Rocky’s Island Pizza

Average. Nothing to complain about, but nothing special.

We ate here for lunch and then ordered pizza for dinner on the same day while staying at the neighboring KOA.
For lunch we each had a steak and cheese, one with the Italian sausage, and the other was the Rocky which had the chicken fingers on it. Both were pretty good/​tasting, beyond mine being served cold. It took almost 50 minutes for us to get our two sandwiches and an order of the loaded fries for lunch. The eat in area was surprisingly small for what the outward appearance of the building gives you. None of the tables were clean, it was obvious they may have been shorthanded.
For dinner we expected a possible long wait, so we called in and ordered for pickup, which was timely as quoted at 30 minutes. We got a large pizza with pepperoni, traditional sauce, and the garlic crust option. We also ordered the garlic bread with cheese. All was decent with regards to quality, but we were a bit disappointed with the lack of pepperoni on the pizza which averaged about 2 pieces per slice. On a large that’s pretty deficient. On the flip side, the cheese was copious and really good tasting for whatever they use, as was the traditional sauce and garlic crust.
In summary, its a good place to get your general pizza and sub fix on. Minus a star for the excessive wait at lunch, dirty tables, cold sandwich and lack of pizza topping.

This pizza was seriously great! We we’re visiting Niagra Falls from Ohio and camping at the KOA behind this place. After a day of exploring, pizza sounded good, so we decided to check it out.
The place was very clean and spacious. The menu had more than enough options and actually surprised us with how much they offer. We ordered 2 large pizzas for 2 adults and 4 kids (ages 6 to 11) and we all left FULL. The taste of the sauce was super, lots of toppings, the crust was crispy and it had a delicious garlicky butter flavor but not overpowering, and the pizzas came out to the table pretty fast with 3 full booths ahead of us. Service was very friendly! Excellent atmosphere and food. Totally was a memorable part of our trip and will definitely go back to the Grand Island even if it is just to get some great pizzas!

There’s a lot to like about Brick Oven. The service was prompt and friendly, and they have an amazing draft beer selection. Our salads were good and sizable if ordinary. I just wish the pizza were better! Very plain crust, sauce, and cheese. Still, a good value in terms of portion.

Had the steak sandwich was amazing! Prices are great and sides and dips are free!
Overall a good experience, kitchen was incredibly clean and people were so nice!
New spot that deserves your business!

Best steak and cheese sub! The service was quick and helpful. They have a good drunk selection and a very clean dining area. I want to come back for pizza. This would be great to take the kids, and then off to mini golf and go karts next door.

The service was very poor. It took 45 minutes to get 1 sub and 1 taco. When we told them that was too long they just walked away. Food was only ok. Not worth going back.

Went home to hang out with the family and we decided to order pizza from Rocky’s. Generally, we order from Just Pizza but decided to try Rocky’s for the first time. We ordered a half tray (12 slices) — half buffalo chicken finger and half Crestwood, which is an old fashioned style pizza with cheese, some olive oil, sauce, and spices. The pizzas with tomato sauce give you the option of traditional sauce or sweet sauce. Sometimes sweet sauces at other pizza places can be too sweet for me, so I went for the traditional.
The pizza itself was pretty good. It was typical «Buffalo-​style» pizza. The dough in the center was extremely thin, so the weight of the sauce from the Crestwood half was almost too much, causing some of the topping to slide off. It had very little cheese which was fine with me. It was not super greasy either. The crust was outstanding though. It was perfectly crunchy and flavorful!
I wouldn’t say that it’s amazing pizza, but it was tasty. Not a bad option, honestly.

Best pizza and wings on the Island. Love the crest wood with sweet sauce… it reminds me of trucello’s. The wings are nice and crispy. I also recommend the garlic knots.