620 On Caton Pizzeria

I have no idea what happened to this place, it was one of our go to Pizza spots, but things sure have changed… a lot. Tonight I ordered a Lg sausage and pepper pizza, a cheese steak and a Sprite. As usual, they delivered on time and everything was hot, that’s to good part. When I opened the box I was greeted with a large pie loaded with, and I do mean loaded, with uncooked green peppers and something that looked like sausage but had the consistency of a sliced meatball. It’s a good thing that I had some garlic salt, crushed red pepper and some grated parmigiano reggiano on hand because other than those adds, the only thing on the whole pie that had any taste what so ever were the peppers. I ate two slices and sent the rest down the garbage chute. I put the cheese steak in the fridge, one food bummer a night is all I can take. Maybe it’s me but it seems as though a lot of the local pizza places, in the past few years have switched to lesser quality meats and cheese. At this point I’d settle for a place that serves up that thin crust, burn the roof of your mouth, molten cheese pizza that you get in the buck a slice joints in Manhattan.

Not the best but damn very good pizza, quick delivery and affordable (comparable) to the nabe. Friendly

omg! ! i had breakfast at 620 on caton in brooklyn today. 2 eggs over easy with bacon and grits. yummy yummy in my tummy! all the way from manhattan. thxs chef pete tirado! !

It was never that great under different ownership but now its disgusting. I ordered the fried calamari which was so hard you could break a window with it. Inedible. Must have been frozen for ages.
Hopefully this shit hole will change hands again.

620 on Caton started serving breakfast and by golly its was absolutely refreshing! The chocolate chip scones were everything! So was the egg white western omelet! the top of it all was the roasted potatoes instead of home fries!!! Woooooowsers!!! If you’re in this neighborhood, the frittatas on the go is everything!!! The chef for breakfast is NOT the same as the pizzeria!!! Thanks Chef Pete!!!

This is my local pizzeria. I have been coming here for 15 years, under different owners, and I love the current owners. They serve good food, and treat you well. Tonight I wanted sausage and peppers, which has been on the menu in the past but is no longer, and they made it for me anyway. because I’m a regular customer, they have even comped me a soda. They know how to treat people right.

Because they’re «too busy» they won’t deliver to my address. I’ll be using Rockys or another pizza spot for my marginal pies.

Good straight-​up pizza at a fair price. Can’t ask more from a neighborhood joint.

Ordered a pizza on seamless, and it never showed up, even though the restaurant confirmed that my order was received.

Don’t order a chicken Caesar salad pizza from here, put sauce on the side, the toppings are not even on the pizza when it got delivered, called for a refund said I will get it b4 10, the delivery guy just left could’ve come back up in 2 mins

Sadly enough I’ve lived in the area for 2 years passing this place quite often. This afternoon, needing a pizza fix and having tried all of the over priced, tangy, and just down right nasty places near me on church ave. I walked over ordered my food from the soft spoken guy at the front.
My food took less than 10 mins, wings and a buffalo chicken slice. When I say delicious! Every inch from the crust to the plate cheese was the shhh. Wings were crispy and hot. Too bad I’m moving in 2 weeks :(my damn luck!

Just got 2 pies from there. Prices were very fair and the pizza was very good!
1÷15÷16
The pizza at this place is going downhill. Once they forgot to put sauce on a Buffalo chicken pie. Recently, they burnt a chicken parm pie, the chicken was horrible. They gave me old stale chicken on the pie. You can only do that once to a customer.

I absolutely love the place. Have been a loyal customer for a long time. Best pizzeria in the neighbourhood. My favourite is the chicken and bacon pizza with hot wings. yummy yum!!!

I decided to try this place after an article on the Ditmas blog on the best pizzerias in the area ommitted this place and many of the comments seemed to praise it. We wanted to get a pie delivered but we were a little out of its delivery zone. No problem. I ordered a pie and sodas to pick up.
We ordered the Margherita pizza with sausage. I usually like the Margherita over regular because the ingredients are generally better. After all, another name for that pie is ‘fresh mozzerella’. Ha! This is 2013. Most places wouldn’t know fresh moz if it slapped them in the face.
Anyway, the pie was… OK. The crust was a little undercooked but nothing that couldn’t be fixed in the toaster oven. The sauce and pesto was actually pretty good, except they put a little too little sauce on it, and in dollops. So you’d bite into a cheese section and occasionally get a clump of good, tangy-​sweet tomato sauce. But the cheese really sucked! Very plastick-​y taste and texture. And the sausage was corporate-​bought round slices, which BTW they skimped on. Like I said, this is Brooklyn 2013. It’s not like the old days when pizzerias competed on taste and quality. Many people on this board say this is the best pizza in the area. I kind of don’t want to find out if this is the BEST there is.
Overall it was edible, though. So I want to next try a regular plain slice before I give my final verdict.

the prices here are the same as little tonino’s. i only tried this place because i was trying to find something in the neighborhood that’s cheaper then korner pizza and decent tasting. i went here with my boyfriend and for me i think this place is better then little tonino’s. however my boyfriend thinks little tonino’s is better. they are both average pizza. i like the menu here more because there are more choices.

It pains me to make this review because I like this place in general.
But 4 times in a row they’ve F-​ed up my cheesesteak. 4 orders, each order the same, each F-​ed up in a different, sandwich ruining way.
I’ve called after the first three and reminded them to check order comments from GH/​Seam and they apologize and that’s it. No offer to make it right or anything.
So my question to you, 620, from a loyal customer since the day you opened your doors, is what the fuck does a brother have to do in this town to get a goddamn cheesesteak with no onions on it?

Best pizza in the neighborhood.

I’m in the car somewhat often with my job. Well, as usual, I was hungry and looking for a place to grab a quick bite. The sign on the store next door that said something about submarine sandwiches wet my appetite, but when I noticed they had a B rating and this place had an A, my mind was made up.
I walked in and was instantly hit by the aroma. Garlic and tomatoes and cheese oh my! I bought two slices of pizza, two drinks (I had a buddy with me) and a HUGE eggplant parm sandwhich and it all came to less than $ 15!!! WHAT!!! NOT TO MENTION IT WAS DELICIOUS!
Thanks guys. Trust me, if I’m in the area again, you’ll be getting another order for that sandwich!

Finally a pizza place that is delicious! Pizza is seasoned well, crisp & no tomato paste or dried herbs. Antipasto has got tons of meat and cheese and crisp lettuce with a ton of dressing on the side.
I intend to try the pasta very soon.
Deliver time was a bit long, but it was Friday night, prime time and they were busy, but not killer time wise, maybe 45 minutes at most.
Try it priced well and yummy! Try it you’ll like it!!!

We ordered for delivery a fresh vegetable pizza (peppers, onions and mozzarella) and an order of garlic knots. The delivery was prompt and everything was piping fresh. The pizza itself, however, left a little to be desired. The vegetable pieces were much, much too large and there wasn’t enough sauce on the pie. As a result, it tasted a little dry. The garlic knots were decent enough, but really needed a dipping sauce of some kind, which was not included. In the end, I had them with ketchup.
I’d order again and try a different pie, maybe, but there are definitely better places close by.