Lenny’s Pizza and Pasta

Lenny’s is the best in Flemington! Especially for catering now that Alfonso’s changed to Alfresca’s and their food quality and service went down. Lenny’s is also there to meet your needs for a big party or a Friday night pizza. Their special pizza is awesome and their owner is so very accommodating. Their pasta and platters are so good. They actually keep your info on file so a frequent host like me is not constantly spelling my street name over and over. Great quality, good price, and big portions.

Good Pizza and nice cheese stakes! A regular stop when in the area. Good staff plenty of parking.

Lenny’s is an ok option. Not the best in the area but definitely not the worst.

Absolutely love Lenny’s. I have been going to the Flemington location for years and have been going to the Clinton location since they opened. Both of the stores have fantastic staff there and Lenny is a great guy. The grilled montese panini is the best and their fries are to die for. I definitely suggest going here.

Paid $ 4.50 for two slices of pizza. A little pricy to me. I paid $ 2.50 for two slices of pizza at a pizzeria in Somerville that was thicker and tasted much better. Lenny’s, your pizza is oily and thin and not that good to be charging $ 2.25 per slice. Won’t be returning. The pizzeria was very clean though

Had dinner delivered. They were very nice on the phone, Julia delivered early love that. Pizza is really good a little greasy but really good. Honey mustard chicken wrap was good. Special cheese steak on garlic bread I had to beat my family off it was that good. Sausage calzone was really good. The sauce for the cheese steak needs work not very good. The overall experience was great, we will order here again.

Super great food will order again thanks so much keep up the good work. They deliver to my office and are really nice people.

Pizza is mediocre in a town with 14 choices for this type of food! The staff was fine, but the product was just OK and the pizza on the counter looked aged!

Pretty much done with this place. Pizza is good, but they can’t get the orders right. We have had so many problems with them from they thought it was pickup when we always do delivery, to just last week we ordered 2 pies and only one got delivered. we remained loyal despite all the many order problems. Last week was just the last straw. It’s not worth the aggravation. Moving on.

Not very good. Frozen pizza is better. My Family and I all got ill from the food there. My daughter on her way home from school eat there 2 more times and had an upset stomach.

Awesome pizza, salad, garlic knots, subs, sandwiches, fries. Lenny is a great owner and is very accommodating. Their catering menu is really good as well.

My husband and I moved here a few months ago and we love their White Margherita Vegetable pie. The prices for the pizza are a bit high though. Their specialty pies are good, expensive, but good. The buffalo chicken pie is also tasty here.

This is my favorite pizza place for a plain pizza. The crust is crisp and I have NEVER had a burned pizza– which I have found to be rare among pizza places.
The fried calamari is great. They also have an additional menu of «fat» sandwiches (like those from the Rutgers food trucks). They are decent but could probably use a little more filling. Overall, I have been pleased with everything I have ordered.

Great Food. Great Prices. We have only gotten delivery but we are always very happy!

Pizza by the slice reminds me of college pizza: sauce that maintains the taste of tomato paste and lots of cheese. My slice was slightly under cooked.

Best Pizza in Flemington! Its not even close! Lenny is a great guy that ALWAYS helps out the community — can’t say enough good things about him. Pizza is the best, if you are looking for a healthy option but want pizza try their whole wheat ultra thin personal pizza! Pasta dinners and cheesesteak wraps are great as well, really can’t go wrong with anything at Lennys! Also, delivery service is the best I’ve ever seen in a restaurant anywhere, very quick and always correct.

Forgetable. We order from them becuase they deliver, but it isn’t anything special. The pizza is ok, sauce could use flavor and pizza is occasionally over cooked. Sandwiches are ok, nothing special. I have also tried a couple pasta dishes and again the sauce could use more flavor.

This is our favorite in Flemington. We make a point of crossing town to get Lenny’s. My family comes from out of state and they want a trip to Lenny’s to get Jersey pizza (next best to NYC!!).
The staff here are pleasant.
We suggest the buffalo chicken pizza (totally YUMMY), plain, pepperoni, ziti, hawaiian — ham and pineapple, sicilian… okay, any of the pizza here is GREAT.

We ordered pizza from here last night to fulfill a craving. Usually we go for Virami’s, but we wanted to try something different since we have only lived here for a few months.
We ordered a large plain pie with mushrooms. It was alright. I thought the crust was a little bit too thick and chewy. The ends were fantastic though. Also, I think that the mushrooms were a bit scarce, although they weren’t overwhelming, I was shocked to see only a few sprinkles of them, especially for paying almost 2 dollars a topping.
We’d probably go again, but it wouldn’t be our first choice.

This is my favorite pizza place in Flemington, and whenever I’m home I make a point of coming here at least once. My family moved to Flemington almost 12 years ago, and I think this location had about 3 different pizza places in it for the first 6 of the years we lived here. Then Lenny’s came, and as far as I can tell they’re not even thinking about closing their doors. These guys get pizza right.
The bread is perfect, first of all. Just the right thinness and crispiness, with enough flavor to stand on its own but not so much that it overshadows the toppings. Now, I’m not a crust-​eater. Yeah, it’s weird, but usually I give away my crusts. At Lenny’s, though, I eat the crust.
My personal favorite at Lenny’s is the broccoli and tomato white pizza. It’s totally bougie, but, my friends, it is DELICIOUS. I’m getting hungry just thinking about it. It’s got lots of ricotta and lots of veggies in all the right proportions. Their plain, of course, is good too. The sauce is nice and somehow they make it so that when you take a bite you can actually break the cheese. It won’t all slide off your pizza and onto your shirt, and I appreciate that.
Lenny’s has at times been inconsistent. The pizza used to be better, though it’s still really good. And they don’t always have my beloved broccoli tomato. Sometimes you will walk in there and it will be clear that you’re getting the last slice of a particular pie that has been sitting out for hours. It’s always good, though, and I can’t say I’ve ever been disappointed.
Lenny’s does have non-​pizza food, but I’ve never tried it. I’ve also never had anything delivered from there, so I can’t speak to the quality of their delivery. Sorry, kids.