NYY Steak

Went there for brunch to celebrate Father’s Day, for 75 per person I was expecting much more. More varieties. Was a bit disappointed and will probably never go back.

Fancy date night last night at NYY. I have been here with friends before so I knew the Casino would be smoky, which is why it didn’t bother me.
Started with the Steak Tartare. I wanted to love it, but I couldn’t. There was an overwhelming flavor of Dijon and horseradish with every bite. It was presented beautifully but I couldn’t eat much of it.
We shared a bone in strip (one of the aged steaks) medium rare, with sautéed mushrooms and mashed potatoes. The steak was incredible! Honestly needed no sauce or butter… Phenomenal. The mushrooms needed a little salt, and conveniently there were several salt options already on the table. Otherwise, cooked perfectly and delicious. The mashed potatoes were flavorful but over whipped.
For dessert, we had the cookie thing and it was HUGE. A full size float and 2 cookies the size of my hands. Delicious and had to take one of the cookies home Bc we didn’t even touch it!
This place has great ambience. Our view of the kitchen was perfect and I really enjoyed watching all the dishes be prepared. It is pricy, but so are most great meals !

We stopped by for happy hour at the bar before an event, so didn’t eat dinner. We ordered appetizers and experienced the best crab cakes ever! I can’t wait to have dinner here since I’ve heard from a local chef that they have the best steaks in the area.

We had a party of 8 and service was terrible. Drinks forgotten, food cooked wrong, manager not professional
I have eaten here several times and the last time I swore I would not go back, now I will never go back to a very expensive meal with the service we received
Thumbs down!

Very good restaurant. The food is usually very good and the service is always great. A unique atmosphere and the sport memorabilia is a nice touch. The pretzel bread is delicious!

Food is always great… the service was a little disappointing this time… the waiter Luis was extremely slow… our dinner was cold…

Ridiculously expensive but absolutely delicious. Best steak I ever had. I took my parents there a month ago and they are still talking about it. The lobster is outstanding, so is the pork chop. The menu is a bit limited but what they do, they excel at. Not much of a kids menu, but then again, the casino isn’t really meant for kids although they are welcome at the restaurants.
Bottom line, this is a great way to treat yourself if you’re willing to spend a little (or a lot) extra.

The experience started off good. Polite staff, well trained, very great décor. How can you not get excited about steaks and NY Yankees? The salads were so well priced and huge! Both salads were «10’s.» The big flop happened when the steak was served. Visually, it looked like an amazing steak. The price would warrant that (I forget but my NY Strip was north of $ 50). It was thick, well cooked… BUT it was so hard! It was probably the lowest quality beef a steak house could get their hands on. I was dumbfounded! I’ve had steaks at «low rent» places like Outback that were better on «the chew.» For the price, this isn’t a place to go to. We were at the casino for a charity event and went their by default. Don’t let the fancy butcher room and décor fool you. This place isn’t good. It hurts me to write this… but for steak, it’s simply not good.

I love steak houses and this one is certainly on par with any great steak house when it comes to the meat. Ambience is cool and different then most. Definitely a nice change from your standard steak house. Salads are great as was the bacon appetizer. I have not been impressed with the sides, but perhaps I have to try a few others. However, this has not stopped me from coming back as we have been here 4 times in the past year.

Been there twice with our friends.
They are VIPs at the casino so we get treated extra well and we don’t pay, so that’s a plus :-)
Food is always great, their steaks are really good even though they tend to slightly overlook them for my taste (I like them black and blue or «Pittsburg» as they say in their menu). We have tried almost everything in the menu (except desserts, we are usually full after appetizers and entrees). Everything is good.
Service is excellent.
Prices are high but it’s a upscale steakhouse, and they are all expensive.

Excellent steak. Excellent service! Way too much food (in a good way). Nice touch with branding the bone with my initials! Atmosphere was elegant but not too stuffy for those of us in shorts.

Dinner was amazing, service was top notch with smiles. The pretzels are amazing and the bone in filet is to die for. I travel for work and have eaten at many steak houses, this is one that tops my list. Best steak house in south Florida and possible around. Keep it up but go Tigers.

Steak is burned very much. Good service but the food was horrible. Will never come here again. Over priced for no reason. I have had better food other places. Who ever gave them a good rating is lying. Food took 45 minutes to come out. It was burned and the bone steak didn’t taste right at all. 278 dollars of pure garbage. I will NEVER COME HERE AGAIN!

I found this place to be outstanding service maître d’ were top notch I had the bacon appetizer and all I can say was wow maple syrup painted on dripping into a little tray of cornbread omg
I had a long bone cowboy ribeye they carved my initials into the bone had a few new knives selections of wine and finished up with an espresso it was truly a fine dining experience but fine dining
It’s not cheap there was for intergroup two bottles of wine 600 with tip
but damn it was good

Four stars because I don’t think you can give 5 stars to a very good steak place. Enjoyed good service, very good steak and veal chop. Portions were generous and cooked well. Sides were nice and a bit different. Steak sauce on the side to test was not 5 stars. Peter Luger sauce is 5 stars. Pricey but who cares when it’s a Steflik house. Everyone was happy.

I’ve dined here at least eight times. The Oysters Rockefeller are tasty, the carpaccio has a nice spice and the shrimp cocktail was huge, cold and crisp. The bone in rib eye is fantastic and should always be ordered medium rare. The Alaskan King Crab is excellent, the veal chop was great and the filet mignon was exactly what a filet mignon should be. Two great sides are the garlic mashed and the asparagus. Finally, I’ve had all the desserts except the donuts and they’re all delicious. Service is always on point and they’re attentive. Yes, it’s expensive. But here, what you pay for is what you get!
I’ve done the Sunday Brunch once. I’m not an «all you can eat» person, but it was over the top and the $ 75 pp is justified. Plus, it’s unlimited mimosas, Bellinis and Bloody Mary’s.

Food was great! But the service was sloooooowwwww
This is an expensive, traditional casino steakhouse. Your meal will likely take over 2 hours to complete and your bill will testify to that statement!
Amazing stone crab claws and watching them butcher the steak when you first enter the restaurant is culinary artistry.
I’m not rushing back anytime soon, but if you are in the area and in the mood for some red meat (and recently got paid) it’s not a bad option.

Made a special trip to Coconut Creek to try NYY. We don’t lend much credit to restaurants located in casinos but this is my second restaurant in this casino and both venues did not disappoint.
First, the deco is upscale and modern presentation of Yankee baseball: wall of knives, baseball themed white plates, tastefully displayed baseball paraphenalia.
We were greeted immediately by the hostess and another staff member merely walking by. The hostess was great at setting expectations with each guest by stating the wait time and in what order we will be seated.
We were seated at a roomy u-​shaped table and our 2 servers introduced themselves. They were both professional and friendly. The 2^nd server was excellent at keeping our water glass filled, as it should be. I hate having to ask for my water to be refilled.
In no time, they brought over warm giant pretzels and cranberry bread. Both were crispy and soft where they supposed to be. They give you 2 types of butter. I could have ended my meal at bread…
Now the steak. We both ordered the Cowboy Bone-​in Ribeye, medium rare. Perfect medium rare. And delicious with generous marbling throughout the cut. I do have to mention the inconsistency between our 2 plates even though we ordered the same exact way. The other steak had a crisp dark sear. While mine did not. The other steak, when cut into, bled on plate. That means the steak was not allowed to sit. Mine did not bleed. So this indicates to me our steaks were cooked with much time apart.
As a side we ordered the Roasted Cauliflower with crusted parmesan special. The cauliflower was not roasted at all and was cold. They basically took raw cauliflower and roasted a light sprinkle of parmesan. The side was not as tasty as it could have been.
The experience overall was positive. The food was definitely decent. I would dine here again.

I shall preface this review with this: order anything and whatever you want: meal was paid for by big pharma. this location is located inside the coconut creek casino. its smokey as f in there. thats the one big minus when it comes to this place, it creeps in to the restaurant even. that being said, we had the private room in the back with great service, the steaks are flinstone size and their south african lobster tails were on point. the sides and apps enough to feed a s mall army.(i cant recall exact sides but none left a sour taste in my mouth nor none that made me yearn for more) I would be back w my oxygen mask and someone else fronting the bill, otherwise will prob have to pass, even with the scrumptious food

Visited NYY steakhouse last night to celebrate our anniversary. From start to finish it was top notch. The hostess started the night off by wishing us a happy anniversary and it kept getting better and better.
We sat with a nice view of the open kitchen. Watching the team cooking the food and watching everything coming out quick from grill to table was awesome… nothing just sits waiting to be picked up.
Stated off with those delicious pretzels. I could have eaten 10 (but I didn’t) and the mustard horseradish butter was soooo good.
App: crab cakes… so good. Fell apart. why? Because it wasn’t filled with breadcrumbs! It was ALL crab.
Dinner: husband had the bone in cowboy ribeye. Cooked perfect. Barely any inedible fat and our dog got the have the bone this morning. I had the surf and turn. Filet was cooked PERFECT. (This means a lot because the last 2 filets at different restaurants were not). Lobster tail was huge and cooked perfectly.
Sides: baby beets. Husband loved them… I don’t like beets. Skillet potatoes. Okay… could have been hotter. It’s a side… nothing special.
Dessert: cappuccino… tasty, but could have been hotter… that’s just my preference. Cookies and cream dessert with a yohoo float… absolutely sinful. Couldn’t even finish a quarter of it.
Service: service was WONDERFUL!
Worth every penny!
Why only 4 stars? 1. Hated walking through the smoky casino to get there. Food could have been a tad bit hotter. 2. Food was not cold, just could have been hotter.

Came here with my two brothers and our significant others and I was pleasantly surprised!
The service was great as was the food… We ordered 2 dozen raw oysters which were very fresh… The stuffed mushrooms which where good, the beef carpaccio which was good, and the shrimp appetizer which were also large and fresh.
We all had steaks… my brothers and I all ordered the Cowboys rib eyes where they engrave your initials in the bone which was a nice touch and needless to say they were great!
The girls ordered filets which they also seemed to be very pleased with… For dessert we ordered crime brûlée which was absolutely amazing and their 151 volcano which was good but in my opinion not suitable for children as you can clearly taste the abundance of Liqour which they attempt to burn off as they prepare the dish table side…
Over all NYY steak house was great and I will def go again… However my only gripe is its location being that it’s located inside the coconut creek casino when you walk into this casino it’s very smokey as everyone is smoking cigarettes and cigars in the building… Not good for us non smokers… Had this restaurant been located somewhere in a smoke free environment it would certainly be a 5 star rating in my book!

Went to celebrate my birthday and it was a great experience. They personalized everything, including the birthday dessert and a photo to remember the night!
The food was AMAZING. Their bread basket has pretzels! We were pleasantly surprised by the whole meal and our servers were so attentive.
Both of our steaks were mouthwatering and all of the sides were delicious.
Worth the price– Can’t wait to go back!