Miseno Risto Pub

Terrible. Eggplant parm sub was awful. Eggplant was slimy and greasy and hard. Sub bread is not homemade and has no redeeming qualities. The iced tea was out of syrup but the waitress just blankly stared at me and said they don’t make it its a Coke product from the fountain… I UNDERSTAND, it’s still not right nor is it tea. Have someone fix it. I also let her know the sub was not edible, she told me to tell them at the counter and handed us the bill. The counter didn’t try to fix anything and charged us for everything… I never write negative reviews but this experience totally deserves one.

Great. Having been doing take out once a week since it opened around 10 yard ago. Excellent eggplant parmagean and large pizza.

Went with two of the girls here after getting horribly lost in a part of Carlisle that I’d never seen in my life. After finding the highway, we decided to go to Miseno. My father’s work orders from here quite often and brings home leftovers which are always fantastic.
Anyways, we found a booth and were quickly served by Raechel. She was very attentive, keeping our drinks topped and bread basket filled. I ordered the Chicken with Vodka Sauce (which is a pink sauce). It was amazing. The chicken and pasta were cooked perfectly and the sauce is to die for! It’s by far one of the best pasta sauces I have ever had and I think I found my new favorite dish. Well worth $ 15, and chances are you’ll have enough leftover for a lunch or two in the days to follow.
For my first time actually eating there, I was quite impressed and will be back in the future.

Terrible Service, Cold Pizza — will not be back
Yesterday, I placed a carry out order over the phone. I ordered two medium pizzas (2 toppings each). I was told the order would be ready in 20 minutes, I arrived exactly 23 minutes after I placed the order. When I identified myself and my order number (#27) the cashier looked at me quizzically and explained «oh…you should have ordered 2 large pizzas instead of 2 mediums. You would have „saved yourself“ $ 3.» I explained that I was unaware of the special and the person taking my order over the phone didn’t inform me of the special. The cashier shrugged her shoulders and said «oh well, I guess you’ll know for next time». She could have offered me the cheaper price… I was taking less pizza out of the place than someone ordering two larges, right? In any case, I arrive home to find my pizzas cold in the center, undercooked and the green peppers plopped down in one big mass in the center of the pie. I have news for Miseno’s and the rest of their joint business ventures: this long time Carlisle resident will NEVER be back! I strongly recommend going elsewhere for pizzeria style pizza.

Great place for NY style pizza! I’ve been eating at this location for the over 4yrs a and haven’t had a better slice of pizza anywhere in Central Pa. If you decide to eat one of their pasta dishes, you will receive nice quality and huge portion sizes.

Miseno’s II (on High St., not to be mistaken for Miseno’s on Ritner Hwy by Gold’s Gym) is a solid go to restaurant. I have eaten here Often, and have never been disappointed. Wait, scratch that, just don’t order the veggie melt sub because they put lettuce on it! The first time it happened I thought it was a mistake, but the second time I vowed to never order a sub again that came with warm lettuce!
Besides the veggie melt sub, everything I have had here is delicious.
Another great thing about this restaurant is that they are one of the few places in Carlisle that you can go when it seems everything else is closed for some sort of non-​traditional calendar «holiday.»

Got food poisoning, two separate times. I tried it the second time since everyone raves about the place and got sick again. Completely different dishes. I do not recommend the place.

Great service, generous portions and good food. My husband ordered the regular ham and cheese calzone and it was delicious. I ordered the lobster ravioli and it had generous portions of lobster for filling and succulent shrimp in the sauce. Wonderful, satisfying meal. We highly recommend it.

Great food, Serves beer, young and old mix. Great staff, Comfortable. close in taste of nyc. Wish they would open one in mechanicsburg on the carlisle pike.