Parmesan cheese. Excellent!

ordered the turkey, spinach and pesto panini in this great little spot. also had a Fat Tire with my late lunch. friendly staff, cool joint, excellent panini!

Saw the owners story on food network (or was it the cooking channel?) awhile ago and made plans to visit when I arrived to Athens. The concept is pretty cool. Décor resembled an average pizza place.
I ordered the Napt on wheat dough which was pretty tasty. Good & quick food.

I drive by here every time I come to Athens and always think, «Hey, I want to stop there». Today I was early for a meeting and had time so I pulled in and boy am I glad I did! As I type this I am having MY PIE MY WAY! and it is SOOOOO Yummy!
I was greeted by three staff who inquired if I’d been here before and explained ordering to this newbie. I ordered white crust (they also had wheat and gluten free), which was tossed in front of me. There were at least six options for cheese and sauces and every veggie and meat imaginable. Well, I can imagine a few more, but there were plenty of choices including arugala, shrimpo and artichokes. I chose marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, spinach, mushrooms, black olives and bacon. My ten inch pizza was cooked in a brick oven and came out quickly and cooked perfectly. The crust is just the right mixture of crucnchy and chewy.
the special today was a personal pizza with whatever veggies I wanted on it and one premium topping (bacon for me) plus a drink for under $ 7. Well worth it. I thought I’d get a to go box, but I was a gluton and ate it all!
I wish there was one of these in Conyers. It would do really well. I will definitely be making a repeat appearance here!

This place has great pizza and the panini’s are really good too. I’m glad they have expanded to the east side as well because this is a great lunch spot!

I was very excited about coming here not anymore. I do acknowledge that you can get your pizza your way in a personal size. I ordered the spinach, gorgonzola salad which they serve in a bread bowl — actual pizza crust shaped into bowl. I thought the dough as a bit bland – could have had more olive oil and parmesan to make it better. Thai pizza was very tasty, felt the pizzas were not pipping hot and needed more cheese. They do have a gluten free option as well. Gelato did not look fresh. 12 flavors which if you have been to Italy means they don’t make it often enough — less flavors means more fresh. I also noticed as we were leaving the score of 80 from the health and safety department — yikes unfortunately you only see it as you leave the restaurant not as you come in!!! Won’t be back — sorry too many other better choices in Athens

Great choice of toppings to make a unique pizza of your own. Not expensive and always hits the spot!

Great deal on Tuesdays, buy a pizza and a drink for $ 6.49. Great pizza! highly recommend!

So, this may be more of a girl place. Guys tend to complain that the personal pizzas don’t do anything for them, but I absolutely love it. I really like all the different options they have and they have gluten free dough for those of you with allergies.
All the times I’ve been in the past, the people working there have been really helpful and patient when you’re deciding which of the numerous toppings and sauces you want.
I repeat, guys will not get full on one of these personal pizzas and the price is a little steep to order 2. But girls, on the other hand, this is a perfect place to get pizza and not overdo it.

Great sandwiches, salads, and pizza. I love that you can see the pizza/​breads cooking and that you can really customize your meal. I also like that you can add certain toppings for free. The also have a beer for under $ 2. Its not anything special, but it is a beer. I have eaten there twice now and have really enjoyed it.

Unbelievable gourmet pizza joint. It’s a shocker if I’m not in there 3 times a week.

Ate here on a recent trip back to Athens. Was thrilled to be able to get a VEGAN pizza in the dirty south. They use Daiya brand cheese as their vegan option (I think says «soy cheese» as an option, although FWIW, Daiya is not actually made from soy.)
I ordered the «Hippie» and asked for vegan cheese. The server kindly informed me that the sauce on the Hippie was not vegan, but I could sub marinara, which I did. Extra star for that. I really appreciate when the staff at restaurants actually understand your dietary restrictions.
The pizza was an 8″ individual size (which it states on the menu; that is clearly a one-​, maybe two-​person serving), but I assume that is the whole deal with it being YOUR pie. Anyway, the pizza came out very quickly! It had a good amount of toppings (artichoke hearts, mushrooms, tofu cubes, and banana peppers) and faux cheese. It was really good! I was actually pretty hungover and only ate half, but continued to snack on my leftovers throughout the day.
I would absolutely go back if I’m in town again. I wish we had one in Vegas!!!

This is by far the best pizza I have had, ever! They have a variety of toppings to choose from and you can put any number of free toppings without adding a cent to the base price.
It has a number of sauce and cheese options. So you can make a variety of combinations. I like the fact that they have different cheeses so you can choose a healthier cheese if you like. The size of the pizzas is just right too. You don’t end up stuffing yourself too much.
Their paninis are pretty good too.
All in all, I would prefer this place for a pizza anyday over the usual pizza chains.

Your Pie is the ONLY reason why I’d come to Athens (other than visiting my sister). Actually, I hate Athens. It’s the most boring town ever… I hate driving along 316… but that’s another story.
So I usually tell my sister that my visits must be accompanied by a trip to Your Pie, which, nicely enough, is within walking distance of her apartment.
Pros:
1. I love pizza
2. Pizzas here are 100% customizable. My pizzas end up being kind of random (like BBQ sauce + feta cheese), but who cares; its still yummy no matter what you pick
3. Tons of different sauces to choose from! (I like their BBQ and Hot Sauce)
4. wheat dough is an option
5. perfectly sized portion
6. good price
7. each pizza individually fired up
Cons:
1. Sometimes the person making your pizza can be bit skimpy on ingredients
For the price, this is the best pizza you can get. It’s nothing gourmet, but still fantastically yummy. There are 3 of these in Athens… please expand to Midtown, and I’d be the best customer!