Cosmo’s Pizza

Wow! Finally found fantastic delivered pizza in Boulder. The crust is just right-​thin but not too thin-​with a nice chewy bite. I ordered the Supreme 24″. The thing was huge, the toppings were generous and it had just the right amount of sauce. Very similar to the best Pizza on the east coast. Bonus… it’s great cold for breakfast the next morning!

I’ve ordered from Cosmo’s Pizza several times over the span of three years, delivery and pickup alike, including one regrettable sit-​in experience (sticky tabletops and loud ambience). I have enjoyed every slice I have ever had, and reminds me so much of home in the Northeast. Kudos to the delicious product!
It is perfect for after a night out drinking, as most people admit, and even a sober night in. BUT, to my consistent disappointment (every experience), the customer service is awful. Abrupt and inconsiderate dialogue, with a significant lack of patience. I assume the employees ringing me up have been poorly trained and had very little experience in the service industry, perhaps this is their first job. Nonetheless, this is no excuse for being a blatantly rude human being to a rather patient and cheerful customer!
Overall, the food has kept me coming back, but after ordering delivery today from the 30^th Street venue, and experiencing one of the most inappropriate cashiers yet (hung up the phone on me), I’ve decided to write an honest review. I hope this is helpful to the business and it’s customers.

The breadsticks with spicy ranch are worth the visit alone. The pizza is great– straightforward NY style slice as big as your face. One slice here is 2 slices everywhere else. Only downside is LOTS of drunk college kids on weekends.

Tershia and Greg,
You are awesome people. There’s nothing better than having a slice of Pizza with the touch of your «affection» in it. Love you, buddies!
And of course, a pizza slice after the night at Cosmos’, … rocks!!!

We ordered a pizza at midnight, gave credit card info, was told it would take an hour-​and-​a-​half, and it never came. I’m sure they make awesome pizza, but what a letdown. Get extra confirmation they’re going to follow through, I guess? Otherwise you’ll have a lot of hungry, disappointed people!

Came with my husband for some pizza after a show at the Fox theater. This was one of his go to drunk/​munchie foods in college so he had to get in on some of that nostalgia while we were visiting Boulder.
Pizza was great and service was quick. Ranch sauce cost extra, which kinda sucks, but it was good.
If I lived in Boulder this would def be a go to pizza joint.

Fresh, tasty pizza in a college town. We were looking for a quick inexpensive bite and this was a great option. No frills, a little untidy, but ran by college guys at the front so I didn’t expect much. The pizza was really good, so a great choice for a late night meal.

Popped into to town and had a craving for some pizza. Well let’s just say this place satisfied the craving! It’s located in an area full of college peeps and scenery the inside of the place was not much to look it, but man was the pizza tasty! For $ 7 bucks I got a slice of cheese pizza and tomato basil and the slices were huge! Those were more than enough. The place was steady busy for a Thursday evening. If you are in doubt, don’t be go check them out!

Well when it comes to the size, and taste of the slice of pizza it is like I was back in New York. I have found another great pizza place that everyone will love. 5 stars from me

Excellent crispy slices, Boulder Beer Co. on tap, friendly, helpful staff. A winner.

One of the best pizzas I’ve had! The service was amazing! Ingredients are nice and fresh. Pizza is made right in front of you. Don’t bring a large group as they are a small restaurant. Overall loved it

Went last night (6÷24÷15) with my mom and siblings. Found this place off Unilocal reviews and decided to give it a try. I ordered a single slice (which was giant by the way) while the rest of my family got calzones which were enormous! We also ordered the breadsticks. It took a bit to cook the calzones and our breadsticks got over cooked the first time but they gladly made us more. The place got slammed not long after we got there and there was only like two dudes working… They were working hard for sure! We had lots of leftovers to bring home. Staff was super nice. Food was good. Would totally recommend to others!

Best late night pizza in town. They deliver too and the delivery pizzas are so much better than their single slices but also kind of expensive if delivered

If you’re drunk/​stoned on ‘The Hill’ at 2 AM then this is your place for late night munchies. In this context, Cosmo’s Pizza is hands down your best option.
If you are sober and in the mood for pizza you’re bound to be disappointed – I was. Boss Lady Pizza, a couple blocks up ‘The Hill,’ offers more gourmet pizza options by the slice although they don’t have a liquor license. Prices are comparable.
Cosmos is clean and minimal. They sell beer which is paramount when it comes to pizza.
In summary, Cosmos is tailored to late night dining. If it’s late, go to Cosmos. Otherwise there are better options.

Cosmos greasy massive slices of pizza are just what the drunk college kids ordered. Hands down the best pizza around boulder! While CU students can be observed stumbling here on the weekends to mix pizza into the alcoholic concoction in their belly most of the east coasters and chi-​town peoples stay away when sober. Over all the pizza is okay, definitely not a place you have to go to if you visit BOCO. Definitely a place you have to go to before you crawl back to your dorm in a drunken stupor. Also sometimes ruffians pop up, making for an entertaining time while you wait in line.
Shout out to the tall guy with the glasses that works at both locations. He tends to cuss out the obnoxious jackass freshmen/​frat bros who show up and act a fool…

It is physically impossible to dislike cosmos pizza (although I will admit their takeout is not as good as their in store slices). Their spicy ranch is AMAZING — so amazing that it’s now being sold at select wholefoods locations. If I had one recommendation, I would say try your best to start with the location on the hill! Best pizza ever.

Such a huge pizza slice for such a great price. It’s only 2.75 but its like 2 and a half pizza slices from dominos. The quality of the pizza is crappy tho. why 5 stars you ask? Because of the magical spicy ranch! Idk what they put in there but it’s like a slight glimpse of heaven. Its addicting!

Came here after a late night on the town. Craving pizza for weeks! My favorite is NY style where the crust is thin. I had ate Cosmo’s before during my college years at CU Boulder and have loved that place ever since! This location was no different! The list of ingredients to put on your pizza is very nice and you can always find what you’re in the mood for. My go to is chicken and jalapeño, or any meat topping. We decided to order a large and it took roughly 10 minutes for our order to be made. Very happy with the choice in coming here, because the pizza was great and I would recommend to anyone out late at night if you are in the area! Try their spicy Ranch sauce!

Hubs is Super Hungry. After the Unilocal Elite Event a few blocks away, and since its the closest to where we were, to Cosmo’s Pizza Broadway St Location we went. That recent visit was on Wednesday January 8^th 2014. Time was about 20:10hrs ish. Right when we enter this establishment, we were «GREETED» with an intense smell. I kept asking Hubs, is that «Weed» Smell OR just Incense Smell OR just my Nose playing tricks with my Brain?
From the Board Menu or the Paper Menu, The Plain Pizza starts with 14″ Medium at $ 9.99, 16″ Large at $ 11.99, and the 24″ EXTRA Large at $ 19.99. Specialty Pizza are from $ 12.69 and the EXTRA Large is at $ 37.49.
We opt to have the following items :
* 16″ Large Pizza with Chicken, Jalapeño and Black Olives
* Calzone with our choice of Chicken and Jalapenos.
Hubs opt to have Fountain Coke Cola for his beverages, while I just opt to water. Hubs like his order of Pizza, coz for one that was the first time he had Dice Chicken on a Pizza which is «breaded». To me its more like Cut up aka Diced Up «Chicken Nuggets». When we peek at the Calzone, boy oh boy its Freaking Huge! I did not expect that Calzone to be Big! The Diced Chicken are also in the Calzones that we ordered. We opt to have the Calzones to go, since we want to eat it at a later hour or the next day.
The Calzone is with Ricotta and Mozzarella Cheese and Marina Dipping Sauce. We don’t fancy the Marina Dipping Sauce at all.
That Dinner was about $ 35 with tax.
3 Stars BEST sums up for what we had that evening and the overall experience. May return when we are in the neighborhood.
COSMO’s Pizza
1325 Broadway St
Ste 1 – 8
Boulder, CO 80 302
Tel: (303)-447−1133
@9/2014

2012 Review #257:
There is nothing for a drunk person that Cosmo’s won’t help. Having been about 5 years since I was drunk eating Cosmo’s, I had never written a review. I assumed the beer goggles had influenced my experience.
Tried some again today at a gathering, though beer was again involved. It was a bit cooled off by the time we ate some though. They ordered the huge size, which is seriously huge, and I tried the spinach/​sun-​dried tomato and the pepperoni/​sausage/​ham. Both were good though a bit rubbery when cold.
If you order the giant pizza it’s cut into squares, so you won’t always get edges. If only there were a «edges everywhere!» pan for pizza like there is for brownies.
Prices are fair. Let us not forget the spicy ranch or «Cosmo’s sauce» or whatever they call that magic elixir that accompanies the pizza for an extra dollar. Splurge and get it. It turns plain old cheese pizza into drunken amazement at your taste buds.