c/o the Maidstone

We stayed here recently for one night in the Hamptons, and really were let down by the stay. The place does have a unique retro charm to it, based on its Scandinavian theme throughout the property. With that being said, it was immediately clear to us on arriving that the inn was quite tired, especially when compared to other lodges in the area, including 1770 House and the Reform Club.
We paid $ 1000 for a one night stay (Hamptons in the summer!) and therefore expected a very nice stay.
The room lacked privacy, as it faced the highway. It was small and tired, and the sofa bed, which they charged extra to set up, was incredibly uncomfortable. Additionally, only a «continental» breakfast was included. The free bikes were one positive, as we took a ride into town.
Overall, was not a luxury stay that we expected. The place was not run as one would expect with a luxury property, and the room was run-​down.

Disclaimer: I lived in Scandinavia for several years and so the bar for Scandinavian-​inspired quinine is quite high. Although my comments below are really focused on the qualities I think most couples are looking for in a night out: pleasant ambience,
Service that is so good you don’t realize it’s there, and quality for the menu price.
Really wanted to like this place more. My husband and I had reviewed the menu in great detail and settled on a night we thought would allow us to enjoy their early dinner prix fixe. However there must have been a discrepancy or seasonal change between their web site and the menu in the restaurant because we were unable to order the prix fixe. But that’s not why I’m giving it three stars…
The good: nice ambience and I like that ingredients are locally sourced. There’s even a special menu for your dog, should you choose to bring him or her along! those with food allergies will also appreciate that he menu is clearly labeled for what is gluten free etc. More places should take Maidstone’s lead in this regard.
Could be better: felt like we were forgotten at times, and they didn’t clear our plates before the main course… In fact they moved my husband’s bread plate to my side of the table when I said we wanted to keep the bread basket. Expected larger size portion for what you’re paying. I truly appreciate the local food movement and enjoy many restaurants who are embracing this philosophy but I do not understand why this place is more expensive and skimpier portions than in brooklyn’s higher end neighborhoods. At &30+ for a half serving of scallops you expect more.

Wow. I was absolutely FLOORED with my recent experience at The Maidstone. I can literally think of no wrong.
1. Décor — Quirky, cute, modern, fun. There are plenty of modern details (a light-​up swing on the front porch, wide-​eyed portraits in the hallways, acid-​washed photoscapes in the garden). Yet, these do not overwhelm the classic American aesthetic we have come to associate with East Hampton (white-​washed wood, red bicycles, flower garden). The combination is visually stimulating without being jarring. Impressive, unique, awesome.
2. Rooms — yes, small if you’re coming from a different region, but as a visitor from Manhattan, I guess I’m used to small spaces or something, because my room size (the Tove Jansson, one of the smaller rooms), was fine. I think that the thoughtful décor contributed to it as well, as the room was super light and airy. Some cute amenities — French press, house blend tea, Malin + Goetz amenities (full-​size, not those tiny hotel soaps that you keep dropping in crevices), clogs, a REAL breakfast (fresh-​squeezed juices, decent coffee, pastries, smoked salmon and meats, pâté, yogurt, hard-​boiled eggs).
3. Service — hands-​down, this MADE my trip. The nicest people that seem to anticipate what you need before you need it. Case in point, we had purchased a cake and wanted to do some late-​night munching. We asked the front desk if we could grab some silverware, just expecting something quick and casual. They not only brought out silverware, plates, and napkins, but also provided us with a candle so we could enjoy their garden by night. Another example, we saw India, the manager, wearing a beautiful hand-​made wreath in celebration of Swedish Midsummer. India, sensing our admiration, offered us a pair of scissors, some twine, and allowed us select blooms straight from the garden. Little things people, little things.
4. Yoga — okay, so I know this isn’t a major thing that people look for in finding a place to stay, but this yoga class was AMAZING. The instructor was super competent, and doing yoga in the Buddha garden was pretty much the most tranquil thing to happen to me in a long time. I highly recommend this course, just because the environment cannot be beat.
I just have the fondest memories from our stay. Will be back for sure.

My girlfriend, bulldog and myself just returned from a fabulous weekend break at c/​o the Maidstone.
We arrived late on friday night following a very slow drive from Manhattan. Tired and hungry we were welcomed like old friends, with a particularly warm welcome for the dog, by the amazing staff and told that a table in The Living Room restaurant would be waiting for us as soon as we wanted to eat. After being escorted to our room we enjoyed a superb meal, cared for by Casey, and Henri was on hand to recommend a perfect bottle of wine (he did this multiple times over the weekend). Off to a great start.
Waking early on a sunny saturday morning we headed downstairs to enjoy a full continental breakfast (included in the rate), where the dog received her now regular dose of love (and even had a place at the table!).
The rest of the stay continued like this and we could not have wished for a more relaxing, warm and enjoyable weekend. The staff were superb and the hotel felt like a home away from home. We can not wait to come back in the summer (a lot).
It is a superb place to stay if you are looking to unwind and relax, especially if you are dog owners. Thank you Casey, Henri and all the staff for a great stay.

The Maidstone in East Hampton is absolutely the most delightful place to spend a day, or evening. The grounds are magnificent; the location is awesome as your are right in the town of East Hampton where the beautiful people live, entertain, shop and dine.
The maidstone is beautiful and staying there will have you smiling. The rooms range from elegant to «thats a hoot» with eclectic furnishings, and great views of the town and grounds. The help at the maidstone could be on a You Tube video showing the way to treat guests. The help is knowledgeable, charming and attractive.
Aside from the fabulous rooms, the other major attraction is The Living Room restaurant where some of the best scandanavian food is served. This elegant restaurant is one of the Hampton’s best. The diners combine elegant local with celebs and tourists. The mix makes for fabulous people watching. Loved all their seafood plates and their famous swedish meatballs.
The hotel is overseen by Sophie a beautiful and charming lady whose warmth and gracious hospitality creates a positive happy energy for one and all. Adam the Dining Room manager is a terrific host and adds an elegance and knowledge to the restaurant.
All in all The Maidstone is Awesome. Loved every minute of our stay and the fabulous dining.
Highly recommended for romance, day cations, stay cations. Great for families and pets as well.

THIS IS THE PLACE TO STAY IF YOU ARE IN THE HAMPTONS — END OF STORY!
OK — so need more info on this place? Here’s the deal:
I WORKED HERE for just a few days as their Night Auditor. The place is EXQUISITE!
The rooms are ALL DIFFERENT and are ALL MAGNIFICENT!!! Some of the rooms are just that, rooms, and then they also have a few «suites» which are small apartments in the rear of the property (including guest houses) They are simply impeccable. Everything that everyone else here said in their reviews sounds totally accurate. The only reason why I chose not to work there was because I have experience as a Front Desk — Night Auditor, which they hired me for. The person training me took that out of control and wanted me making French Press coffee for guests, etc. and Jared doesn’t do French Press coffee for anyone, sorry, not my thing unless you’re paying me much MUCH more… Also they wanted me to memorize the history and design of each room and the life story of the folks whom they named every room after… Um… NO…
Anyway, I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND the hotel — and they have these cool retro Bicycles to lend out to guests so you can cruise EH in style!
Rooms have phones and TV/​Playstation/​Flat-​screen
DVD’s and Games are available in the Library located in the lobby
NOT ALL ROOMS ARE PET FRIENDLY SO CHECK!!! But the common areas of the Hotel are and as a Dog person I would highly recommend!
The (Scandinavian) Restaurant and Bar are great — Kitchen was clean too!
Parking lot is provided so you are OFF STREET (Very Important during the season in EH)
On Rte 27 VERY close to EH Jewish Center (Walking Distance) and downtown EH.

Went with my partner and well-​behaved toddler. Service was impecable — polite, friendly, helpful but not intrusive. Very family friendly without feeling like you’ve gone to the family camp. Breakfast which was included in our package was amazing — the «Continental» includes pastry, greek yogurt and granolla, cheese, fruit, and ham. All the rooms are different but ours faced the back lawn and was clean, well decorated, and had good ammentities (couch, desk, fridge, clawfoot tub and shower). Someone has problems facing the cemetary in front — — really??? It’s a historic cemetary from the 1600’s and is pretty cool — it’s not like you’d be watching them bury bodies and have funerals all day (and anyway in the Hamptons why would you stay in your room all day even if they did). Hotel provides beach umbrellas, chairs, towels, AND the all-​important beach parking pass! Has bikes (including some with baby/​kid seat on back).
Easy walk, bike, drive to the beach.
Chairs on the porch and well-​placed (meaning arranged for maximum number of people to have relative privacy) on the back lawn for reading, relaxing, tanning, whatever you want.
It’s not inexpensive, but we felt it was worth every penny! I’ve only been home one day and I’m dying to go back… I wish I could live there!

Ok, I was torn and the 4 should have taken it because of the pet friendly concept. Truly, the pet welcome is beyond compare ie. candlelight dinner in the restaurant in front of the fireplace with my pup (in the lovely designated portion of the lovely interior). So my criticism comes with that caveat. AND I GET that one must pay for this pet priviledge). The Scandinavian theme and funky unique artistic vibe were very cool. Also, THE LIVING ROOM restaurant on site was beyond excellent as far as cuisine goes.
BUT, disappointingly, the significant cons:
1. Cold mannered reception desk, wait staff, very short on smiles… charisma.
2. Upcharge (who does that?) for housecleaning at the tune of $ 33/​night (on top of the nightly $ 25 petcharge)
3. Odors in the room. Creepy upholstery stains and a strong odor of «other odors being masked». Truly have never stayed in such a pricey accomodation that wreaked of cheap fabric softener (sheets and towels).
4. And lastly… the mattress/​lack of mattress on the beds. It is not a mattress, more like a soft thick, very thick padded quilt. I overheard guests phoning with a request for a board underneath for their upcoming stay… odd stuff. I get that this may be very Scandinavian, but, as an American I would have preferred a headsup.
Bottom line, I expected more for the price I paid and the pictures that I saw on the website.

My husband and I enjoyed a short little getaway at Maidstone through a daily deal site package and got a great deal considering rooms are usually $ 500 – 800 per night. First, Maidstone is very dog friendly, which is marvelous if you love dogs. We brought our minigoldendoodle Lucy and we were able to enjoy «restaurant» service with our dog. We enjoyed lunch, cocktails and breakfast as a family, which was really fun. The restaurant «Living Room» is Swedish themed (Swedish meatballs, ligonberry, etc. on the menu). The rooms are named and designed after Nordic people with varying degrees of fame, such as the Alvar Aalto room and Brigitte Nielson. We stayed in the Hans Christen Anderson room, which unfortunately faced Main street (and thus the town cemetary) and the Tove Jannson room across the hall also has this view. I love that the Inn is design forward, colorful and pet friendly. It faces a cemetary which is not a positive feature, but it is walking distance (equidistant) to the beach and town center. However, to be honest, if I were paying full price for everything, I would have higher expectations but overall, we had a lovely stay.

This hotel is the perfect amount of luxury balanced with eco friendly amenities, friendly staff and style. The bar was a perfect place to gather and have some appetizers and cocktails, with French bartender included. The hastens mattress was very comfy and I have always wanted to test the brand. Loved the Scandinavian style. Lots of personality and high end touches make me a happy lady! Malin + Goetz products are always a plus too. A wonderful spot. Go stay, and enjoy!

I really wanted to love the Maidstone. It has a great location in East Hampton and interesting array of rooms, with a restaurant on site, but for the rest it has a lot to be desired! When we arrived (after the indicated 3pm check-​in time), we were advised that our room wasn’t ready, so despite being tired and wanting to relax, we headed back to town to pass an hour. Unfortunately, that was the least of our issues! The room we were assigned was nice, albeit small — but as the place is pet friendly, we ended up across the hall from a dog that just never stopped barking. A call to the front desk and we were advised that the staff was trying to locate the owners, but have been unable to. As we were trying to relax, the non-​stop barking was everything but. This lasted till about 11pm when the owner finally returned. Found the staff lacking and not very helpful…

The Maidstone is amazing! I went there for a weekend with my partner and friends. From the time we checked in to the time we left, the staff was warm, friendly and accommodating. With an Swedish eco-​chic feel, the Maidstone is like no other place I have stayed. I could have spent my entire weekend on the porch having a wonderful time.

Cozy and unique! Very friendly and attentive staff. We were there during the off season (Feb) so very little traffic which was nice. Rooms have a contemporary flair (Swedish inspirations). A little on the smallish side but definitely had a homey feel to it. Very environmentally conscience hotel (no bottled waters, recycled paper etc). Hotel is opposite a cemetery so view is not one of the big reason to come here LOL. But still a great little hotel, full of color and warmth.