Cupcake Wishes

Ok, so I must admit I have an addiction to this place! I have my favorites but all their cupcakes are AWESOME! They are so soft and freshly made. I love the variety and the presentation. Their new location is great and the staff couldn’t be more friendly. I do believe I’ve gained weight since they’ve opened, but life is about rewards. They are definitely Avon’s best kept secret! A MUST TRY!!!

Definitely uses a box mix. Save your money and buy a Betty Crocker mix and make them yourself. I got cupcakes for my birthday and was really disappointed. The icing in the cupcakes was nice but I make cupcakes all the time and it’s obvious when a cake is homemade vs. a store bought mix. The strawberry and carrot cupcakes are definitely not homemade.

Think there are better around town in Rocky River and Lakewood (don’t want to give them a free plug) but these are OK. Only three stars because they operate on the theory once they sell out they close for the day. This creates an issue when you want to plan on getting a special treat for home after work. I mean make enough to keep regular hours! Because of this I choose other places over this. They are not good enough to go out of my way to get them!

Clearly the person who left the bad review is slightly misinformed and should check facts before posting them on the Internet.
A-​they bake the cupcakes everyday at the store, just because you can’t see the oven doesn’t mean they don’t bake them fresh, the oven is in the back genius.
B– the cupcakes are delicious and certainly don’t taste like they are out of a box. I guess I need to find out what box you are using cause they must be amazing if it taste like these cupcakes.
C-I’m not sure if you have ever bought cupcakes from any of the other shops around town but $ 2.00 is nothing for a cupcake, especially such a yummy one.
All in all, people should be sure of posting things without knowing for sure their facts are correct.
These are the best cupcakes around! We had them at our wedding and got so many compliments and have been loyal customers ever since!

I love this place! I’ve been getting cupcakes from Holly for years! The specialty cupcakes are amazing! I love the Reese cup cupcakes! Although the store is small, I find it cozy and the staff has always been helpful! You do have to get there early as they do sell out of cupcakes. The bonus is, they are made fresh daily!

Absolutely amazing. I loved working with Holly. She was so accommodating and sweet. The set up for our wedding was beautiful. The taste of the cupcakes were phenomenal. We had wedding cake, buckeye, cassata, Arnold Palmer, and red velvet cheesecake. People took one of each and loved every flavor.

As a whole, the experience was poor.
The storefront (they don’t make any cupcakes in the store so it’s not a bakery) was uncomfortably hot, which could have been solved easily by cracking the front door open.
There weren’t many cupcakes left even though they had only been open four hours by the time I came in.
The cupcakes themselves:
–the cake tasted like a box mix at best (my brother, who eats anything, spit it out)
–the frosting had a powdery texture most likely from too much powdered sugar
–they are expensive for what they are $ 2.00 for a «regular» cupcake and $ 2.25 for «specialty» cupcakes
There are no quantity discounts (ex: getting a dozen)

The best cupcakes I have ever tasted. Cupcakes are super moist and flavorful and a reasonable serving size. My sister-​in-​law and I have made a hobby of exploring cupcake shops together and these beat out Sweet Maggie’s in amherst and La Bella of Lakewood.
IMO, the flavor combos and icing put these over the top. I had chocolate raspberry and raspberry champage. The icing is not sugary sweet and crunchy like other shops but creamy with just enough substance that it doesn’t make the cupcake soggy.

Great cupcakes. Butter cream rocks! They change out flavors so you don’t get bored with the same old same old. Love the peanut butter/​buckeye cupcakes the best. This has started to become a weekly event for us.