Times Square Pizza

We love the pizza here and they are always friendly to us. We has an issue with a burnt pizza one time and the owner/​mr. pizza guy made things right. Great place to have pizza.

Firstly the pizza is ok and even occasionally I’d call it good. But there is no food that good, that is worth dealing with the rude sarcastic girl behind the counter.
Totally unprofessional and a sad disappoint to my day.

Hallelujah! I finally found a pizza joint in eastern Hillsborough County worth a flip! This place was recommended by several over the past few months and we finally got around to visiting. If you’re looking for authentic, New York style pizza, this is the place!
On the inside, the place doesn’t look like much. It’s a little dated/​run down, but there are pinball machines and some 80’s Atari’s arcade games. The wait staff and other employees were very friendly. We go a large meat lovers pizza. Huge portions and lots of toppings. We also ordered two drinks. The drinks are unlimited, but the refills are behind the counter, so an employee has to get them for you. The place looked clean, and when we were done, the staff came out and cleaned up the table (there aren’t any trash cans out on the dining room floor).
The pizza itself was great! Not too greasy, it wasn’t burnt on the bottom, and the meat toppings were delicious. I will say that it was about a 15 minute wait, which isn’t too bad, but when you’re hungry it seems like forever!
All in all, we’ve finally found our «forever» pizza joint. Great place!

Been eating here for lunch off and on for 3 years Food is good and I usually have a positive interaction with the staff. Not today. Please work with the blonde behind the counter on improving her customer service skills

Pretty good NY style pizza place. One of my top 3 favorite pizzerias in the Valrico/​Brandon area.

Best pizza in Bloomingdale! And the Tuesday special cannot be beaten, no way, no how! The sauce is awesome, the crust is delicious, and the toppings are fresh! We can’t wait to try other offerings on the menu! It’s one of our favorite things about having moved to the area. Used to go to Bloomingdale Pizza, which is pretty good, but this place has made us permanently change course. Definitely give them a try!

The fall season and back-​to-​school time has descended upon Bloomingdale and with it comes new schedules, lengthier commutes and less time and energy for cooking dinner. Most families have their favorite pizza place on speed dial for those evenings when you just don’t feel like or lack the time for cooking. For my family, that joint is the independently owned and operated New York Times Square Pizza in Bloomingdale Square.
New York Times Square Pizza has a straight forward and basic menu which allows them to focus on the good stuff. I recommend ordering from the Gourmet portion of the menu and let them do the work of picking toppings. The Time Square Special with Pepperoni, Sausage, Onion, Green Peppers and Mushrooms is as easy and delicious as they come. I like to order either the Mediterranean (with Kalamata Olives, Pepperoncini and Feta) or their version of a simple Margherita. My son prefers the Philly Cheese Steak (with Cheddar from the can) or the Hawaiian. I happen to be a fan of thinner crust pies with abundant toppings done a bit long in the oven so the bottom has that slightly burnt crispiness. But not too well done as it is important to be able to fold the slice and eat it with one hand. Yuuuum … I am getting hungry just writing this!
As regulars, we have also enjoyed other items from the menu. Need to feed an army or want plenty of leftovers? … try a Calzone or Stromboli. As a side dish the Garlic Knots are buttery and come with a cup of sauce for dipping. For a pizza place, they also make a pretty good Philly style cheese steak and their wings are crispy and flavorful, especially as a side dish. The drink menu is limited to the soda fountain or bottles for delivery.
They offer both delivery and booth service and have a few tables outside for when you find yourself a little peckish and need a slice while doing some back-​to-​school or holiday shopping at The Square. Weekly specials include Ten Buck Tuesday, where you can get any large Gourmet pie for a ten-​spot and the Friday twofer of two one-​topping pizzas for $ 19.99. On top of all this they have been known to host game nights for families and to inflate a screen out front for movie night. Speaking of which, as an added bonus, one of the owners is not only an Alumnus of Bloomingdale High School but also starred in the movies The Sandlot and My Girl. All in all, New York Times Square Pizza is the place your speed-​dial wants you to call.

We just returned from lunch here with our family. We ended up sharing a large Stromboli. When they say large they mean large it was perfectly big enough were the three of us and still leftovers for home. The prices were really good and the Stromboli was excellent. The girl that waited on us was very sweet and attentive. We have definitely found a favorite spot.

For what it was, NYTS Pizza hit the spot. We were hanging out with friends in the area and they ordered some pizza to be delivered. If I had had a chance to ‘Yelp it out’ I maybe would have advised going in a different direction. However, our pizza was delivered shortly and our noshing began.
Was it the best pizza I’ve ever had? Probably not. Would I order from them again if I was in the area and in need of some grub? Possibly.

Walked in and ordered a large two topping pizza, price was about $ 15 but the pizza was huge. Only took 15 minutes to have ready. Sat outside to eat with m y brother and enjoyed it a lot. Pizza tasted great, even had left overs for dinner. The server was nice– gave us free refills. I don’t know why the other reviews on here are bad– pizza was perfectly fine to me and I’ll most likely be back for more! I just wish it was a bit cheaper but they do run daily specials!

If I could give negative stars I would. I feel like I was insulted or slapped in the face. They had the nerve to give me burnt «loaded cheese fries» with CHEEZ WIZ!!! And charge $ 5.25 for it! Never in my life… how can you call yourself NY Times Square Pizza? I traded in my fries for just a salad and was given enough dressing for 3 bites and not even a fork because apparently they had none. So, 25 minutes and $ 13 later we ended up with a soda, gross slice, decent zeppoles and crappy salad. If I had gone back in there I would have exploded. I’d rather deal with the waste of money than be served cheez wiz or get sick. I wish I had taken a photo of the disgraceful food.

The Pizza here is great. This reminds me of a NY pizza joint, not a high end italian restaurant. Crust is thin and somewhat crisp, sausage is good.
Wings are pretty good, and sandwiches are great.

I just ordered from this place and was very disappointed by the taste quality. I love pizza but this would make me hate it. The sauce is not the type of sauce for pizza and the calzone almost made me gag. The wings were ok though. They probably need to change the name, this is not NY pizza! I guess I should have known when I saw it empty and the two people who walked in we’re friends. Get it together people!

We’ve had pizza delivered several times now, and it’s always been delicious. The cheese ravioli is also very good. We alternate between getting pizza from here and PJ’s, depending on which one my wife is in the mood for. But if it were up to me I’d always order from NYTS.

Too much hit or miss, either pizza will be fantastic or really bad. No middle ground here. Don’t eat here anymore due to the inconsistency, also the baked ziti is awful.