Buttermilk

I wish I could give this company more stars because their pies are good. The problem is their pricing seems to be all over the map and you feel violated as a consumer. Whether you buy at a craft show or their store… pricing varies. A basic buttermilk pie is $ 30.00. Really??? Even for a mini pie that does not have much middle (no more than a good slice of pie) its nearly $ 9.00. The pricing ruins the experience of enjoying the pie when you feel taken advantage of.

I was visiting my sister in Gainesville for the weekend, and decided I would drop in and pick up her favorite — chess pie — as a surprise. Seduced by a fresh strawberry pie, I walked out of the store with two, 60 bucks lighter and on Cloud 9. The chocolate chess pie was AMAZING and worth every single calorie. In fact, we finished it in two days… hot, cold, with and without ice cream. The strawberry pie was also very good, I grabbed a small slice before my niece insisted that I leave it with her.
Thank goodness I don’t live in Gainesville, or I’d have to return for the savory tomato pie, which promises to be Cloud 10-​worthy!

Stopped in on a whim. So glad I did. Absolutely amazing! I bought strawberry pie and coconut pie. Crust was incredible. Filling delicious. Happy to know its all natural and homemade. Nothing creepy in here! Thrilled!

I was surprised at all the great reviews. I make pies myself and use quality ingedients, so I know how very cost-​effective they are to make, so I wasn’t happy that they charge up to 39.95 for one average size pie. Folks, that mark-​up is serious price gouging.
Other than that, the slice of pie I got was not that great. It was good, but if you’re going to have a select specialty shop, you have to knock it out of the park.
The girl waiting on me was nice enough but wasn’t into answering questions.
I gave them 3 stars based on the cleanliness of the shop and for the pie being «good».

The first time I put a bite of the chocolate chess pie into my mouth, I thought I’d died and gone to heaven. Every bite after that invoked the same feeling, perfection. I highly recommend Buttermilk. Each pie is pure bliss. Just ordered two for Thanksgiving!

Great pie slice. Ordered two for thanksgiving. Way better than the big box pies. Looking forward to Thanksgiving.

If you are going to open a pie kitchen you should be able to make a pie like they do! The crust is beyond anything I have ever had. I pick them up for special occasions as they are pricey but they deliver on taste when you want to splurge. Their signature Buttermilk pie is rightfully that. Not to heavy handed on sweetness but just right. For fall they rolled out the Carmel Apple pecan and it was well worth the decadence. I don’t know how they do it and I’m glad I don’t. My waistline couldn’t stand it.

These pies are AWESOME! Sweet but not too sweet. Premium fresh ingredients and perfect crust. Buy one and you will find it hard to save some for anyone else.

I recently picked up a pie after hearing rave reviews from the locals in Gainesville about the Buttermilk Pie Shop. I was told I must get the Pecan Pie — I’m glad I did. It is the best Pecan Pie I have ever eaten. At a little over $ 30 per pie, they are pricey but well worth it, would make a great gift.

Excellent buttermilk pies! Although I have no idea how anything else tastes … I always intend to ask for one of their other tempting delicacies … but when they say, «What can I get you?» … «Buttermilk pie» are the only words my mouth can seem to form … I’d check with the doctor, but if discussing this strange malady involved disclosing the location of Buttermilk … I’d have to stay away and keep silent … after all … more pie for me!

Satan bakes pies here. This place is nothing but the devil and a diet destroyer. I hate that I’ve discovered it. I hate that it’s right around the corner from work and I hate that I’m absolutely helpless to resist.
Omg. These pies are simply to die for. I’m not kidding. I love sweets, I love pie and the little gems that come out of this adorable place full of friendly workers are some of the best things I’ve eaten. Like ever.
Crust…pure flaky buttery goodness. I routinely eat all of the crumbs out of the box. It would be a crime to let any morsel escape.
My current favorite is the signature buttermilk. I’d actually not had this type of pie before, but after one bite we were getting along like life long friends. I don’t know how the sour tartness of the buttermilk is preserved in the creamy sweetness of the filling, but it is… and the texture and taste are perfect. Second fav is the lemon chess… another amazing combo of tart and sweet… this pie reminds me of springtime and Easter, but this greedy pig is happy to eat it anytime.
I also love the chocolate chess… and I’m not usually a chocolate fanatic but this filling manages to be decadent and rich tasting, but it feels amazingly light. It’s perfection… all in a little pie pan.
I’ve taken the coconut custard and pecan to friends and they were beloved by all. My mom has basically instructed me to bring her a pie home every time I make a Gainesville-​Atlanta run. And that’s from a lady who is very particular about her sweets y’all.
Basically, I’m in love. This place is paradise. I think it’s a little pricey… but it doesn’t stop me. These pies are amazing.