Sally’s Sweet Shoppe

I ordered a cake and cookies for my sons birthday… Wow is all I can say! Cake was The BEST tasting cake I’ve ever had! The cookies were delicious as well! Hands down the place to get your favorite sweet treat! My advice is to not walk but RUN to try this amazing bakery!

Cute little place in Genesee Depot Wisconsin. Easy to find, couple of retro tables inside and a little table outside. Not a huge selection of baked goods but what we had was very good. We had warm chocolate chip cookies and a Ho-​Ho cupcake.

Very cute place!!! And very yummy treats!!! Will go go back for sure!!! Sally is super nice. Kid friendly. Wish it was closer to Oconomowoc.

Fantastic bakery!!! Everything we’ve had has been exceptional! What a treat in the great little town of Genesee Depot– way to go Sally!

The rumchata crème pie is heavenily along with the various breads they offer. I recomend the monkey bread with Italian food. Excited to hear about a second location opening soon in delafield.

Conveniently I drive past this darling little sweet shoppe everyday; makes it really easy to get addicted! Not to mention its nestled in a cute little town. Their fruity scones are my favorite, especially when they’re still warm from the oven! They have a great variety of goodies and the girls there are helpful, friendly and they love to laugh! Always worth the stop!

Hands down, the BEST cupcakes I’ve ever had. And I’ve had a lot of cupcakes. Was drawn in by the fluorescent pink, hand written «BAKERY OPEN» sign on the street. Bought two treats: a Pumpkin cupcake with Dark Chocolate truffle filling and a Dark Chocolate cupcake with a Dark Chocolate Truffle filling. O. M. G. The cake was moist and fell apart in my hands, in a lovely and delicate way. The frostings were distinct and totally mouth-​watering. And the best part… are you ready for this… The sugar content was more than enough to satisfy without laminating the tongue and putting me into a diabetic coma. Cost per cupcake was about $ 3.50 and TOTALLY WORTH EVERY PENNY. Honestly, I’m going to dream about these little devils for the rest of my life.
If you’re in the area, you MUST stop by (be sure it’s before 2pm when Sally closes her doors). If you’re not in the area, «getcher butt in here»!!
Remember that this is a totally local business, so if you’re gonna use your credit card, make your purchase at least $ 10 (not hard to do) to make her fees worth while.