Bennigan’s

Food was great and our server (Julius) was AWESOME. Definitely recommend visiting this establishment.

My family loves this restaurant. We go to watch our favorite teams play on the big screens and enjoy the delicious food. The employees and management are wonderful, accommodating, and treat everyone like family. We’ve been going to this Bennigan’s location for a year now; almost every weekend.

Tried the fried broccoli and they were good.
The food is good without being extraordinary and maybe to «greasy» — Typical Bar food

Well I realized why all the other ones closed.. absolutely awful food. Prolly only stay in businness cuz It’s attached to H.I.
I ordered the irish dip to be safe. deli roast beef, a slice of processed American cheese, a hard bun. was terrible… cole slaw smelled musty. Usually I take 2 bites too make sure. but naw, I passed… ordered cheese sticks (which the server comped) that tasted like vinegar…
The service was fantastic… and deserves 3 stars… the food –2stars.

Monte Cristo Sandwich!
Does this review really need to be any longer than that?
Grabbed a Monte Cristo Sandwich and the drink special for the day (long island $ 4.50) and ended it with Bread Pudding with Praline Sauce. I hadn’t had the Monte Cristo in a LONG time… maybe 15 years. But somehow I remember that raspberry jam. (forgot to take photo of jam… was so hungry almost forgot to take the photo of the sandwich, hence the jam on the sandwich in the left corner of the sandwich lol)
Had gotten the sampler appetizer. The burgers was okay. the rolls were great. Nachos however after two bites left the rest untouched.
Ate all the ice cream and but only half the bread pudding.
Whenever the next time I come back I’ll probably try the Cajun Chicken & Shrimp Pasta with a Monte Cristo Sandwich of course.
Wish they had more Bennigan’s around if nothing else somehow connected the brand with more Holiday Inn’s

I’ve been to this location twice now, first time I don’t really remember and the second time this August past with my boyfriend’s family. We were a party of 7 I want to say, and Bennigan’s was BUUUSSSYYYY. Nevertheless, we were seated by a nice hostess pretty quickly and our waitress, Gabriella, soon came to greet us. I don’t know how she did it, because she clearly had a lot of tables, but she was AWESOME! She kept on top of all her tables so well and very personable and knew her menu. There seems to be a great staff working here that actually knows how to function as a team. They were all very good at helping one another out with keeping tables clean, getting food out to customers, and whatever they could possibly do. Well done all of you!
Food was great. We had no complaints at our table. Everything was hot or cold as it was supposed to be, portions were plentiful, presentation was good, prices reasonable, flavor tasty, and we even got to use the check-​in offer! They do have some specials on food and drinks, so check those out!
The restaurant is located at the base of the Holiday Inn (yes?) so understandably there is a lot of travelers dining here. The layout of the restaurant is spacious with LOTS of TVs. It is mostly dining space, though there is a bar in the center that isn’t at all intrusive. You can anticipate me saying that it is a clean restaurant, I’ve already addressed the quality of staff they have here so expect well of them.
I should hope our great experience isn’t unique to just us; of course, there can be bad days, but I believe this to be a worthy option.

And here I thought that all of the Bennigan’s had closed!
They were extremely busy, with a softball tournament team in the restaurant, so it took almost 10 minutes to get a waiter, but the front area hostess, who had seated us, tried to take our drink orders to help out. She wasn’t sure of what beers they had on draft, but said, «I know we have Corona…» Corona isn’t a draft beer, and I wanted something somewhat Irish.
Our waiter finally came by, took our order, and the food was delivered by another employee. Shortly thereafter, our waiter came by & told us the softball team was gone & he «had a lot more time for us», which he held true, checking on us several more times.
I had the fish & chips, which apparently was «all you can eat» here on Friday night, which I didn’t know until I decided I was done. They were served very hot (right out of the kitchen), had a thin breading and the fish was light & flaky. My son had the chicken tenders which were also very hot when they came out.
The fries on both of our plates looked like there was a mix of freshly-​fried and previously-​fried (i.e. some of them were left in the basket & re-​fried to be served). That made them very crispy, which wasn’t actually all that bad.
There were TVs everywhere, all showing various sports channels.
Overall a good experience.

This place us the only Benniganas I know of left. It brings back some good memories and the food is still very tasty!

Good food! Good service! Always relaxing! The fish fry is FABULOUS! Check Local Flavor for coupons and deals…

Good experience. Waitress was great. Had no issues. Highly recommend this location and hotel!

Great service and good food. I had the Fork and knife carnitas sandwich, it was very tasty and came out about 15 mins after ordering.

So pleasantly surprised to come here. The location is all upgraded and really nice setting. The outside seating was comfortable and had fun music going on the whole time felt almost private. The food was delicious the service was okay but I would still be coming back and letting people know to come check it out

I eat here every night when in town for business since I stay at the connected Holiday Inn. Had not been to a Bennigans in 20 years prior to finding this gem. Burgers, Monty Cristo a Fish and Chips, Ribs and Firecracker Shrimp are great. Have eaten in, take out and room service. They misplaced my order once on a take out order but the manager was personally all over it and deducted $ 25 off my $ 35 meal for me waiting 10 minutes. Food and service here convinced me to change my hotel of 10 years.

You come here when you stay at the Holiday Inn. Had dinner/​lunch with clients here a few times. Just so so. However, Friday all you can eat Fish&Fry is really good!

Very good ! Can be slow to serve at times, but the place has been remodeled and looks good

Clean, nice laid back atmosphere. Portion sizes were a nice surprise for the price. Won’t go back without plans of getting the broccoli bites! One of the best apps the wife and I have had anywhere.
I was expecting less as it is connected to a hotel, but very much enjoyed myself. Look forward to a date night re-​visit.

The only reason they get 2 stars is because my burger was cooked well, normally deserving of 4 stars by itself, but food quality isn’t the only thing that rates a restaurant. Our server was very nice, just inexperienced, like she wasn’t trained how to use her time properly, when to visit the table, or basic patron cues like setting the check holder up when it is ready to be paid.
You may be saying to yourself, «Hey, this isn’t enough to give 2 stars!» and you would be right. My main problem was these posters that they had plastered all over the restaurant for «Fat Fridays Fat Tire Experience» If you didn’t know fat tire is an exquisite beer that happens to be one of my personal favorites. How excited I was to walk in, on a Friday, and be a part of «Fat Fridays»!
I asked our waitress when she was taking our drink orders what «Fat Fridays» consisted of since the poster, which I have added to their pictures, was very vague. She told me she didn’t know and had to go ask a manager. O.K. I thought, let’s see what happens. She comes back and says that Bennigans was featured in some sort of magazine or some sort for having Fat Tire and that was why the posters were all over. I said «Great, can I get one?». She had to go ask again. She came back and said they don’t carry Fat Tire. What? These posters are all over and I want a Fat Tire! She went to talk to her manager 4, yes 4 separate times all to tell me they don’t have it. Yet the manager didn’t think it would be appropriate to come over and talk to me his/​herself at any point during the meal?
Very strange, very stupid. Once I left the restaurant I promptly went to buy Fat Tire at my local grocery store. I will have satisfaction!
Here is the link to the poster if you would like to see it:

I always get the same thing, Bennegins Club with sweet potato fries and it’s always good.
We come here so often the server recognizes us :)
Good lunch spot with huge portions!

The wife and I stopped in on a Sunday afternoon where the place was maybe ¹⁄₃ full. We were quickly seated and served, the staff was great although the background noise from the TVs was a little overwhelming at times.
The wife had the Irish dip and I had the cottage pie. Both were good but the cottage pie was «Great». The spices was fantastic when mixed with the meat.
We’ll be back again

Order the Monte Cristo — it’s seriously world famous. It’s a life charger and also a heart attack on a plate.
The Monte Cristo is a ham and turkey sandwich with American cheese deep fried in a beer batter. It’s dusted with powdered sugar and served with a raspberry jam — it’s the ultimate sweet and salty combination. A sandwich of this magnitude could only be enjoyed with a fork and knife as you would prime rib. The oil in the deep fryer must have been super hot because the fries were crispy and my Monte Cristo was beautifully golden. Warning: the Monte Cristo should only be eaten once per year to let your arteries clear up or order it as an appetizer and share it with a group.
For only $ 9, the Monte Cristo is a steal. I would have paid twice the amount easily for the pleasure that I received from it. It’s f@#ing amazing.