I just had to do this… It’s now over 3 years since my initial review for Gabby’s. I still think they have the BEST pizza around.
Kelly M.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Foxboro, MA
I can’t say enough good things about this restaurant!!! Our baseball team was in town for a tournament and were looking for great authentic pizza in Flemington near Diamond Nation. We came across Gabby’s and I am so glad we did. We had about 25 people in our party so we called them ahead. They were very welcoming and told us to come right over and had pizza and salads waiting when we got there. Our team took up all the seats in the place but the staff was so accommodating and right on top of all of our requests. We had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza which was AMAZING not too hot but tons of flavor, cheese pizzas, chicken caesar salads and the Chicken pizza with Vodka sauce. Everything was delicious!!! If you are in Flemington, visit Gabby’s you will not be disappointed.
Alex M.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Flemington, NJ
Their deep-dish Buffalo Chicken Pizza is absolutely out of this world, but that’s all I can recommend. I don’t like their sandwiches or their plain pies.
Andrew G.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Farmingdale, NY
I tried Gabbys pizza yesterday for the first time. It was ok. It’s not to thick and not to thin with an ok sauce. A lot of people rave about Gabbys, I thought it was just ok.
Debbie K.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Flemington, NJ
This is my first time ordering from Gabby’s. I ordered delivery and my pizza arrived a bit messed up.(See picture). As for the food, I’ve had better pizza. The sauce was to the sour side, the crust was a bit chewy. The Caesar salad was descent. Overall I don’t think I will be ordering from this place again.
Melanie R.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Flemington, NJ
Place has really gone downhill in the past few years. Filthy inside, questionable food safety. If you are lucky enough to get your order right!!!
Christopher M.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Arlington, VA
Josh Harris is the man. So is Hector.
Mommabee T.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Ringoes, NJ
They are rude & have zero customer service sense. Pizza is Ok. nothing special. There are much better places in the area.
Victor C.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Flemington, NJ
Service is REALLYBAD! Employees are not the greatest cooks. Place is not the cleanest. Pizzas are not very good. Food is limited.
Mike A.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Newark, NJ
I love Gabby’s especially the deep dish. I also love the fact that they deliver and deliver quickly. Nice folks too!
Gary S.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Flemington, NJ
Better than average pizza for the area. My «go to» pizza place till I find something better. Though it’s not my thing, they get a few points for attempting be innovative with their special pizzas. Would be nice if they offered a really great, authentic pizza margherita. I’ve tried their«italian» food once or twice. It was OK for the price. Atmosphere isn’t much; a little worn and grimey.
Cayce K.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Princeton Township, NJ
Gabbys saved the day after we waited for an hour for to-go food from another restaurant, and left starving. Lots of variety. And they gave us extra slice! They are just a good pizza place.
Daniel P.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Flemington, NJ
EDIT: The last few times I’ve been there the service was slow and the employees were incredibly rude. I’m staying away from this joint for a while. : This is a pizza for fans of good dough. It’s a little thicker than others in the area and the sauce and cheese is not caked on to compensate, as one would expect. I myself am a big crust-lover, and it is currently the place I’ll go to for a pie. Great for a night of vegging-out and relaxing. I mean, come on… It’s pizza from New Jersey. Even New Jersey’s BEST pizza looks like the retarded cousin of New York’s worst pizza.
Tony G.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Louisburg, NC
Pizza and subs were outstanding and nice little eatery inside. Service was just above average.
Ted D.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Ringwood, NJ
I usually write long reviews but since i have only had one item here it will be sort. I have only ordered the deep fried calzone. If i never had one in Brooklyn i would have given them five stars. But since i have something to compare them to they only get four. If you have never had a deep fried calzone order one and give it a try. Try it plain, or with some ham. If you are feeling crazy fill it with your favorite topping and let the pocket of cheesy friend goodness take over!
Jeff W.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Flemington, NJ
We ordered on a Monday because Viramis was closed. Over priced and sub par for pizza in this area. Sauce was too sweet and the crust was doughie. I was shocked by their prices.