Post Corner Pizza

Gave this a try because everyone said it was so good. Well, it was my first and last time. Pizza had absolutely no flavor at all. We ordered a small cheese and it was completely tasteless.

My family and I have been going here for over a decade and were always satisfied with the service, but my last few visits leave much to be desired. Maybe it is new staff who don’t put as much effort into customer service as the other familiar faces. Waiting for our food was surprisingly long. The waitress offered a second basket of dinner rolls. How very nice of her. I’ll overlook that she took away the basket before I had a chance to reach for the butter while I was cutting into the last roll. She’ll be back soon with another basket and more butter, right? Fifteen minutes later and she never came back to our table. We had to stop her as she rushed by us and ask for more rolls. Then we waited… and waited… and waited for our pizza after we finished our appetizers. She didn’t seem that concerned with our table and maybe 20 minutes later she apologized and said they’re backed up in the kitchen. However, the table next to us ordered at the same time. They were a table of three and ordered similar items as we had. They were served promptly. Their pizza was done well before ours. When they finished their dinner and left, we were still waiting for our pizza. Absolutely ridiculous! By the time our pizza finally came, I already lost my appetite.
And as if the service couldn’t get worse tonight, when we asked for our last slice to go, they just gave us a tin foil and made us wrap it up ourselves! The table next to mine received the standard box wrapped in a plastic bag for their last slice of pizza.
Quite frankly, I may have lost my appetite for Post Corner Pizza for the foreseeable future. Seems like there is a decline in service each time I’ve visited. Tonight was the worse service I have gotten at this restaurant. It’s a shame because my family were regulars for over a decade and continued to come back due to the friendly staff. The food is good but not unique enough that I can overlook poor service. There are other restaurants with similar quality food that provide consistent service to all their customers.

Our pick up orders at Post Corner Pizza have been completely off putting 2 weeks in a row. Both times we were given 20 – 25 minute pick up times but both weeks, our orders took twice as long. We waited 55 minutes for only 3 items tonight and no apology for the wait. We are now looking for different go-​to takeout place.

Food is decent here. Good Greek fare. Was really disappointed is the cleanliness of the bathrooms this time. My wife had to ask for soap in the ladies room. And the men’s room was close to a NYC subway bathroom.

This is probably one of the best pizza places in town. We stay close by and we often visit this place or order in when we have a craving for pizza. The place serves not just pizza but great Greek food. I loved their spinach pie and the Greek salad. The waitresses are extremely friendly and the service is really good.

I have been going here for a long time. I have always enjoyed the pizza. I recently went there and we ordered the same as always. The sausage on the pizza tasted off. When I said something to the staff instead of an apology for my bad experience and or how can I make this better for you, I was questioned and interrogated on my taste. They made me out to be a criminal. Not a good experience.

The food is subpar. I had a meatball grinder that taste more like a «mushball grinder». I’m not sure the beef is real beef, from what I could taste, it’s artificial. To make matters worst… the service is poor. The cashier who looked to be the owner didn’t acknowledge me when I walked in nor did she thank me after I paid for my order. I felt discriminated against. I’m Hispanic and unfortunately know a thing or two about discrimination. I want a refund. Not only for the disgusting service I received, but also for the disgusting food. I don’t recommend this place to anyone. And I will never go back there! I would give this place a zero star if I could. If you want great food and great service, visit Hope Street Pizza in Stamford, CT. It’s 5 miles from this place.

Incredible. My friend and I went there and talking about how years ago, they would give him a pre-​made off the top of the oven when he would arrive to order take out. He would never accept it. Sure enough we got a pizza at our table and from the taste and texture of the crust being soft and mushy, worse pizza ever from a greek restaurant. Go to East Ave in Norwalk.
Never again post pizza.

Came off 95 looking for a place to eat. We were very happy that we lucked upon this place. Because of the name, we expected a pizza joint. The menu is large with a variety of options. My group of 7 all ordered Greek. All the portions were generous and everything was delicious. If I lived closer, I would make this a regular spot. They far exceeded my expectations.

This place has the best pizza in Fairfield county and I should know as I’m a connoisseur of good pizza. The grilled cheese and ham sandwiches are great and the meatball and cheese sub is amazing. My husband loves the ravioli. The waitresses treat you like royalty when you walk in. Even the young woman who clears your plates and doesn’t speak English always has a bright smile for the customers.

Post corner pizza has been around forever and I’m not sure how it has managed to stay open. The one consistently good item on the menu is the Greek salad. We ate there last night and it will be the last. The iced tea was like water and when we told the waitress, she already seemed to know there was an issue with it. She was rude from the minute we sat down, the well done pizza we ordered was barely cooked enough let alone well done, the margarita personal pie was disgusting and when the waitress asked if it was okay and was told that we didn’t like it, she said «Yea, the margarita pizza isn’t good here» and the kicker… one of the people in our party didn’t get his meal at all. We told them to remove it from the bill and they blamed the cook. $ 55 for a pizza, a salad and two orders of mozzarella sticks. I felt like I had been robbed. Never again.

Delicious pizza & salads. Very reliable. Very fast. Extremely friendly staff. Greek style. They cut the large pizza into rectangles.

This is my favorite pizza place. I just love how crunchy and crispy the crust is. It’s always so hot when we pick up. Love that it is cut into squares. Haven’t actually eaten at the restaurant since 2004 or so but we do take out all the time. So consistent.

I am writing this updated review because I have realized Post Corner Pizza has lied to me several times. In Post Corners response to my review they said I wasn’t charged for the pizza that had the bug on it. Today I realized when I was checking my credit card bill they still charged me for my pizza when they said they won’t charge me for the pizza with the bug. In their response to my review they also changed their story around. In the first response they Post Corner said that the bug that went into my pizza was a cricket that hopped into it when it was being cooked due to the doors that they sometimes leave open in the summer. Now they changed the story to the bug hopped into the pizza on the way to my house in the delivery car. For several reasons this is not true because the bugs was baked into the pizza as you can see from my first review and how’s does a bug that size get into the pizza when the pizza is in a cardboard box sealed. They were also trying to make it clear that it didn’t happen in the restaurant when it did. The other thing that doesn’t make sense to me is the other change saying they saw the bug on the way to my house and made a new pizza for me. This bothers me because there saying they saw the bug before serving it to me and they still served it to me. This doesn’t make sense to me as of how the bug would get in and why they would change stories. The only reason that they change their story is to cover up that the place is infested with bugs. I am truly sadden that they would lie to me when I’ve been going there for 25 years. I am never going there again because I’m not supporting a business that lies to their customers.

Sometimes a restaurant just makes you feel welcome. Our waitress while busy was friendly, efficient, and communicative especially with our 10 month old daughter with whom she made friends. Patrons from nearby smiled and came over to say hi explaining that despite living in Boston they still make sure to stop off for dinner remembering when they used to eat here when they were kids.
It isn’t often that a restaurant draws a mix of families, younger kids, and older couples all at the same time. That may be the mark of an institution! We will be back with the whole family.

Definitely a fan!
Awesome greek salad, and the price is right. The salad had a bunch of Peperoncinis. which is the best! I like places that bring rolls before your food comes out, so that is always a nice touch.
I have also had their mozzarella sticks, which were tasty, and their pizza, which I could have done without.
However, for a cute spot in Darien, Post Corner Pizza is definitely a great place.

We love Post Corner! We used to get it on pizza Fridays every weekend when I was younger. The pizza is always great it’s Greek style which is a nice break from the norm around. It’s consistently great and always has a great crunch to the crust. Tonight we tried something other then pizza and went for the Gyro platter which was great! They salads are great Greek style as well they have an excellent house dressing that’s really good. We both highly recommend the place we always do delivery but they have a nice comfortable dinning room for nights when you want good food in comfort!

My brother and I were looking for dinner, and were debating Chipotle and a few other options. To do something different, we decided to order from here. I had previously come and ate a pretty good chicken parmigiana grinder. It was flavorful and moist unlike other similar grinders.
Tonight we had a craving for calzones, so we ordered two bacon calzones and wings. Our experience when we sat down at home, was certainly lacking. The calzone was clearly pressed with a machine, and contained about a pound of mozzarella, and not much ricotta or bacon. It was greasy. The sauce came straight out of a jar; typically I can tell the difference between jarred sauce and fresh sauce — The flavor has hints of sweetness, and the spice mixture is overwhelming.
The wings were frozen from a bag and thrown into the fryer.
This is my first review, because I was disappointed in this experience and will not go back; there is a John’s Best that is closer on the Post Road, and it is likely cheaper.
My expectation of pizza and Italian-​type dishes was far from satisfying. I can go to Pizza Hut if I want mass-​produced, low quality food. I hope they start taking the time to make their own ingredients.

Just not my type of pizza. Greek style, incredibly greasy and terrible oily crust. Amazingly, a lot of people love it. Can’t speak for the food though as I never ordered it. only the pizza. So take this review for what it’s worth!

Best pizza and best gyros in town!
HOWEVER, WORST customer service anywhere around!!! The owner is a truly nasty and dishonest individual. He doesn’t deserve to remain in business.