In Cahoots Co

We went to In Cahoots for a wings on Thursday night. The special is $.40 wings and are pretty good size better the Buffalo Wild Wings. There are about 6 different sauces. I ordered the spicy bbq and the teriyaki. The teriyaki was not salty as some sauces usually are. I would also order the onion rings. Good onion rings are the basis for any successful establishment and they have them.

Wings are great! One of the bartenders (a bigger lady) gets kind of nasty and very rude. She seemed to be drinking behind the bar. Drinks aren’t priced too great either. Needless to say I only come for the wings. They keep upping the wing prices so I’m going less frequently. You need better service to increase the prices!

When we walked in it felt like we were in the twilight zone. People all turned and stared! No one said hello, or how are ya! We sat down in a booth and waited ½ hour to find out that they started serving at 5:00. We’re here earlier because we have a football game to get to.
Had to go up to the bar to get a drink! Was scolded when asked about ordering food!
As far as the fish fry goes, it’s just ok. Don’t waste your gas to come from anywhere other than Genesee Depot!
Waitress dropped off the fish and took off! There aren’t others waiting, which is no surprise!

Monday taco night, 1 chicken and 1 beef taco… they they were both pretty good. Nothing too special but reasonably priced food, some decent tap beers and a divey type atmosphere. Waitress assisted me from my booth but mentioned that ‘usually people order at the bar and then sit down’. Located in Genesee Depot which is a cute tiny little town. I would definitely come back again!

Passed by on the way to lacrosse game and decided to stop in for lunch. Good bar atmosphere. The group had a few burgers which were very good. Beer was cold. What else can you ask for. Special thanks to the chef for making «Troy Tots». Basically nachos made over tater tots. Not on the menu, but ask for them.

Very good wings and chive fires… they run about 30 cents per wing. This place has improved from years past. Supply deliveries seem to happen around lunch (really?), so be careful where you park… you could get blocked in.

Pokey, the owner, has assembled the Best Wings in the area. Along with Club 400 in Waukesha he’s hit the jackpot!

I see a lot of older reviews, so I am hoping this one will help tip the scales toward the positive (4-​star average). My husband and I made In Cahoots our first stop on our Memorial Day motorcycle ride. I am really glad we stopped, because it was a gem. The bartender was soft spoken, but polite. She was quick to get our drink orders of one mild and one spicy Bloody Mary. Mine was perfectly spiced as I like it. I like the kick after the sip. She obliged. Then, we saw that Monday is their Mexican day. We just ordered the homemade chips and salsa, and I was pleasantly surprised by what was brought out. Hot from the fryer were tortilla triangles that had been deep fried and salted. They were awesome! I seriously only docked them for the Pace salsa they served with them, because I thought it did a serious disservice. Imagine if In Cahoots made their own salsa each morning or even just on Mondays for the Mexican specials. Take note: you could become the go-​to spot for both homemade chips AND salsa, and you would certainly have a faithful regular in a girl from Wauwatosa. I would travel a good distance for other-​worldly chips and salsa.

Stumbled on this place while out getting lost on the motorcycle. Friendly staff, good food. It’s a regular stop now.

Tuesdays and Thursdays are their «wing» days. At $ 0.30/each it’s a pretty sweet deal. Last time I was there they were a little on the dry side (probably an older batch just refried), but it was for lunch. They have about 6 – 8 flavors which cover your typical bases. I don’t do the firery kind, but my friend did say they had some bite. Not the melt your face kind, but edible. In addition to the wings, I would highly recommend the chive fries. They come with a dipping sauce that compliments them well. The staff is friendly and very down to earth. You kind of have to when you work in a town that you can drive through on one breath of air. Enjoy

My wife and I stopped here during a motorcycle ride through the area yesterday. There were a few other couples there at the bar too. It was definitely NOT crowded though. We sat down at the bar. Several minutes later the bartender walked right past us to chum it up with the couples next to us. He never even acknowledged us and didn’t pursue the conversation with our neighbors to serve them anything – just socializing. We sat there several minutes before I finally got frustrated to the point where I had to interrupt his conversation with the others and request a beer.
Then he asked us what we wanted but never apologized or acknowledged that he had skipped right past us. What a jerk.
We drank one beer and left – went to the café next door instead and spent our money.
I like riding through this area but will never again stop here.

In Cahoots is a good biker bar stop if you’re out in the Genesee Depot area. Drinks are standard, food is ok, though I heard they have really good wings, and the atmosphere is rugged. The BLT had crisp thin bacon which was just enough for a traditional sandwich. The bar does have history, as one of the frequented places by the famous passed resident Alfred Lunt, whom you can learn about at Ten Chimneys. The town is very quaint and worth a tour of In Cahoots and the surrounding restaurants, bakery, and shopping.