Mustachio’s Pizzeria

The crew at Mustachio’s turn out some of the best subs and pizza in WNY
Being right around the block from my place has made it my GO TO fast food when ever family or friends stop by to party or watch Sabres /​Bills games
We have been loyal customers ever since their first week open and have yet to find another ‘Za place in the Kenmore area that matches their taste

Pizza is probably the best in the Ken-​Ton area. Thinner crust than most and the sauce is seasoned perfectly. Wings are average but everything is always consistently the same. The prices are pretty reasonable for the area and they usually include coupons with the delivery menu. Would give them more stars but sometimes the person taking calls and the guys behind the counter have lousy attitudes and can be a bit abrasive. The building itself also isn’t exactly the most inviting. I seem to have a hard time convincing friends to eat here because let’s face it, when you think of a mustache associated with pizza the first thing you do is look for hair in your food. Nothing to worry about here though, they have great pizza at a good price. I just recommend having it delivered.

Mustachio’s is hands down the best pizza in Kenmore! It has a thinner crust, which isn’t very common for Buffalo pizza but it’s really great. They use the little pepperonis that that curl up with a grease puddle in the middle, which obviously makes it taste even better! The cheese and pepperoni is the only pizza I’ve had but I’ve gotten it on multiple occasions and it’s been consistently good every single time. I tried the wings this time and they were decent, nothing to write home about or anything. The employees are so so in there, some times you catch them in a good mood but they’re generally pretty plain. They don’t go out of their way to be extra nice or anything, to me that doesn’t matter so much when I’m in and out in a minute just to pick up a pizza. I’m very critical of pizza as its my favorite food of all time but Mustachio’s is great, highly recommended!

I just tried to order a large pizza and a double order of wings from mustachios. The guy was pretty rude to the point where after I ordered, I called and canceled immediately. Not spending $ 30 where my business isn’t appreciated.

Beat BBQ ever !! Really great. Fast service and great subs !! Will most certain I will return

I have always enjoyed the food from here. Don’t think I’ve had a bad batch.
But…the staff can be very curt on the phone. I don’t like feeling as though I am annoying them by calling to place an order. This has happened repeatedly and I don’t know the reason and I don’t care really.
As much as I like the food, I just got tired of the attitude from them.

I’ve said this before to several people in WNY and I always get funny looks. I am just not a fan of Buffalo pizza. Most of the places that people «love», to me, well, suck. Crust is too thick, sauce is too sweet, etc.
Enter Mustachio’s. The misses and I found this gem when we were moving into the neighborhood last December. We’ve been regulars ever since.
Crust is perfect, cheese amounts are perfect and I usually get my pie «well done» and they know exactly what that means when I ask.
The staffs is always great, too. This is a great corner pizzeria in a quiet, peaceful neighborhood.

Bland and extremely average. Also, delivery took about 75 minutes even though they quoted me 45 – 60, so pizza was lukewarm when it got here. Had to put it back in the oven, which turned out to be a good thing because it was undercooked. Won’t be trying this again.

best pizza in Kenmore. wish I could say the same about the service. would have been 5 stars. too many shitty experiences

I’m no pizza guru, but the pizza here is amazing. The crust is thick and the sauce is perfect. Not too sweet, not too tangy. The slice specials are such a good deal too. Just try it.

Pizza and wings are good, with so many places in our area it’s amazing how much there is a difference in the food. They have a consistent product and is always ready when they say.

You have to either be Tom Selleck, or look like Tom Selleck, to frequent this establishment. I once went in there for a slice. It was good.
Definitely good Pizza, but definitely not the top tier of incredible Pizza, WNY has the stiffest competition possible when it comes to this Italian Pauper’s Delicacy, and so it’s really hard to stand up to some of the top places. But this slice is definitely worth a try if you’re in the Greater Kenmore Consolidated Metropolitan Area.
Buffalo actually has the best Pizza in the world — check my «best Pizza in the world» list to see all the best Buffalo pizza places, lots of my choices are Buffalo based. But this place doesn’t really live up to the hype.

I’m not really a fan of their pizza, but since they’re down the street, I decided to order a calzone one day and I am now in love. They are enormous and soo tasty. One of the guys that works there was a little rude on the phone though, but whatever. It happens.

Mike (other reviewer), is a fool. The staff is always nice to me (guess because I’m not a dick?) and I have never had anything bad from there. Really good Antipasto salad with a wide range of ingredients, and consistent pizza.
You know how sometimes you go to a place, and it’s great, and the next time it’s different? Mustachio’s is good every time.
Also, they know how to cook french fries. They don’t do them ahead of time and let them get soggy in the container.

I’m a picky pizza eater, but this place has some of the best take out pizza in Buffalo. My favorite is sausage, onion and pepperoni. If you ask for it on a thinner crust they will do it for you and it’s soooooo good!

mustachios pizza
i would just say your better off getting a tony’s pizza
the staff was shit so was the food
have a great day
god bless
i mean why go on and on about it…
who ever writes positive reviews on this place… owns it

Buffalo may be known for its wings, but people often overlook how great the pizza there is too. New York and Chicago are just fighting for second place, Buffalo is where it’s at for pizza.
The pizza at Mustachio’s is some of the best I’ve had for delivery. I’ve been told they take the time and effort to make their own dough and especially their own sauce, a characteristic that should not be taken lightly in this age of cutting whatever costs you can. This sauce is slightly, but not overly, sweet with a good depth of flavor and the right quantity for the pie. The dough likewise adds as much to the flavor of the whole pizza as any other component. They have the standard list of toppings to add, and while I wouldn’t fault you for sticking with the basic cheese pizza I would highly recommend at least getting pepperoni.
They aren’t just a one trick pony though, like most restaurants in Buffalo they make a mean basket of wings of the normal mild, medium, hot variety but also other flavors such as barbecue. Pro tip, ask for them extra crispy!
With all the pizzerias in Buffalo you owe it to yourself to stay away from the national chains and get some top notch quality pizza (and wings). Do yourself a favor and try out Mustachio’s, if you don’t like it hey there are tons of other pizza places but I would be surprised if you don’t go there again.