Which Wich

We stopped her for a quick sandwich. I really liked the process. It was nice marking the items you want to make up your sandwich without standing in a line feeling rushed. The portion size and good quality was good. The service was quick and the staff was friendly. If you want a good deli sandwich and don’t have a lot of time this is the spot.

So happy this place came into the area. Great change of pace from their competitors like Subway.
Ordering is easy inside the restaurant and even better during busy hours online via the app.
Many options to choose from sandwich wise and we love the shakes.
Our kids enjoy it here as well…

Came here for a chocolate and strawberry shake because this is one of the few places that use really ice cream. I am disgusted and disappointed at the wait time. The place was nearly empty and it was a 20 minute wait. The kid could only make one shake at a time and couldnt get it right. And the crazy thing is you have to fill out a card.
My husband said his shake wasn’t very strawberry. So I am very disappointed to have payed over $ 10 for the two large shakes.

I stopped in today for the first time. I read no reviews and had no idea what I was stepping into. The ordering process really threw me thru a loop for a second when I saw everybody standing at a counter filling out scan tron forms for some sort of test. Once I figured out the process I dove right in and went to it. I liked that everything was laid out in advance and simple. I think my kids would love this concept. I can see where it can get a bit cumbersome at the beginning with families having to corral kids and get the bags filled out in a timely manner without holding up the line. My lunch was great and I will be back. I got the wicked and it was delicious.

The wife and I both ordered the turkeywich. Very very good. Will definitely be back.

I just recently discovered this place and love it! The sandwiches are delicious and ordering is super easy– just mark all the toppings you want on a paper sandwich sleeve and then bring it to the cashier. Definitely recommend getting the fresh avocado!

Which Wich has been my favorite sandwich spot for years. The first time I got to indulge in a tasty wich was years ago in Murfressboro, TN.
The concept is so smart! You walk in and see a bunch of brown paper bags on the wall. They have the biggest variety of sandwiches I’ve seen at a sandwich shop. Each bag is labelled the protein source of that sandwich (Turkey, Veg, Chicken, etc.) On the bag you pick all your toppings. Every experience I’ve had with their toppings is that it is so freaking fresh! Even the avocado is fresh! Not the squeeze out of a tube stuff.
Once you hand your paper bag to the cashier, they throw it down an assembly line. It usually takes 10 – 15 minutes because they are using fresh ingredients and it takes time to cook the food. Especially if you’re getting a hotwich.
I’ve always had good customer service at Which Wich and this location didn’t disappoint. All locations have a loyalty card so if you frequent the place often, you get a free sandwich!

I like the premise of this place, and it helped to read the reviews before arriving so I knew what to expect. Filling out the bag for what you want is a cool concept. The 14-​inch sandwich is enough for 2 people. The sandwiches we got — pulled pork and crab and artichoke — were very tasty. It does take about 5 minutes longer than subway and Jimmy Johns, but it’s worth it for what you get. Our 14-​inch sandwiches were $ 11.50 each. I had a BOGO free coupon; otherwise, I probably wouldn’t have come. But after trying this place, I can see it being one of those once-​in-​awhile-​indulgent-​type places. Nice workers, and there’s a reward card also. The area is easy to get to and has ample parking. Jimmy John’s is still probably our No.1 choice (their bread is sooo yummy), but I definitely think Which Which is worth a try for anyone looking for something new out there.

Which Wich was like my jam back in St. Louis. To the point I would drive 45 minutes to go there if I canceled my dietitian appt that week (My dietitian’s office was within walking distance so I would buy a massive chicken salad from there and eat it in her office — further leaving her to wonder why I have issues keeping my weight up). Oh and yes the sandwiches are massive.
Somehow though Which Wich being within easily accessible distance has caused it to lose some of its charm here in Fishers
But for those who didn’t overdose on it, here’s some info:
First off: you grab a bag from the wall (divided by protein — i.e. Chicken) and take a sharpie and mark what you want. This becomes the bag they put your food into. You take your bag to the register. Make sure you mark all the extras you want (you can even specify hot or cold!).
You can also get chips, sodas, milk shakes, and fresh baked cookies too! Shakes and cookies are yummy!
They also have a charity thing involving lunches for school kids — I forget all the details about that though. So you should ask.
Then they send your bag down the line on a clothespin, assembly line style.
They’ll call your name at the end — you wrote it on your bag! And you grab your sandwich.
Eat in or carry out.
I have had SO many combinations. Only one I am meh about are the gyros. They’re not very good… In my opinion.
Chicken salad is fantastic (no nuts or grapes — as it should be). Not café patachou, but good
Other options taste better than subway. Comparable to jimmy johns. I like the which Wich experience better though. And they have a frequent buyer card. Which was great in St Louis

It has a unique ordering style. You pick up a bag and a marker. Then, check off the items you want on your sandwich.
I wanted something different to the sandwich world. I got something resembling a traditional turkey meal (with lots of toppings).

On the great sandwich continuum, Which Wich falls somewhere above Subway and Jimmy John’s. No need to stand behind glass with a horrified expression as the your sandwich artists puts banana peppers on your sandwich when you clearly asked for bell peppers. Verbal interference is minimized with a paper bag system outlining EXACTLY what you want on your sandwich in bold red X’s.
And the options are copious! Splurge on that bacon and avocado. Add every vegetable. HUMMUS! Then top it with that oil, vinegar, salt, and pepper. Who needs mayonnaise? (blasphemy?) Have everyone thinking, «What a fatty!» as they dunk their hot, chocolate chip cookies into their strawberry-​banana milkshakes.
Which Wich makes a fast, tasty sandwich without conversation or judgement. Orders can be completed with nary a word. Shut up, take my money, and make me a sandwich. This fatty’s hangry!

Fun, unique shop. Pick a bag, mark your toppings, turn in the bag and pay. Loads of options for even the pickiest of eaters. Since each sandwich is made to order, it did take a bit longer than I was anticipating, even with an empty shop. Would definitely go again.

The sandwiches here are pretty good, a bit pricey which is why it’s a treat to come here. I love all the options just with it was a bit more budget friendly or they had specials. Great staff and very helpful.

Meh, it’s a sandwich shop and an overpriced one at that.
I order lettuce wrap sandwiches, apparently the cut them in half and don’t wrap it in a way you can eat it like a sandwich/​wrap. The roast beef is a light tan color, not a good quality meat at all. I’ll be going to Jimmy Johns from now on.

I’ve eaten here about 5 times since they opened in Fishers and haven’t had a bad experience. I like the food selection and quality. It’s more expensive than subway, but tastes way better!

Met up here with my buddy for lunch last week. He’s been a few times, this was my first.
It seems like fast food is slowly becoming a thing of the past, and there’s a new form, with better quality ingredients moving in. There’s fast fired pizzas, fast mexican food, and fast sandwich shops. Which Wich definitely takes the cake in the sandwich department. It will be my go to from now on for a quick bite when I’m in a sandwich or sub mood.
As you walk in, you can observe their menu, then you grab a bag with a list of ingredients and combinations. You simply mark off everything that you want, write your name, and hand it over! This place has a much wider variety of choices than a subway or a typical sandwich place would.
I’ll definitely be back sometime this week to try something new!

I have been here twice. The sandwiches are really good but each time I’ve eaten here I have had to dig stuff out of my mouth. The first time it was an olive pit which I bit down on pretty hard. Today I had to pull several stems out from banana peppers.
Seriously people watch what you put on the sandwich… maybe the kitchen needs to focus on foreign objects a little better.
The other customer service failure was we placed our order online and they didn’t even start to make it until we got there.
I would like to give the food 4stars but they get three right now.

Delicious, fresh, customizable sandwiches made by a friendly and helpful staff. You write your order on a bag, hand it to the cashier, and they call your name when its done. Lots of possibilities and tasty sandwich fixings you won’t find at Subway or Jimmy Johns. I had a toasted turkey sandwich and it was delicious.

I mush have looked a bit lost upon reading the menu and one of the girls explained the process of picking a bag-​which determines what kind of meat and then you mark the rest of your selections on the bag as well. Simple enough! My husband and I really enjoyed our sandwiches. I liked that you can get them hot and with so many choices. It was about 15 dollars for a large and medium sandwich, no drinks or chips.

I was so happy they opened a store in Fishers! I’ve eaten at the Carmel location a lot and it’s always great.
This new location is just as good! And if you’ve never tired WhichWich it’s away stop!
They have a great selection of sandwiches you order by filling out a bag and checking what you want it’s great fun!
They come hot or cd your choice. A little pricier than other similar places but well worth it and the shakes are awesome!
If they offered catsup they would have all five stars!