The Pizza Cabin

Just average. Had high hopes since this seems to be a local favorite. We had the pepperoni pizza, Italian sub, bbq pizza, garlic bread and wings. Everything was pretty bland. Best thing was the pepperoni but even that was fairly tasteless. Crust tasted frozen. Too bad! Not sure we will be back.

The pepperoni and pep pizza was killer. Top 5 for me. Def worth the trip from Hilliard.

We have driven past a thousand times thinking we should stop by sometime. Tonight we finally did and so glad we pulled in. The environment reminds us of a mom and pop shop down in the Smoky Mountains. The customer service was top notch and the pizza was awesome. We tried one of their homemade meatballs and it was stellar. Looking forward to coming back and trying their subs … Blessings!

Great pizza. Thin crust. Great sauce. Excellent service. From Jersey so I am really picky. This is good.

Great pizza. It’s a thin crust style pizza with sauce that is sweet enough to where it’s good but not too sweet to where it doesn’t belong on a pizza. Pepperonis were tiny but they put a lot on and they were very flavorful.

I ordered ahead and picked up through their drive thru. The pizza was on time and the guy was pleasant enough but the pizza kinda sucked. It wasn’t the worst I’ve had but it was pretty close to below average. I can’t say that I’ll be back anytime in the near future.

The pizza is always fantastic and it is worth the drive. The service isn’t always the most polished, but we haven’t had a bad experience.

I haven’t tried a huge variety of their menu because I HAVE to order the Hawaiian pizza if I order from here– it is the BEST Hawaiian pizza I’ve ever had (I order with out the almonds, but still amazing) Meatballs we’re good as well. Did have a little longer wait when we arrived to pick up, but the pizza was hot.

Great local business that we love supporting. They provide great fresh pizza subs and amazing boneless wings. Great personalized service and a very family friendly feel. The hands on ownership and care is clearly recognizable.

Decent pizza. The pepperoni was pretty spicy so my two young kids weren’t able to eat any. The garlic cheesy bread is basically a sub bun with cheese but was decent. The location is small and kind of dingy but seemed cleanish. Probably wouldn’t have ordered from there if I’d seen it first but I ordered then picked it up. Decent price. Friendly staff. My pizza was waiting on top of a shelf and not in a warmer like at most pizza shops but it was decently warm after driving home. Nothing special. It I’ve certainly had better and worse.

Wife and I want ¼ and ¾ split on our pizza. Some places act like it involves quantum physics to figure out divide a Pizza that way. Pizza Cabin said, «Sure however you like it.» They have a 3 meatball appetizer and not wanting 3 I said, can you sell me just one and he said, «sure, we put parmesan cheese and sauce over it is that OK?» Bottom line, there was a bearskin on the wall, an easy chair and a TV in a corner. It’s the kind of place I love to go to on a cold dark winter night. Cozy and down to earth feel. Staff was friendly, accommodating. Pizza was excellent, meatball was awesome. Only change I’d make it to cut the onions smaller. They’re good, just to big for my taste and I know if I ask them to cut them up a little for me, they will. It you just want good food without all the horns, bells and whistles (and sterile environment) of the big stores, this place is good. Told my wife as we were leaving, I felt comfortable there.

Pretty harsh, I know, but here’s why:
–Placed order at 4:50pm, was told 15 – 20 minutes, got pizza at :5:30
–They use frozen pizza shells (no, I’m not kidding…)
–Employee was eating in the food prep area
The place was pretty busy but they should have been able to give me a more reasonable timeline. This alone wouldn’t give them the low rating. It was when I saw them pull frozen food service pizza shells out of the freezer that really upset me. WTH, I can get that crap at a ⁷⁄₁₁. Sauce was acidic and there was lots of it. The cheese was sparse and lacking any flavor, the toppings were fair.
While standing there for about 30 minutes, I noticed the employees would go from preparing the food to answering calls. Typical I guess, but it was a little unsettling watching their hands touching their face, touching their hair, touching the phone and pen and then they walk over and prepare food without washing their hands or wearing gloves. The worst of it was watching one of them eating pepperonis out of the bin a foot away from a pizza being prepared — yuk.
Sigh, is there no good ‘real’ pizza in this area? I hate the thought of going back to driving an hour round trip for Borgata.

Just moved to Delaware a few months ago and this is best pizza place I have found. The guys are super friendly and the pizza is stellar!

Stopped into The Pizza Cabin Friday with one other family after a long day boating.
I have always wanted to try this place and after this visit we will be putting this on our list of pizza places to order from more often.
The kids had a pizza and some wings which they loved! My wife and I had the Calzone which was awesome!
The negative, I believe this place does more carry out than full service. The drinks were not fountain drinks and the sitting area was very small, however there were picnic tables out front!
If you are into carry out then I would highly recommend this place!
Keep up the hard work!

Great pizza perfectly cooked the several times we have ordered it. Try the spicy sausage it has a good kick to it. Perfect balance between a crisp crust and well cooked ingredients. I love pizza and am on a quest to always try new spots, but this place has you coming back.

I have been trying to find my fav. Delivery pizza in lewis center. These guy are def in the running. The pizza was thin and the sauce had a perfect sweetness and acidity. It was very reasonable as well. On top of everything else the guy on the phone and the delivery guy were very polite and nice. I will be going back

One of best pizza places in Columbus. Spoke with the owner while there on my first visit today, and these guys are very adamant about their pizza and quality food ingredients. We got three pizzas, Hawaii 5 – 0, supreme, and pepperoni. All three were spectacular. Thank you!

I don’t like decreasing stars, but after two benefit of the doubt experiences here… I can’t let my rating stand.
I’m not really sure what has happened to the quality at Pizza Cabin. I went to their dine in location further south and was not impressed, then after a couple tries again at this location… hoping that their ovens were just better and more broke in. Nope.
They changed their meatballs somehow, and now their subs, which were once «craveful» are now… dismal. They are too saucey and the meatballs are lacking flavor. They just fall apart and are like eating plain cooked ground beef. NO-​BUENO.
The pizza left me feeling not so hot after a couple slices and dare I say it… it was close to Massey’s in quality. In other words… not very good.
I have to say, I am REALLY disappointed! Something has changed and it isn’t for the better.
For the first time in my life I can say I had a «skunky» pizza.
Hopefully, something can change. I really used to dig this place and it sufficed when I could not make it to other locations around central Ohio that offered decent Midwestern pizza.
I guess I am back to my search once more for awesome pizza in the area.
Minus $ 25 bucks in my pocket and ¾ a large pizza in the garbage.
Take Caution, friends.

We came here for a work lunch and it was delicious. They cook their pizza in a stone oven rather than a conventional one, and you can really taste the difference. It does take longer to get your food, but it’s worth the wait. The owner was our waiter/​cashier and he interacted with us and we had an enjoyable time. He also gave me a free side of ranch for my calzone, which I really appreciated because most places charge you for these. I will definitely be stopping by again and look forward to when they open their location on Lazelle Rd!

My wife and I have been wanting to try this place for the last 4 – 5 years. Finally, as we were driving down Route 23 last night, we decided to stop.
Best. Idea. Ever.
Admittedly, I’m only leaving 4 stars because it is a pizza place, but if you are looking for a GREAT pizza place somewhere between Delaware, OH and Polaris; this is the place to go. They use high quality ingredients and are super friendly when you walk in. Try their homemade hot sauce (made with chipotle peppers); the rich smoky flavor can’t be beat.
The dining area does not have a ton of seating inside, but there are also a few tables outside. They also do delivery and have a pick-​up window so you don’t even have to leave your car if you are picking up your order. No matter how you get it, if you are in the mood for pizza, this is certainly a place you’ll want to try.