Fonta’s Pizza

Great food, service and local flavor. I had the calzone (greek) OTW, friendly service. Highly recommended!

Ate here the other day and can say one of the best pizza I have had in a long time. Love the fact that it is a family business.

You can’t go wrong with Fontas. Delicious pizza, spaghetti and garlic bread. This is what a pizza joint should be. Great customer service and excellent food.

Whenever I’m in Greeley I stop here to eat! Good food, good service, never had a problem. Military friendly. Will go back every time!

I have become addicted to Fontas after living here a year. I have always preferred to make my own pizza because everyone always fell short. It has been literally a decade since I actually LIKED restaurant pizza. The ingredients are fresh and top of the line. I always have a positive service experience here. The specials every day are great values. Today I took advantage of the Thursday special — BOGO HALF OFF.
All you hear at my table is «mmmmmmm».
If you don’t do anything else in Greeley, make a point of eating at Fontas at least once.
I love the Greek selection here too.

We ate here twice in our 4 day stay to the area. Easily some of the best pizza I’ve ever had while on the road. The staff was very helpful and attentive and the prices were good!

Love this place! Drive 40 min to eat here. The Greek salad is soo good and the pizza is amazing too!

I followed the other reviews and just stuck with the pizza. Meat lovers and Passion, which is their version of a Hawaiian, were both very good. Just a little bit to salty but still I would gladly order again. I was very satisfied. Although $ 20 for a large is a little steep.

Absolutely love this place, never knew about it until a friend took me there and wow, i think it is the best pizza in Greeley, even better than roma. Staff are friendly, and place is very clean. Pizza is awesome

Don’t go on a busy night to Fonta’s, as the service is just ok. You do not get refills filled as quickly or at all. The waiter/​waitress does not come back to the table at all, so you better have everything you need the first time around. The pizza is very good. The pizza’s are made very well with the crust not too hard, or over cooked. The sauce is not over spicy, or bland. The atmosphere has a lot to be updated. The booths are worn out, and springy. This is a great place to order a pizza out, not to visit.

This is a family owned restaurant. It’s nothing fancy as far as décor or atmosphere but the pizza is pretty good and we’ve always had good, friendly service.

Yum! I have only been going there for 30+ years. love the pizza, Greek salad and Calzones. Specials all week Yumm!

Hard to beat the square cut pizza. Also a must to get their famous house salad. It’s a toss up between Roma’s and Fontas for the best pizza shop in town. The bear special is a great pizza and almost better the next day. Definitely order a large or even two pizzas to have leftovers for the next day.

if you’re going to eat pizza in Greeley, why waste your time anywhere else? Get pizza made by a family business and avoid those chains that skimp on the pepperoni.
See you there!

Pulling into the packed parking lot for a Saturday night dinner, we thought we might have to wait to be seated. Not the case; plenty of tables to accommodate large diners. we were seated in minutes.
Our plain 16″ cheese pizza was delicious. Plenty of toppings available; can also order specialty pizzas from the menu.
Service was excellent; our drinks were filled promptly by our waitress. Another staff member came by and asked us if our pizza was to our liking.
Men’s restroom was clean and attended to.
We be back to dine here again. plenty of other dishes on the menu to try out!

Went for a later lunch today and had regular crust (thin) with basil pesto sauce, onions, mushrooms, and pineapple. It was not the best pizza I’ve had, but the pizza was good, the ingredients were fresh, and the service was friendly and prompt. We will definitely go here again if we are in Greeley again looking for a place to eat.

Short version — Gordon Ramsey needs to get his hands on this place!
Fonta’s does have good pizza, but if you go, stick with that and stay away from the Greek side of the menu.
I love spanikopita and ordered that. It was obviously frozen at LEAST once and re-​heated til barely warm in the microwave. I know that because I got it less than 5 minutes after I ordered. The crust was soggy and strangely tough and the filling was only ok. Then they charged an extra dollar for a couple tablespoons of tzaziki sauce. I will NEVER get spanikopita there again, especially not for $ 8.
I also ordered pizza rolls, 4 for $ 6, which is a good deal. These were much better, even though they took awhile to get out. They were topped with a ton of oregano and parmesan, which I brushed off, but the dough was good (slightly yeasty), gooey cheese and full of pepperoni. The sauce they come with… well…that was terrible. It took me forever to figure out what was wrong with it, other than being too sweet. Finally it hit me that it tastes just like the sauce in Chef Boyardee ravioli cans. There’s NO reason for a pizza joint to have bad sauce, but it must be a combination of their tomato brand and having sat cooking too long. I would smuggle in my own, next time (or just order to go).
The restaurant itself is one big room with a bunch of outdated seating and décor. It can get loud if it’s a busy time. The wait staff is pleasant, if not very fast. I had to ask for drink refills repeatedly and about the timing of my food. I wasn’t checked on after it was delivered, either. My waitress only had 5 tables with 2 – 3 people at them.
Next time: Stay on the pizza side of the menu, get the cheesesticks, which are AMAZING, and order to-​go.

Best Pizza in Greeley.

The service was friendly and attentive. The pizza was quick, hot and had lots of toppings. A nice switch from chain pizzas. Kids had a great time and left happy as did the adults.

Well, my first stop in Greeley, Colorado for food was Fonta’s. My bf’s family lives in Greeley & boasted that this pizza is fantastic: they were oh so right!
Fonta’s is a small cozy restaurant with an old time pizzeria feel. On this particular Thursday evening, the restaurant was packed with children celebrating a sports victory. They were extremely loud & running all over the restaurant, but even that didn’t phase us, as we were with family & the food was so great.
Fonta’s menu was much more than just pizza: fried zucchini, spanakopitas, wings, burgers, sandwiches, & chicken fingers. The pizza menu was extensive with a variety of specialties. We had the spanakopitas, fried zucchini (amazing!!), the house specialty pizza: beef, ham, sausage, green peppers, onions, & black & green olives & another pizza with pepperoni, sausage, & Canadian bacon. The pizza crust is thin, but a full thin: NY style. & Fonta’s doesn’t skimp on the toppings: each piece was slathered with every ingredient. & the sauce was wonderful with large tomatoes & a great flavor. The beer selection was smaller than I am used to, but for a small restaurant, pretty good with bud products, & sunshine.
Our server was wonderful: checked on is multiple times & made sure everything was great.