Panatieris Pizza

Food always taste great when we order there. Average prices and decent dine in seating.

Manager and staff extremely rude. I brought a large pizza pie with me and my 8 year old son. When I got home opened it up n cheese was hanging over the crust everywhere. looked horrible and never seen a pizza pie as bad… brought it back and before the manager even seen the pizza he accused me of driving crazy with my son in the car to make the pizza cheese sloppy… I live 1 min away. Speed limit 25 mph. The way the pizza cheese was it was way too much cheese just sloppy and unprofessionally done. Don’t go there

Cardboard pizza! I would not patron them. We ordered the margherita pizza and the works to go. Both the crust was exactly like eating cardboard. The box it came in was probably tastier than the crust. Overly salted.
We used to frequent the Martinsville location when Enzo worked there and then he left :(, now we are trying to find pizza as good as Enzo used to make and so far it’s been a disappointing endeavor. No bueno aqui.

Been patroning this location since it was next to quick chek on 28 in bound brook. The young Hispanic clerk tonight didn’t know I was bilingual and was calling me a piece of s@;t in Spanish as I ordered 2 slices to go. Ask them to keep in for awhile because I like it hot. He got mad a spouted more obscenities in Spanish after that. Them the got mopping the floor came over by me to make sure I wasn’t going to react! Didn’t have too, that’s what this site is for! So embarrassed that this establishment has gotten so bad when it comes to customer service! Never going back. Lost a 30 year 2 – 3 day a week customer!

I just started working up the street from this location and I LOVE their Tortellini pizza. Different and tasty (especially if you love cheese the way I do). Place is clean overall and the staff is very friendly.

The service at this place sucks. I’m pretty easy to please so I’d like to believe that if I’m moved to write a review, it’s either because I’m extremely impressed or very disappointed. This one is the latter. I’ve eaten at 2 other Panatieri’s and the pizza as well as service is good. I ordered two pies that were overpriced and did not live up to the Panatieri’s standard. I absolutely love pizza. I’ve been in love with it since a toddler and I’ve eaten my share over the years. One of the pizzas I ordered was an extra cheese pie and it had the same amount of cheese that a regular pie has. When I asked if it was made with extra cheese, I was given as blank stare and an answer of yes. I know an extra cheese pie and that wasn’t it. I’ll never go back to this place. As far as the other pie, which was topped with chopped tomato, I couldn’t stomach more than one slice. What a waist of money. These two «small» pies ran me 28.00. Ripped off is an understatement.

This is the 4^th Panatieri’s location I’ve been to – Bound Brook, Flemington, Warren and Martinsville. I think the Flemington location is the best but I go to the Warren location most frequently. It was my first time at the Bound Brook location.
One negative about this location is that the parking lot is incredibly small and they share it with a Dunkin Donuts. We were able to grab a spot but I’d have to imagine that people come here relatively often and can’t find parking. Upon entering, it’s actually pretty small — not too many tables. I’m a huge fan of the Panatieri’s slice selection. This location had about 15 different slice pies to choose from — as an FYI, the Warren location consistently has the most selection.
I went with a Buffalo Chicken and a Cheesesteak slice. I get these two slices pretty regularly at Panatieri’s, along with a few others. Each location does a couple of things differently from the others. For example, the Buffalo Chicken slice in Bound Brook was drizzled with blue cheese while the other locations don’t do that. I actually wasn’t as big a fan. I like the hot sauce and regular cheese, sans the blue cheese. However, the cheesesteak slice here was great. There was a ton of cheese and a ton of meat — a winning combination. I always order it with a side of marinara sauce. Definitely the best cheesesteak slice I’ve had.
This location is not the most convenient to where I live but I’d stop back here if I was in the area. I’m a huge fan of Pantieri’s, in general, because they have such a good slice selection and it’s always so unique. Solid spot except for the limited parking.

The two guys that work there have an attitude problem. Never smile or say hello. They don’t get the concept of customer service. The girl at the front counter is nice enough. Unfortunately they have the best pizza in the area. I wish I could go elsewhere to support a friendlier business, but their pizza isn’t as good.

Italian food is like sex. Even when it’s bad, it’s still kinda good. After my take-​out order from here yesterday, I felt compelled to write a review.
I ordered the portobello pasta. $ 11.99 and it comes with a small salad and some bread. This was the WEAKEST pizzeria portion I have ever seen. On top of that, it just tasted awful. The salad and accompanying vinaigrette dressing was the best part about this meal.
The pizza from here is very average, as is their eggplant parm sandwich. I’ve given this place enough chances, I think I’m done.

Pretty good food. Super close to my house. Wish they delivered. There serving sizes are very large and they have a nice variety of pizza to choose from. Their plain slice is good.

Recommended about this place and thought it was worth giving it a try since I’ve been craving some good pizza. This really hit the spot. You have to go in to see what speciality pizzas they have available. Quite unique: pasta on pizza (baked ziti and tortellini), cheesesteak on pizza, chicken and broccoli w alfredo sauce… check my picture of what they had in their display case.
Service was great. Didn’t rush us to pick what we wanted. Requested for hot pepper flakes and garlic salt and put them in little containers for us.