Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream

This is hands-​down my favorite ice cream shop! From taste to service, they get it right every time. They claim to use fresh, all-​natural, local ingredients and it shows in the flavors and taste of their ice creams. They have a roster of always available flavors along with rotating seasonal selections. They offer free samples to aid in choosing your order and their servings are large and filling.
Some of my favorite flavors include pumpkin (seasonal), cinnamon (seasonal), mint chocolate chip (always available), and pralines & cream (always available). Their caramel sea salt is the best I’ve ever had!
They have many locations which include Avon, Ohio City, and Rocky River. I’ve never had better ice cream anywhere!

I live in LA where vegan options are as plentiful as traffic delays. This vegan ice cream kills any others that I’ve had. ALWAYS get the salted caramel. ALWAYS grab a couple extra pretzel sticks, which are free. And always be grateful for Mitchell’s. Yum!

This is what an ice cream shop should be.
The quality is amazing. Every flavor I’ve ever had had simply tasted exactly what it suggests – Key Lime Pie is one of my personal favorites as it hits the flavor perfectly, and adds delicious texture variation with graham cracker pieces.
All of their ice creams are made just a little ways away locally, and menu items marked with M100 have ingredients solely in a radius of 100 miles from Ohio City.
Plenty of space to eat in and relax, indoor or outdoor on the patio. Great atmosphere, especially for kids who can take advantage of the paper and crayons to doodle their hearts out.

The best ice cream you’ll ever have in your life. The Oreo is delish. Staff is friendly and it’s always clean and happy when we go!

Nice! Ice cream is good too. Great place to bring the family. Friendly environment that’s happy to serve and answer questions.

Mitchell’s is the best of the best. This has to be the best ice cream place in the country. I’ve lived in three other states since moving out of Ohio and traveled quite a bit. I can confidently say that Mitchell’s is the best ice cream out there. Close your eyes and point at a flavor because it’ll be the best you’ve had. They have a really large selection for a shop that makes such unique flavors. My current favorites are campfire s’mores and lavender. I’ve also fancied the bing cherry chocolate chunk which has generous chunks of delicious chocolate in it. For my husband’s birthday party I picked up two cakes here and they were the bomb. Six months later my grandma was still talking about those cakes. I feel sorry for people that have never had Mitchell’s ice cream.

Friendly and smiling staff and of course most delicious ice cream ever-​especially the toasted hazelnut! We’ve been here numerous times as a treat and always enjoy it. As other reviewers have mentioned before it is a bit on the expensive side but definitely worth every penny!

It’s the perfect summer hangout! My husband and I always sit outside on the patio to enjoy the delicious, creamy homemade ice cream! Mouth-​watering!

Very good flavor, texture, and service. We keep going back again and again. A train, too!

If great ice cream and creative flavors are not enough, the homemade whipped cream and cherries top it off. It’s also nice to see they use local ingredients when they can. The staff is very friendly, not to mention patient. There is so much to choose from!

The ice cream was fantastic (caramelized chocolate and cherry chocolate chunk), but the waffle cone was relatively soft/​stale.

We are what you would consider regulars at Mitchell’s. The Avon store is within walking distance, but unfortunately the mileage walked does not equal the calories consumed (most of the time!). On to the ice cream review:
We have tried just about every single flavor and our favorites are: Caramelized Chocolate, Toasted Hazelnut (tastes a lot like Nutella!), S’Mores, Blue Cosmo, Coconut and Peach. To be honest, there is not a flavor we haven’t liked though. The store is immaculately clean, the service is smiley and helpful, they offer unlimited samples and the patio is fabulous. If you haven’t tried it yet, you should. You won’t be disappointed!

Sweet Jesus how does this place only have 3 reviews?! It is a beacon of delicious dairy in the Cleveland suburbs.
Why so delightful? Let me count the ways…
1. The staff are sunny & sweet. No stink eye if you need to try a bunch of flavors before deciding on your selection (s).
2. Quality ‘scream in creative but not ridiculous flavors. You’ll find tasty combos, especially in the seasonal varieties like Wildberry Crumble, Carmelized Chocolate, and Cherry Stout, in addition to their classics that are sure to impress. The Wildberry Crumble and Mint Cookie are a few of my personal favorites.
3. Portion sizes are pretty generous. One scoop is the size of a (small) softball.
4. Per their website: «Fresh, local, wholesome. Farm-​fresh dairy, grass-​fed and raised on family farms in the countryside of Holmes and Wayne Counties an hour away. Local seasonal fruits. The finest organic vanillas and arabica coffees. Locally-​roasted nuts. Belgian, Swiss, & Dutch chocolates.» I like all of these things.
5. Super clean store & patio with the cutest train rolling around the interior perimeter.
There may not be too much around this Mitchell’s, but with ice cream this awesome, I could care less. Oh, and I hear the birthday ice cream cakes are host a brownie foundation. Best. Decision. Ever.

First time here. Ice cram was great with lots of flavors. Had cones, but will try a sundae next time. Just a little expressive: 2 double scoop comes were over &10.00.

Two local guys with a passion for fresh ice cream and innovative flavors have made this one of my favorite places to go for dessert. I’ve been to the Mitchell’s in Rocky River and Westlake so I decided to stop here last night after a dinner out with friends in Avon Lake. Like it’s other stores, the place is bright and clean with smiling young faces behind the counter eager to take my order. $ 3.50 for a single scoop might seem a bit much, but it’s well worth it — and for the quality of the product you get, it’s a bargain.

Great selection of different ice cream. Their specialties are neat as well. Inside or outside seating. Don’t be discouraged by lines, any length moves quickly. Friendly teenagers working. Not the cheapest but definitely not outrageous. 6 people got ice cream for $ 25 bucks