Silver In The City

What a cute shop! I stopped in one night last week to find some last minute Christmas gifts and really found something for everyone left on my list. They have a wide array of cute and trendy items including things for the home and baby. Lots of cute jewelry and accessories in the store as well. Gifts for men are fewer and farther between but they do have a pretty good selection of things targeted more toward guys. One of the things I really like about the store is that they seem to keep things really fresh. They had a ton of seasonal items for the holidays and I feel like I find something new I like every time I’m in there. The view from outside the shop is killer. Once you see their window displays and the bright, modern treasures behind, you can’t help but pop in to browse.
As far as the staff, they’re friendly, knowledgable about their merch, and professional. I recently had to return an item that I bought that I noticed was slightly damaged. The exchange was no problem even though I had already removed the tag. I appreciated the fast and understanding service at this busy time of year.
One of the best shops in Carmel, hands down!

This place just makes me feel all sorts of happy. I have seen them on facebook but didn’t realize they had a location in Carmel. I was sad when Mass Ave on Main closed and this pretty much is the same thing. Lots of Indiana vendors in one place. I bought the coolest cookie cutter shaped like the state of Indiana, which I’ve already used. The prices are mostly reasonable. The jewelry is a little overpriced for what it is, but I understand that it’s all hand stamped and made. I would like to see more Indiana vendors in there, there were a few out of state ones and it would be cool to see it totally dedicated to the Hoosier state. But I’ve already been back twice in a week to shop for more goods! I have a feeling they’ll get to know me really well!

Love this store! Also like the location in Carmel — it’s more convenient for me since I work up here. Their assortment of unique gifts is really second to none. I always know that I can find something for a birthday or Christmas present when I’m stumped as to what to get someone. Great selection of local, Indiana gifts too.
Also, what candles are they always burning? This store always smells so good! If you’re not careful, you can easily throw down quite a chunk of change, but the gifts are so fun that it’s worth it.
Definitely a can’t-miss stop if you’re looking for gifts.

I love going downtown to walk around Mass Ave. but this new location for Silver in the City has me never needing to leave Carmel again!
SITC is my go-​to place for unique birthday gifts and mindless browsing when I’m in the mood to shop for myself. As soon as you walk in, it’s very hard not to buy everything in sight. They support local businesses and entrepreneurs (United State of Indiana, etc.) and they have many «Hoosier» items! I limit my visits because I literally love everything that there is to buy in SITC.
Customer service is great and they have dog treats for your pup if you happen to bring them in… which they are very welcome!

I was excited to hear Silver in the City had expanded to downtown Carmel (the original location is on Mass Ave). I checked it out on a day they were having a 25% off sale store wide, excluding locally made goods (which is what I wanted to check out. Womp womp).
Silver has quirky knick knacks and other nicer «gag gifts» for that friend that’s hard to shop for. Cute magnets, a nice jewelry selection, home goods, etc.
I really wish they had more locally made products — I only spotted Best Chocolate in Town, PUP, and USI, but I probably missed some.
I was also a bit frustrated that there were 3 – 4 women working behind the front counter and no one greeted me — and they just talked to each other the entire time I was in their store. I was just wanting to browse, but it would have been nice to be acknowledged and make sure I didn’t need help.