Argentos Pizza

For a pizza shop in Buckeye AZ this is by far the best I’ve had. Very comparable to Rays in Phoenix and I would certainly come here and eat again. Prices are reasonable, a 16″ cheese will set you back about $ 12. Garlic knots are pretty solid, as is the antipasta salad.
Lots of large and small booths in the building for groups of all sizes, clean outside and in.
If you’ve got a pizza craving here in Buckeye, go here and skip the chain places. You’ll thank yourself!

Ordered a large sausage pizza and mild wings. Yum! We will definitely be ordering again!

Very friendly team, delicious food, check out their Alfredo pasta — very rich and tasty.

Had a hankering for a Margherita pizza and this seemed like a good place to try. We called for a tea out order. We got the Sicilian version which was a good twist. Could have had some more dollops of mozzarella on it. Nice soft doughy crust. Sauce was good.
Also go a meatball sandwich and French fries. No salt was on the fries and the meatball, although not gross, were not the best.
The inside of the restaurant is old, tired, and outdated. The gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and gave me a water for the road on the house. There were 2 people eating when I was there, but uncertain if they worked there or were customers as they were speaking a foreign language with the man behind the counter that was not Italian.
Upon arriving at the restaurant it was odd. A young man came out of the side door and appeared disoriented. My wife did not go in with me but insisted on the windows up and doors locked when I went in. She said later the way he was acting was unusual. He walked to the corner. Stared at the ground and literally walked around in circles. As I exited the establishment he was coming back and stumbling. He went back into the restaurant. Not sure if this is a common occurrence or a random thing. Just an observation.
Would call it a 2.5 experience but rounded up to 3 on this one. The food ok. Service ok. Ambiance… so so.

For a growing place like buckeye we need a great pizza place and this is it! I read the reviews about the calzones so I decided to go try one. I got the calzone special and it was HUGE! I shared it with my husband and us together could not finish it. Very tasty. I’m excited to try the rest of the menu. The restaurant was very clean and inviting. The workers were very friendly!

We stopped here on the way from Los Angeles to Tucson (it’s not far from the Phoenix bypass). Great pizza. Friendly staff. They were very nice to our kids.

Great food and broad selection of things besides pizza on the menu. But the pizza is really good, freshly made dough and a good amount of toppings. fast and friendly service, it’s worth the trip.

Absolutely the best Calzones and Pasta dishes this side of Florence.
The recipes make up for any lacking in décor or ambiance…
If your’e looking for great food at very reasonable prices, it’s definitely worth the drive!
You really must check it out — We do — every time we are driving back from Mexico, or even to LA. Save the appetite because the Calzones are HUGE.

Very much enjoyed my lunch from Argento’s. The portion was huge for the $ 14(included delivery). I had the baked ziti with Italian sausage, and I could tell the sausage was previously frozen because it was a little freezer burnt and texturally the outside was a little off. This was the only misstep in the whole meal. The pasta was perfectly cooked and the sauce was great. I’ll most likely be ordering in again and include a follow up review.

We stopped by Argento’s with friends after spending the afternoon at the Hellzapoppin PRCA rodeo. Our friends had been prepping us all day describing the outstanding pizza they’d enjoyed at Argento’s. They were absolutely right on! Our party of six enjoyed excellent pizza with terrific service and value prices. Fresh ingredients were obvious. The crust was perfect and the sauce exceptional. Lots of other treats on the menu too. Argento’s is about 20 miles from our home but well worth the easy drive.

Our go-​to pizza place! Recently tried the margherita and it was really different and tasty. Love their fried zucchini too. The owner is so funny and friendly too! Great small town feel.

Love this place. coming from the East Coast (NJ/​NY), I know what real pizza should taste like. Argento’s NEVER disappoints. the owner is there all the time and is super nice! Would absolutely recommend this place!

We grew up in New York City (the Bronx) and have long searched (in New York, Washington, Pennsylvania and Arizona) for a pizza that resembled our childhood memories. After many years of disappointment friends of ours (also from New York) suggested Argentos. A Brooklyn raised couple joined us to try Argentos’ plain cheese pizza (the only way we used to order). It was heaven at first bite. The aroma was so good we brought back «fond» memories when we burned our pallets (couldn’t wait for the pizza to cool down). IT IS FABULOUS!

I really enjoy this place.
I decided to try something different (I love their buffalo chicken pizza and Stromboli’s) today. My wife order an eggplant parm sub and I got ckicken parm. They were both delecious.
The bread may have been the best restaurant bread that I have ever had.
This place has great Italian food.
The owner is very friendly and takes great pride in the quality of his menu.

Gluten free pizza!!!
Traveling cross country with two kids who were hungry. Usually along interstate routes there aren’t many choice places to eat. My daughter found this place on Unilocal after searching for pizza. What she failed to mention was it was a bit away from the interstate. After finally arriving and walking inside our noses went crazy with the yummy smells. We ordered a gluten free pizza which was perfect! Left there happy and satisfied. The detour was worth it!

Argentos has speedy delivery and is never skimpy with their toppings. A solid pizza choice for where you are out in this neck of the woods. I particularity enjoy how their crust is firm, with a bit of softness. Their sausage was lean and there was tons of it. This isn’t some mass produced sausage, this is the real deal. I hear the owners came from NY and brought their recipes with them. It shows! Great wings and fair prices make this a winner.

I actually created a Unilocal account just so I can leave a review on this place.
We tried it for the first time about 2 weeks ago and already went back last night. We have tried the pizza and it was really good. It’s a bit greasy, but I have yet to find a pepperoni pizza that isn’t. The boneless wings are delicious. My mother in law tried the steak and cheese calzone and it was pretty big and basted in garlic butter. This is now our go to pizza spot in Buckeye.

Tommy is a great guy and he makes amazing food. End of story. Try it. He really puts his heart into this and makes everything himself. This is as local as it gets. This place will make you come for more. You will like it.

My favorite pizza place ever!!! The owners always treat you like family and will even cook dishes not on the menu on request. The crust is perfect and very tasty. The ingredients are all fresh as is the dough. The portions are huge! You will not leave hungry and the prices are very reasonable. The place is very comfortable and will accommodate big parties on short notice.

I really like this place! I’ve tried it a couple times now and the service has always been great and the prices are really fair. You get a ton of food for what you pay for! The wings are great and the garlic knots are nice and garlicky. The pizza is thin crust and has been pretty greasy each time, but that can be expected with homemade-​style pizza. Definitely will go back!