Brewster Pizza House

Ovepriced ($ 22 for 3 toppings) and very small pizzas for the price. Very meh food. Only get it at last resort.

First, we enjoy their hot sandwiches from the take-​out side of the store. My wife especially likes the chicken parmesan sandwich. The bar side is where we go to watch football on Sundays when the Packers aren’t on broadcast tv. They are VERY accommodating, even when the Pats are on, to make sure we can watch on one of the larger screens. The pizza especially is good, and the beer is nice and cold!

I have gone to Brewster pizza for years. It was never awesome but for that we go to NY. The pizza that I got today was inedible. The crust was the consistency of glue. I ate half a slice and the rest is going to the trash bin.
The wings are OK, moist and lots of sauce. The breading is soft, thick and not to my liking but I could see where someone else might like it.

Took forever to get someone on the phone. Delivery took forever. Pizza wasn’t that good. Sub par at best. Frozen pizza is better. The boneless buffalo wings were breaded chicken fingers with a dry buffalo flavor. Salad was regular with store brand dressing. They don’t know what real Italian pizza is or how to make it.

This has turned into my go-​to «Cheers» place. It’s a great local hangout that’s chill with good food and it’s inexpensive compared to everything else around. The staff is friendly and the bartenders are awesome. They remember your name and even what you eat and drink!

This is an update to my prior review. After trying for a very long time to get through to the business (busy tone, no answer) a woman answered and said they were too busy for delivery. I waited about 20 minutes and called back and a man answered and said they were delivering. Anyway, other than the issues with getting the pizza, when it was delivered it was very good. The man told me 45 minutes for delivery and it came in about ½ hour. The delivery driver was very nice (and busy!). Would definitely order food from Brewster Pizza House again. I was pleasantly surprised (especially on such a busy evening). Next time though, I will go pick it up (I would of this time but did not have a car available). btw, ordered the Hawaiin and a Buffalo Chicken pizza.

Not bad… We ventured out into the snow for pizza and found this place close by to Ocean Edge. The Calzone was the flatter type but very tasty, My Steak and cheese was just fine. Prices were very reasonable and they have a full bar next door.

Worst pizza I’ve had in a long time. Food wad — undercooked, oversauced.

Exceptionally below average. Cardboard crust pizza. Gyro was OK. Wings were ok. Been there twice. Wouldnt go again.

The folks who give this place a good review must be buddies with the owners. When we walked in, no hi, how are you, nothing. When our food was ready, we were summoned by the girl who took our order. She couldn’t be bothered to walk the ten steps it would have taken to bring the food to us. We ordered three calzones and the sauce on the side was ice cold. The manager walks by without a look or how are you. They are very rude here… part of the New England charm, I guess. We are always hearing calls to «shop small», to patronize local businesses on the Cape. Well, forget this place. Domino’s in Harwich makes a better pizza and you don’t receive a dose of «attitude». Save your money, shop elsewhere. It’s the only thing they understand.

not worth the trip. gyro was burnt and flat bread over toasted, pasta with sauce just bad, chef salad not worth 7.99

We have ordered from here several times and this will be the last time!
I was told at 7ish that they had no more large pizzas and we could
get kid sized ones. This is in the off season!
We ordered 2 small pizzas and a grinder. The meat on the sandwich looked like something you get in a school cafeteria and tasted bland. We will be ordering pizza elsewhere from now on!

This place has remained the same my whole life– same décor, same amazing pizza. Friendly locals will help you behind the counter and the pizza comes out pretty quickly. Try it– it’s the best pizza on the Cape.

We had a pre Easter dinner featuring pizza from BPH. I loved the spinach feta pizza. lovely sauce on the plain. Not bad at all…

Great Greek Pizza! Perfect for your first night in Brewster. Dad’s can hang out at the bar while the pizza is being made.

Average pizza and wings. Good for a night in with delivery.

They get two stars only because they are one of the only places that delivers in Brewster… sometimes. They deliver when they feel like it, despite their posted delivery hours. The pizza is decent, the sandwiches are a disaster. Fortunately for them they are the only game in town!

Pizza here was terrible. Crust was too hard and uneatable.. Also ordered a steak and cheese… it was worse than the pizza. Super dry and barely any cheese. Overall not very good quality. I will not be going back.

Very nice people and help here. Said our 2 large 14″ would be ready in 15 – more like 25 mins. About $ 16 each. Believe it to be Greek-​owned — located inside of Foster Sq, toward the back… near Oki’s sushi.
Pizza honestly was not terribly tasty – dough flat and a bit hard… ingredients quite salty and also not of the best calibre. However, for the local area of Brewster, sure am glad that we could get some easy food for our Settlers of Catan wars slated for home. they were open till about 2100… nice for us.

I have looked forward to stopping by this place every summer for years now. It has changed a bit with time, but the food remains thoroughly enjoyable. This past weekend was my first trip there of this year. They seem to have a new big screen TV viewable from the handful of tables in the eating area. Additionally, a new bar section has opened up adjacent to the restaurant in a spot formerly inhabited by another tenant in the strip mall area where this restaurant is.
I’ve never had a bad pizza here, but my favorite has got to be grilled chicken, diced garlic, spinach, and black olives. Service is quick, prices are fair, the pizza is hot, and the environment is comfortable.