Baggios Pizzeria and Restaurant

I really love this place! Staff is so nice, prices are good, there’s an outdoor seating area & its BYOB! My friends and I came here to get some good inexpensive food and we left very satisfied ! This is a cute date spot I would deff come back!

first time here and got the margharita pizza with mushrooms! the pizza was very thin but it was good. however, i didnt really see anything too special about this place like how others said. the owner was very sweet and welcoming though. maybe i’ll try something else next time

I had dined here with my mom on a tues night. Pleasant, simple place. Nicer than a local pizzeria but not a full resto-​type place either but they do have a separate dining area. We ordered buffalo wings and a large pie-​half plain cheese and half spinach/​mushroom. The wings weren’t the typical buffalo chicken wings you’d expect. These were crispy and dry seasoned (with no liquid buffalo sauce) and came with blue cheese dip on the side. They were ok and I may or may not order them again; will depend on my mood.
We are originally from queens so we know our pizza. There are the «meh it’ll do» kinds and there are the ones you’d go out of your way for. This place is the latter. Honestly this is not THE best pizza I’ve had but it was delicious and different from the ones I’ve had before. The crust was thin without being too thin like a cracker where you can share a whole pie and still have room in your tummy. Words from my finicky mom: «the sauce is from fresh tomatoes» (translated into English) and she thoroughly enjoyed it! I took some leftovers home and when I ate them the next day it was really hard sharing with my dog lol I will definitely be back with my mom again.
[This review was based on dining in. Your experience may be different for pickup or delivery.]

Real Italian pizza. Get a couple slices and feel the real deal like back in Italy. Good prices, too.

I always order from this place but after Saturday’s service, I don’t think I’ll be coming back. My boyfriend and I decided to dine in and when we entered, nobody greeted us. The waiter looked at us and continued chatting away with other customers… so we just picked a random seat and waited for the hostess or another server to bring us the menu. It took about 20minutes for someone to bring us the menu and I was getting pissed off because the place wasn’t understaffed or super busy… just the workers don’t seem to care about patrons that are not regulars… even when my boyfriend went up to the counter to ask for a waiter, it took an additional 10minutes for them to send someone over. And it was another additional 40minutes for the food. We had the deep pan grandma pizza and it was great. the food is never a problem but the service is horrible and unprofessional.
A note to management:
Baggios isn’t the only good pizza place in the area.

Their heart shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day was amazing! Me and my fiancé devoured it. Their pizza is really to die for! Not only was it delicious, but the delivery took 20 minutes as expected. George, the delivery guy, is hilarious and is one speedy guy! Best pizza in Bergen county by far.

Always fast delivery and hot, delicious pizza. I couldn’t be happier with this place. The vodka pizza is the bomb!

Its very rare to find a pizza place thats good around here. It was delish! the shrimp scampi was good as was the pear salad. At first i questioned the honey mustard dressing but it was so good once mixed w dash of balsamic vinegar. The server was so great… which is sooo hard to find these days. I’m usually very hard to please. I dine out almost every night and mostly in nyc but this place is a great local place. Hopefully it will be the same upon my return.

We ordered a large plain pie, which is $ 13 on the menu. What came was a white pie with mushrooms and onions, which cost $ 23. We paid with a credit card over the phone and tipped the delivery guy $ 6 before we got our food.
I called to get the pie I asked for but the owner decided to be rude on the phone saying that there’s 10 of them there and they can’t be wrong. Basically telling me I ordered the wrong thing. I didn’t
I asked him plainly to refund the amount he charged and send out what I originally asked for, and he refused. So we’re calling the credit card company and writing this review.
Congratulations Baggio’s, between me and my coworkers, we order from you guys at least once a week and I’m making sure that none of us will order from you guys.
And btw, we work in a residential building and we’ll make sure to give our honest opinion if anyone asks about your business.
PS: The thin crust pie you mistakenly sent was extremely greasy.

Ordered delivery for the super bowl. The crust on their grandma pizza was super tough to eat; I can’t even say chew because it was so hard that there was nothing to chew.
We also got chicken parm with angel hair pasta, except they gave us spaghetti.
The wings came with 6 pieces. They were buffalo wings that were fried… so essentially they were fried wings, which were small.

Over a week ago, we had a very disappointing experience with our party of 3. The service started out well, but quickly deteriorated. Not once did the server ask how our food was which was lukewarm at best. Furthermore, we didn’t have any followup throughout the meal asking how everything was. This is all despite the place being relatively empty. On top of this, the entrees are on the expensive side. The only positive thing that occurred is that we will never ever spend another $ here again.

Fantastic pizza. My second time ordering delivery and it’s finger licking good. Ordered Milanese pizza (veggies, salad and chicken). Perfect thin crust, healthy and delicious. Placed my order in line and delivery came within 20 minutes. Very happy.

I came here with two other people for dinner and we got full off of one large pizza and an order of pappardelle pasta. Great portion sizes!
Pizza here is definitely the standout item on the menu. Thin-​crust pizza with just the right amounts of cheese and tomato sauce made for a delicious meal.
The pasta was not as exciting; it was good, but it wasn’t amazing.
We also ordered the calamari appetizer, and I’d have to give it a pass next time. It took quite a bit of chewing to get through.
The place itself is pretty small, it seats maybe 30 or so, and you get a view of the kitchen where the guys are throwing pizzas around. One thing I really had a hard time with was the smoke from the cooking pizza. While there’s no visible smoke, I had a hard time breathing because of how heavy the smells got. Walking outside after the meal was a breath of relief (literally). I would order pizza from Baggios again, but maybe as takeout.

This place has some of the best pizza in town. Thin, crispy yet moist pizza. The guys look pretty tough and mean but they’re actually very nice and full of humor. You can dine in, take out or have it deliver right to your door.
Their mushroom pizza is strangely addicting. I’ve never had canned (almost pickled-​like) mushrooms served on my pizza like this place but boy is it yummy.
I hear their espresso is pretty solid too!

Their pizza is really yummy. I think we have so many good pizza place around this restaurant area but Baggio is one of the best in town. Not only pizza but also pasta is good too.

Decent pizza place in the area– love their bruschetta pizza– their crust is crispy and bruschetta has a good amount of garlic which I love! :)

I have actually never set foot inside the restaurant itself but I have ordered delivery about 10 times in the past year. It’s become my go-​to pizza spot for delivery. I almost always get the pizza ala vodka with an extra topping of chicken. I have never been disappointed with this order. I have also ordered the Italian hero and chicken parm hero. Both were nothing special compared to the pizza. Speed of delivery has also always been very fast. I will continue to order from them whenever I am craving pizza.

Always a good place to go. Food is good, reasonably priced and the pizza is a mainstay here.

For whatever reason, it’s hard to find a pizza joint that serves Pizza alla Vodka.
Fortunately for Baggios, it is one of the rare places that does serve the Pizza alla Vodka. I say fortunately because I would never come here if not for the Pizza alla Vodka.
There’s nothing wrong with this place but I don’t think there’s anything special about this place either. What makes it more difficult to come to this place is that the prices are higher than other local joints.
But the Pizza alla Vodka is solid. It’s a nice thin pie of pizza and the Vodka sauce tastes great. I’m pretty sure a normal human being could finish an entire pie in one sitting because the pie is pretty thin and it doesn’t come with any toppings (although I’m sure you can add toppings to it).
So if you’re into Pizza alla Vodka, I definitely recommend that you try it here.

I’m from SI so I like to think (and obviously purely my own opinion haha) that I know pizza!
When my parents moved to Jersey, I needed to find a new pizza place! And this comes the closest to what I’m used to. Thin crust pizza with tangy sauce and melted cubes of fresh mozzarella (cheese is in patches, not across the whole pie).
I’ve been coming pretty consistently over the years and I haven’t noticed much variance in food or service. I will admit, it’s a bit pricier than you can get elsewhere for pizza/​pasta but I’m ok with that.
Pasta portions are on the larger size — can definitely share between 2 ppl with an app or salad. Most times I got with my parents or 2 gfs (so in 3’s) and we get 2 pastas + app or 1 pizza/​1pasta/​1 salad and maybe some wings (crispy not saucy) and its plenty. Generally ~$ 20pp incl tip.
I recommend the vodka pizza or plain pizza.
The standout pasta for me is the Black Linguine with shrimp, garlic, tomatoes and broccoli rabe (no sauce, its tossed in olive oil).
Always end with a tartufo — ice cream scoop dipped in chocolate.
It’s nice to sit outside in the summer. There’s a muni lot behind the restaurant if you can’t find street parking.
Also, no longer on the menu, but the chopped cucumber, tomatoes and onion salad (Sorrentina Salad) can still be ordered if you ask. :)
BYOB!