Mike’s Pizza

Our ride or die in the neighborhood! We don’t order pizza from anywhere else. The delivery is always SUPER fast, the pizza is great, the crust is perfect, and the toppings are fresh. We always order a large pie with jalapeños and pineapple. They are always accommodating and friendly. Mike’s pizza for life.

I have only had the meatlovers pizza which is perfect for 2 people. This pizza is to die for! I have only ordered it on seamless. It comes quick and hot. Love it!

These guys been around over a decade, and they haven’t failed me yet. Not to sound like a fat a**, but I literally eat from here damn near every week. Good pizza, pasta dishes, AND salad. Delivery is quick and reliable. Solid!
Food ⁴⁄₅
Service– ⁴⁄₅

Their pizza is pretty solid considering there isn’t else much by. Their delivery is very fast on Seamless and I usually hit them up for an $ 8 pie — feeds two. Definitely try one of their larges with tons of toppings!

Fantastic Veggie Pizza
I have been ordering from Mikes for about a year now, I have never been disappointed.
About a month ago I tried their veggie pizza, it’s so amazing, so tasty and full of well cooked veg.
Tonight I had it cheese free as I have gone vegan and it was loaded with delicious vegetables. I honestly didn’t even miss the cheese.
Thanks Mikes!

You could spend $ 15+ on a bland medium pizza from a chain…
…or you could spend $ 11 and get a large, delicious hand-​made pizza, delivered to your door without much of a wait. It’s good, cheap Brooklyn pizza. There’s a decent variety, and the salads are fine too. Good for a group of friends or a lazy night in with Netflix.

Freaking good pizza, thin crunchy crust, thick creamy cheese. being from WV we wanted some Ny pizza. glad we stopped by!

Good pizza for this area.
Fast delivery.
Decent pasta dishes as well.
Pass on the salads, garlic rolls and mozzarella sticks — they just don’t do them well.

Solid and cheap, for a party. The white pizza was good. Came quickly!

Took over an hour and a half to deliver one pizza and when I called to ask about its status, the guy was sassy, defensive, and refused to tell me where my pizza was! WTF, dudes?!

We order Mike’s a lot, it’s the best option in the area for delivery. Sometimes the pizza is pretty spot on! Chewy crust, crisp on the bottom. But Mike’s is inconsistent– I sometimes think they have different crusts that they use. Sometimes they don’t bake it all the way. And they mess up our order every now and then, like giving a ginger ale when asking for a coke, or adding/​missing toppings. Overall, better than Beverley’s. Their delivery person is really nice, which is a plus!

Best delivery/​carry out pizza in the neighborhood. Delivery can be slow at times, but whenever I call to check on the order, it’s there in minutes and piping hot. The guys are super friendly as well. $ 9 for a large carry out pie. Can’t beat that.

As everyone says, this is not a fancy high-​falluting (sp?) pizza place. It’s just your neighborhood pizza place. But for what it is, it’s the best kind. The pizza is damn tasty. No frills, just dough sauce and cheese, but it always arrives piping hot, it’s chewy and savory and lots of sauce (I always add a little salt). There are many other such pizzarias in this neighborhood and they all serve hot circles of garbage. Mike’s is solid, consistent, reliable, and good. Toppings always good too, sometimes I get pepperoni w/​onions. If you want to get fancy they make a great Nona pie (fresh mozzarella tomatoes and basil). And the entrees/​salads are good too. Everything always arrives piping hot.
The service is also a cut above. They have always been exceedingly polite with me, over the phone and when they deliver (even when I call them every five minutes because I’m getting hungry). Never any bad attitude. Which is much more than I can say for the Papa John’s delivery guys who won’t even get out of their cars and make you come outside in the dead of winter to get your «delivery.»
Delivery usually arrives within 20 minutes which is unusually fast for any restaurant. And the prices are very reasonable ($ 10 for a large plain pie). Really I can’t say enough good things about Mike’s. Been ordering from them for years. Nothing fancy, but solid and positive vibes all around. Hope they stay in business for a long long time.
P. S. if you want to use a credit card you can order online

The pizza coming out of the place is nothing to write home about, but considering how few pizzerias are actually in the area and how low they charge… I can’t really complain. Quick delivery, cheap food and relatively enjoyable.

I was very dissatisfied when I called to place an order and I only live 12 blocks away and they told me that they do not deliver in my area.

Things have CERTAINLY changed for the BETTER at Mike’s Pizza.
I originally gave this place a bad review mainly for getting order wrong many times, but in the last year, they get it right AND the quality of the food has vastly improved! It is now my favorite place when I want pizza delivered! BRAVO!

Best pizza in the hood! Delivery takes FOREVER but the pizza is so good! Got pineapple and will do so again!

Substandard. Just wasn’t that good. Got a plain and a chicken slice. Would not go back.

This spot offers a great value when it comes to pies. As always I tried the plain slice first as I always do when trying a new pizzeria.
Not the best slice I’ve ever had but in terms of NYC pizza it’s definitely not bad. At a little over a dollar per slice your tummy and your pockets will both be equally happy. The specialty pies looked interesting so I might try something else if I return.
If you are in the area I’d recommend checking this place out for a cheap lunch or dinner. If you live nearby take out or delivery would be your best option. I haven’t checked out any other pizza spots in this area so I have nothing to compare it to in the neighborhood. I don’t live in the area so I don’t plan a return visit.

Awww, I like Mikes!
They have good hours and you can always get a slice when you need to.
My favorite is the fresh mozzarella slice, which they usually have. It really makes my day. I can’t say much for the other items, I usually get the mozzarella slice or a plain one.
Hey, it’s pizza… and it’s cheap. You can’t ask for much more!