Casa Di Pizza

Had a chicken parmigiano sandwich. This is usually a test of a good pizza joint. This one was made with precooked chicken cutlets and they were heavily crusted and probably a day or two old. The sauce was thick and about average. Not too sweet. The bread was average white sub bread, and the cheese was rather flavorless. I was here on a job next door and took a chance because it has a mon and pop vibe. Other food that I saw looked tasty. Can’t comment on the pizza.

I love love Casa Di Pizza I am from Buffalo and when my daughter told me they had a Casa Di Pizza I was super excited. Pizza is delicious, Real Buffalo Wings delicious this is the place! People are friendly service is quick and the food is delicious and their prefer hot sauce Franks Red Hot !! Happy Customer we happily drive 1 hour just to enjoy some Buffalo Pizza and Wings! Great Food, Decent Price, Friendly People and Great Service!

Terrible pizza. My girlfriend and I split a thin crust pizza and we each had one slice before we threw it out. The crust was soggy, sauce flavorless and the cheese was rubbery. The entire pizza tasted like a frozen pizza. It was incredibly salty and that was it, no other flavor. For a place that calls themselves the House of Pizza you’re better off going across the street to Blaze. For $ 20 a pie I expected so much more, if it was possible to give negative stars I would.

Had this pizza last night. it was horrible. the bottom of the pizza was jet black. meaning their ovens are dirty. The taste was like eating charcoal. a pie and 10 piece wing order cost me about $ 40 after tipping the delivery kid. save your money and dont waste it in this garbage.

Best pizza I have had in a while! The sauce and crust make the pizza better then the rest! Fast delivery! Friendly staff! Great environment!

Casa Di Pizza is by far the best pizzeria in Bradenton and Sarasota! The staff members are so kind and the food is AMAZING! Love coming here and enjoy the awesome atmosphere!

PREMIER BUFFALO STYLE PIZZA AND WINGS IN FLORIDA (You’re welcome, Dolphins’ Fans)!
You would have to attend a Jim Kelly Celebrity Classic golf tournament and bear witness to Dan Marino chipping onto the green to ever see the extent of collaboration between Bills fans and Dolphins fans as you will with entering the Casa Di Pizza in Bradenton Beach, FL.
As far as Casa Di Pizza’s pizza is concerned, it’s one of my all time favorite slices (it’s hard for me to narrow down a list of pizzas that I like the most to a «Top 10», but Casa Di Pizza is in there somewhere). It’s a Type I Buffalo Pizza: which is what I refer to as being Buffalo pizza (thicker than NY style, but certainly not deep dish Chicago), that is cheesier & slightly well-​done so the pepperoni’s get a little charred around the edges.
Those of you from NYC (or New Jersey but pretend to be from New York anyways) and you absolutely insist on super thin crust, well then Casa Di Pizza may be a suitable compromise for you, as it is thinner and a little crispier than most Buffalonian pizzas.
The wings are top quality as well. You won’t find them on a list of «Greatest Wings in Buffalo» due to the Anchor Bar Effect, but again, they’re in there.
Now to talk about this location in Bradenton Beach… It’s a refreshing pallet paradigm switch from the other restaurants with delicious seafood and God-​awful pizza & wings you’ll find in the area. It also serves as a Bills backer bar (Hey-​Yay-​Yay-​Yay!), but I found it audacious and offensive when they asked me if I wanted blue cheese or ranch «dipping sauce» with my wings. First of all, no self-​respecting Buffalonian uses the term «dipping sauce’, nor would we ever use ranch with wings, but then I noticed the worker was wearing a camouflaged Miami Dolphins baseball cap and then I understood.
Lastly, even in Bradenton Beach when Bills fans watched in reluctant but quiet acceptance as the Bills dropped another important game, there was a big fat Pats fan donning a Tom Brady jersey (of course) cheering and heckling Bills fans at the bar. What’s wrong with you, Pats fans? Not only do you win everything but you applaud the misfortune Bills fans must endure every season? For shame!

I ordered from here yet again… this is the second time. I would like to say first how good the pizza is. Absolutely delicious. We had a regular pizza as well as a white one… they were perfect. I would also like to compliment the service. The girl I spoke to when I ordered was respectful (this trait is missing often on the phone with people today), kind, not hurried… she even offered us more pizza at the same price by making us aware of a deal that was going on. A large pizza for the same price as a small this week. When you combine all of that… it equals me coming back to this place each and every time I want pizza. Head and shoulders above other pizza places I’ve been to. Thank you guys and gals.

Several people told me about this restaurant and how good it was, so after being bitten by fire ants and drugged up on Benadryl I figured delivery was the way to go.
The pizza and wings were great, and this is coming from someone originally from Jersey. They delivered in the time frame mentioned in the ordering process and the delivery guy was even able to figure out my apartments gate and navigate around the rather large complex.
I would definitely order from here again, Benadryl-​ed up or not!

For a pizza joint, they sure need help with their pizzas. Umm HELLO?!
I’ve ordered from this place many times and the pizza has showed up cold or soggy (or both) every single time.
It’s amazing that u order a pie and are told it’ll be 45 minutes for it to be delivered, and I ended up waiting 1 hour and 35 minutes… I can only imagine how long I would have to wait if I ordered multiple. Of course it showed up cold, too.
The manger ended up taking 10 bucks off which was pretty decent. Also, the pepperoni is tasty, …but it’s not worth the time and money for me.

Wings are really good here! And the pepperoni and white pizzas are my favorites. Great football game day meal.

Just had one of the greatest pizzas ever at casa di pizza.

If you like your pizza thick like cake with an impenetrable layer of cheese on top this place is for you. If you enjoy real pizza do yourself a favor and head over to Rico’s.

This place has great Buffalo style pizza. The crust is not too thin and not too thick, lots of cheese (I suggest getting light cheese). Kind of pricey but they have weekly specials. This is the best take-​out pizza I’ve had in Florida by far. Give it a try!

This place is a joke. i frequent the World of Beer a few doors down from it, so ive ordered from them a few times when i was hungry. (World of Beer does not serve food) Look, even when im drunk and starving, the food from here leaves much to be desired. I thought food usually tastes better when you are starving, right? Well, not here! lol Also, the servers are rude. I order from Evies or Dominoes instead. They are always nice and consistent.

Ordered beer and pizza. Had to remind waitress about the beer. Pizza was okay but not memorable. Sauce a bit sweet for my taste. Crust good though. Beer was cold.

Wasn’t impressed. Four people– pizza and sandwiches close to $ 70.00. Everything seemed to be out-​of-​the-​box/​frozen. We got a sampler of wings. plain and fried with sides of BBQ sauce and Bleu Cheese which tasted like it came from a bottle. Nothing special to bring me back.

This review is strictly based on their «Original Buffalo Wings».
I have to borrow a quote from another Unilocal review: «Best Buffalo-​Style Chicken Wings in Sarasota» as there is just no other way to say it.
We took out a bucket (50 wings @ $ 29.75) each was perfectly crisp with the skin and the meat «bonded» as one, no breading or slippery chicken skin! The leftover wings were still crisp when re-​heated the next day. They could not be better. The bucket included a large portion of carrots, celery and four cups of blue cheese. We had 25 each mild and medium… the medium was not very spicy. Next time I’d step it up to a medium/​hot combo.
BTW, a phone order had a wait time of 35 minutes so it doesn’t appear these are pre-​cooked in any manner. It was all boxed perfectly designed to hold wings and the sides, not tossed in a bag, pizza box or Styrofoam package. They take their wings seriously!
They have a broad menu, including pizza, calzones, many sandwiches and salads.

I’ve only ordered here once, and for pizza.
Some ado has been made about the dough, made New York style.
It was my experience that you pay New York prices for what is at best average pizza. Mine came out soggy and just not that great.
I cannot speak as to any other food that is sold here, the wings or sandwiches, but the sub-​par pizza and relatively high prices dissuaded my from returning.

Yum!

Best Buffalo-​Style Chicken Wings in Sarasota. Period.
I grew up in Upstate New York, where it was a given that when you had pizza delivered, you had wings delivered too. This Casa is a family offshoot of the original Casa-​Di-​Pizza in Buffalo, NY. There are some things that you miss when you move to another part of the country. For me, tasty buffalo wings that bring out a sweat on my forehead are one of those things. Chains like Wild Wings just aren’t the same.
Great wings; good pizza. If you’re from Upstate, stop on in to catch a Sabres or Bills game on the big-​screen. Good times.
My only gripe is the limited beer selection.

Being from Buffalo makes this biased but the pizzia is better than most in this area and the wings are true to original in Buffalo.