Sal’s and Mal’s Pizzeria

Tried this place for the first time last night after a recommendation from a family friend in Foxboro. Fantastic New York style pizza. The sauce, cheese, and crust were just right. And just like I had read in another review, the pizza was too big for the box and folded over in the back– definitely got our money’s worth!
They were very friendly taking my order over the phone, verified they would come as far into Sharon as I was for delivery, and then were just as pleasant when they showed up a few minutes even BEFORE the promised time at my door.
The menu could use some more detail as to what the specialty pizzas have on them, but the answer is still just a phone call away.
We’re going to make this our go-​to place from now on.

Mediocre pizza. Got a plain cheese. Poor tasting cheese and too much soupy sauce. The place is absolutely filthy. Filthy place means dirty food handling practices.

This is one the best pizza I’ve ever had. I had a buffalo chicken half and barbecue chicken on the other half. I over Gorge myself with it I couldn’t stop eating it was just that good wish this place was by my house.

Decided to try this place based on other reviews & so freakin glad we did! Got a large cheese pizza which is HUGE & delicious. The dough is great, the sauce tastes kinda sweet & it had lots of cheese on it. Also ordered a Greek salad (YUM), garlic knots & fried dough with cinnamon. Everything was AMAZEBALLS! My only regret is not discovering this gem years ago.

Wow. What a great surprise.
Looks like a hole in the wall… But the pizza was fantastic… Perfect crust… Great sauce. Just the right amount of cheese

I love this place! Best quality for money. I’ve tried pizza from many restaurants and this is by far one of my favs

Stopped in on a Monday evening and ordered the special, buy one large sub with a 16 ounce bottle soda get a free sub. The person taking the order seemed to be unfamiliar with the special, but the owner was nearby and he confirmed the special, so no biggie. I ordered a large meatball parmesan sub a small tuna and two slices of pizza. The meatball sub was excellent, or at least SHOULD have been excellent (more on that later), the tuna sub was fine and two slices of pizza were «meh». I was curious about the pizza because of the positive reviews that stated it was «New York» style pizza, however, it was impossible to gauge the goodness of the slices there, because they were rather «old» looking. I really shouldn’t have ordered them as it’s not even close to pizza fresh out of the oven. I just felt that the slices were so old that they either should have been tossed or the place should have acknowledged this and discounted the price by at least half. Oh well, anywho, the place was definitely in need of a good cleaning, but my visit would have been primarily positive until the submaker asked if I would like the food in a plastic bag. I said yes and they then proceeded to LICK their finger in order to get the top end of the plastic bag to separate. They then proceeded to take the meatball sub out of the oven and use the very same finger to hold down the sub as they cut it. Being the non confrontational type, I chose NOT to complain about what I just witnessed and proceeded to go home, unwrap the sandwich and slice off a ¼ inch layer of bread across the top of the entire sub. Really, someone who is handling food should no better than this, it was disturbing. And although they made the tuna sub BEFORE I witnessed the finger lickin’ submaker in action, it dawned on me that the correct presumption is that this individual licked their finger every time they retrieved a plastic bag. GROSS GROSS GROSS. Oh well, so much for trying not to be overly critical. Food is good but management needs to get a grip on their staff’s finger licking.

Solid 4* Delivered once and just stopped in for takeout. Pizzas are ample and thing that makes these pies unique is the crust. Thin, and cooked to perfection.
White pizza with tomato and basil is huge, pepperoni and another with eggplant, spinach and mushroom. Something special about these pizzas. Will be back

This little hole in the wall on a side street in Foxboro is probably one of the best thin crust pizzas on the east coast, period! The owner who is from Greece but grew up making and learning to make pizza in Brooklyn for most of his life has it nailed down and makes it better than you can get it in Brooklyn! I know this is a bold statement but I swear it is true, it is as good as it gets! It is not a place to go for ambiance, it is a take out kinda place but they do have some tables and the owner and his wife are super nice and grateful people and appreciate their customers. They have a huge menu but I almost always just get the pizza (pepperoni extra sauce extra well done) but I recently had the sausage parm spaghetti with the homemade garlic knots which blew my fricken mind! Today I tried the «small» Italian sub which weighed in at about a pound which was fantastic. These are the types of restaurants that appreciate our business and deserve our hard earned dollars! They put out a amazing product for very very reasonable prices! Do your self a favor and make a effort to have this pizza!!! You will thank me later!

The meat lover’s pizza sucked! For the price of $ 22 I should have gotten ALL the meat. The quality of the meat on the pizza also left something to be desired.
The saving grace was the fact we were tailgating at Gillette and had some beers. Kid.
The pepperoni was decent. I wouldn’t eat here again given the choice.

Hole in the wall, best pizza and subs around, literally the definition on greasy pizza

Absolutely the best pizza in Foxboro! It’s not the Greek style everyone else seems to have its authentic NY style and huge! Love the garlic knots!

Come for the pizza, but dont expect any sort of décor. Best pizza I’ve had in years. Huge portions, fair price. The place is the pizza version of a dive bar, but who cares when you get a slice bigger than your head.

Great little place, we ordered a Italian calzone and a Greek salad. So good we will be back! Thank you

I really like their food. My only complaint is it’s a little overpriced. Seems like every time I come here I’m dropping $ 35 – 50. $ 38 for a large pizza, mozzarella sticks, and small sub? Maybe it’s just me.

Delivery order that took over an hour to arrive. The driver had to call for directions which surprised us as we live 2 turns away from the place. Pizza was ok but was cold when it finally arrived. The kids liked it so maybe we will try again some day.

Great pizza. The gentleman on the phone was great and promptly delivered my pizza with a smile and a thank you. I ordered the Large pepperoni extra cheese. Seriously speaking, the large is way to big for one person. It’s more like a extra large. I will order it again tonight. Look no further folks. It’s the real deal.

We went in there today because we saw this place on Unilocal.I was so excited to find a NY style pizza place…
We walked in, told them that we’ve never been there before and they were so welcoming. Two of the nicest people working there. We discussed the different options and decided to do a half and half… because you still have to judge a place by their Cheese pizza.
While we were waiting, we had a nice conversation with the gentleman working… and the lady that was making the pizza came out with a surprise for us… the most incredible twists of dough, garlic, parm and oil… OH MY GOODNESS! So Heavenly. I just wanted to eat 20 more and tell them to cancel the pizza.
We got home with our pizza and I’m glad that we didn’t…because the sauce is perfect, the crust was thin and crunchy… it was cooked perfectly. You could tell that the Onions and Pepperoni was fresh and the cheese was so gooey and tasty.
I can’t wait to order here again… and I will… oh yea… I will.

I had to try this place a few times before I got a real feel for it.
The first two times I tried some specialty sub and was not impressed. Then I tried thr garlic knots, which I was not sure why everyone goes crazy over.
Finally went with just a plain pepperoni pizza and was finally really happy. You get a lot of pizza for the price. You need to be hungry or have company when ordering one of these. They have a lot of pepperoni and the crust is great. Not too thin and has some crispness to it. The sauce is not bland but not overpowering to where you cannot taste the toppings.
All in All, impressee with the pizza more than I orginally thought I would be.

Fantastic food, fantastic people. This has to be the best pizza in Foxboro. They could easily compete with some of the North End italian restaurants in Boston. The crust is that perfect authentic thin and the meatballs are like heaven.
The owners are wicked awesome too. Stop in and grab a slice, you won’t be dis-​appointed.